Proof PRIOR to payment!!!
Fast response and got a proof of my idea on my first email PRIOR to sending any payment! I love this company, they did our wedding coins as well 7 years ago and they are still awesome!
All About Challenge Coins (allaboutchallengecoins.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 61 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Construction & Manufacturing and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 97% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 50% of negative reviews; 4 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-10.
Fast response and got a proof of my idea on my first email PRIOR to sending any payment! I love this company, they did our wedding coins as well 7 years ago and they are still awesome!
The artists don't take initiative so you'll have to tell them what you want specifically down to the smallest detail across multiple revisions but the end product meets expectations and the prices are extremely reasonable
They work with you and respond quickly. Easy to work with and this is about my 8th coin.
So far so good, great communication. I am excited to see the end result next week.
The staff was extremely helpful, easy to communicate with, and the design artist was able to design exactly what we wanted. All of my interactions with the staff have been wonderful and positive.
Very fast and easy communication
I have been a customer since the late 1970’s. Previously I have enjoyed a positive relationship with the staff. I now suspect that relationship was based solely on my spending thousands of dollars on gold and silver coins. I recently took 3 cases of embossed bitter bottles, embossed milk bottles and green canning jars to sell to All About Coins. I had heard the president of the Utah bottle club was there and called to be sure he was in expecting a fair price. For the entire lot including Over 30 very clean bottles and one found to have a small chip he offered me $15. Yup and he held firm. I had to consider my options. I have severe diabetic neuropathy in both feet. Because of the recent construction, I had to carry the bottles three blocks in the rain. This required me to take make three trips. He made me wait about 20 minutes before coming out to make his $15 offer. I knew this was a very poor price. However I also knew I was not going be able carry the three boxes back up my car because it would require 3 more trips in the rain. I finally settled for about $30 in foreign coin. I will tell you the foreign coin section was low quality. But I picked the best I could. If you are making a purchase from All About coin. I’m sure you will be treated well. Sell something expect nothing. I will never do business with All About Coins again. Date of experience is approximate.
Hello Sir, You have left this review for the wrong company. We are are All about Challenge Coins in Winter Park, FL. No relation to the company you did business with in Salt Lake City, UT.
The list of superlatives describing the service provided by All About Coins would require more space than is available. Each phase of our project was handled as quickly and efficiently as all providers should but seldom do.
Thank you very much!
Very happy with the quality of the coins. Design and finish are excellent
Mr Wardlow, We appreciate you taking the time to give us another negative review. All reviews are evaluated and every circumstance is carefully reviewed.
Prompt and professional. The ordering process was seamless. You will receive the quote to review, then pay afterwards. I highly recommend this company.
Thank you
Customer service is excellent. Response time is quick. Smooth ordering process.
We appreciate your review, thank you
Jacob and the design team were amazing, patient, and professional. They delivered time and again, despite the several versions, tweaks, and nuances we requested, each time they were "appeared" happy to make it right. The finished product is going down range with us and we couldn't be happier. Thank you All About Challenge Coins, you have a customer for life.
Thank you
Our custom-made medals arrived today and they far exceeded our expectations. Our "designer" was amazing as we went back with multiple changes in the proof and assisted us in making it extra unique by adding the initials of our artist to the back of the medal. It is truly a legacy award that will survive for years!
We appreciate it
They were great to work with and provided me lots of options to get the metal tokens I wanted at a great price. Long time customer as they has awesome customer service and quick turn on providing proofs I can easily edit to get the perfect design to order.
We can't say thank you enough
Great customer service and always quick turnarounds. They know exactly how to put your ideas on a coin and make it look great!
Thank you
Always Great and Fast Customer Service. The products are always spot on, delivery is fast and great quality of products
Thank you
Throughout the process, I had a lot of delays. They worked with me and stayed patient, answering any questions and modifications without issues. I appreciate what they did for us.
Thank you
61 reviews matching