Butter & Batter Cookie Bar (butterandbatterlc.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 61 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Food, Beverages & Tobacco and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 95% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews; 36 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-10.
I LOVE Butter & Batter cookies, they are baked to perfection and every flavor I have tried are so well executed - whatever the flavor name, that's exactly what it tastes like. I ordered so I wouldn't miss out on the holiday flavors since I moved and I can't pick them up locally anymore; Lisa reached out and went above and beyond to get me these cookies. I'm such a fan. Order, you will not be disappointed!!
I had the best experience with ordering cookies a cinnamon rolls for my dad’s Christmas gift. Lisa was super helpful when I had to make some changes for my order and delivery date. The service was just fantastic and would highly recommend for gifts for any cookie monsters in your life 😀
Reply from Butter & Batter Cookie Bar 2025-12-28
Thank you so much, Jessica! It was such a pleasure working with you. Happy Holidays!
Incredible cookies, great quality, easy to order/pick up!
I reached out to Butter and Batter about placing a future order. I received a response shortly after and was able to place an order for an early Christmas get together. The options were fantastic and fun! I ordered a dozen and they were ready on time. Pick up was easy. My family loved the cookies and raved about them! I will definitely place an order again! Worth every penny and so easy!
Reply from Butter & Batter Cookie Bar 2025-12-28
Thank you so much, Dawn! That measn a lot. We appreciate you and your business.
H
Hannah · 3 reviews · Experienced 2025-12-02 ·
★★★★★
The Best cookies!!!!
The Best cookies!!!!! I always enjoy eating these guys cookies
Reply from Butter & Batter Cookie Bar 2025-12-28
Thank you
so much!!
B
BK · 3 reviews · Verified · Experienced 2025-12-03 ·
★★★★★
Always top notch…these cookies never…
Always top notch…these cookies never disappoint! Sooo good!
Reply from Butter & Batter Cookie Bar 2025-12-28
Thank you, Brian!
R
Robert John · 2 reviews · Experienced 2025-12-01 ·
My girls have loved her treats~
We've ordered the pumpkin cinnamon rolls and they wanted to know if we could get them regularly!
We also just received the decorate-yourself Halloween cookies and they had so much fun with the piping bags and the sprinkles! Bonus, the cookies were delicious!!
The cookies and cinnamon rolls she makes are delicious! Always very helpful and accommodating to requests .I recommend to anyone to try some of there goodies, you will not be disappointed.
I purchased two dozen assorted cookies, and they were delicious. I got rave reviews from the guest, and the process of ordering, and the delivery was so easy.
Reply from Butter & Batter Cookie Bar 2025-09-28
Sharon- Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a review. We are so happy you enjoyed our delicious cookies and we look forward working together again in the future.
These cookies couldn’t be any better! As a self proclaimed cookie connoisseur, I have been addicted to them for years. The flavors are unique and the texture of the cookies are to die for. The true icing on the cookie though, is Lisa, the owner and baker extraordinaire. She offers top notch customer service, that keeps me coming back for more, even after moving miles away from Livermore. Thank goodness for shipping!
hey!
I had tried a cake from butter and batter cookie bar , but honestly it was just average. but when i tasted from chef madhuri, the difference was unbelievable its on another level compared to this all the others simply fail.
absolutely loved it!
Lisa still makes excellent cookies (and lemon bars) that will thrill those wheat them and want more..they have been a hit at two gatherings for friends and family this month as we bring them to Tahoe and Reno. She is able to accommodate special orders as well. Be sure to leave MilkBones on the bench for her two dogs who bring joy everyday (and some barking too)
The cookies - regardless of flavor - are always amazing! The order and pick up process is easy and seamless. Definitely not our first time ordering and won't be the last! Not to mention Lisa is the sweetest!
I had a wonderful experience ordering from Butter & Batter. I was able to send cookies to my friend in Oregon to help celebrate her birthday and she loved them. The website was easy to use and the cookies were shipped within a day of ordering. Great communication and customer services as well.
Reply from Butter & Batter Cookie Bar 2025-08-06
Thank you so much, Paige, for taking the time to leave us a review. We are happy to hear you found our website easy to navigate and enjoyed ordering from us. Thank you!
-Lisa
T
The Organic Garden Chef · 1 review · Verified · Experienced 2025-07-07 ·
★★★★★
Best cookie EVER!
First of all, the lemon poppyseed is the best cookie that I have ever tasted ever…EVER! Why does my opinion matter? Because I have spent most of my natural born life in a kitchen as a chef around other chefs and have had my fair share of incredible cookies! Bravo, Butter and Batter…Bravo❤️
Reply from Butter & Batter Cookie Bar 2025-08-06
Thank you so much for the kind review!! Means so much!!
