A warning to sellers - "Printify Choice" overrides your print provider, and you can't turn it off
The entire point of Printify was that you could choose your print provider. You could compare quality, pick the one that works for your products, and build your shop's reputation on that consistency. Their new "Printify Choice" feature breaks that promise completely. Since it was enforced on my account, my orders have been automatically rerouted to providers I didn't choose — and my customers have received multiple incorrect, and damaged orders as a result. With my chosen provider, problems were essentially zero across hundreds of orders. The toggle to disable it doesn't work. Order routing shows as "Disabled" in my settings, yet orders keep being rerouted. Weeks of support chats and five different agents have produced nothing: support confirmed misrouted orders can't be reassigned after the fact, promised supervisor follow-ups arrived late with no timeline, and the only compensation offered was an insulting $15 coupon. If you picked your print provider deliberately, know that Printify can override that choice, send your orders elsewhere, and offer no way to opt out and no recourse when a bad product reaches your customer. Factor that risk in before your reputation pays for it.