MyComicShop (mycomicshop.com) has a 4.5 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 200 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Hobbies & Crafts and its reputation is excellent. 89% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 9% are 1 star; The business has replied to 38% of negative reviews; 9 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-11.
Over the years I have bought entire collection of groo the wander comic and numerous other comics they are highly commendable comic shop accurate grading fast shipping only ever lost one comic and they refunded me never had a problem i highly recommend my comic shop buy with confidence 😊👍
I can’t say enough good things about MyComicShop.com! From their incredible selection and the outstanding condition of the comics to the fast shipping, every part of the experience exceeded my expectations. What impressed me most was the care taken with the packaging. I ordered a four-issue series, and each comic arrived individually bagged and boarded. The entire set was then wrapped together with additional backing boards for extra protection and packed securely in a perfectly sized box, preventing any movement during shipping. It’s clear the team takes pride in making sure comics arrive exactly as collectors hope they will. Outstanding job, MyComicShop team! I’ll definitely be ordering from you again.
Warning to all high-end collectors: Be very careful doing business with MyComicShop / Lone Star Comics. This company has a recurring pattern of petty, incredibly unprofessional behavior when handling high-value transactions and customer service. First, I purchased a comic from them on eBay that arrived with undisclosed surface marks and scratches. When I initiated a completely legitimate return due to the poor condition, they reacted like children—banning me from both their eBay storefront and their independent website simply for returning a single damaged item. They clearly cannot handle basic accountability regarding their grading. Most recently, I purchased a high-value key issue (The Batman Adventures #12) and requested a cancellation within 30 minutes of placing the order. Tracking confirms the item never shipped and never even left their warehouse. Absolutely zero physical effort or logistics were expended on their end. Despite this immediate cancellation, they issued a partial refund, withholding nearly $60 of my money to cover their own backend platform fees. They essentially charged me an arbitrary 'fine' for an item that never moved. The complete lack of business common sense here is staggering. They openly advertise a 30-day return policy. If I had let them ship the book and then returned it, they would have been obligated to issue a 100% full refund and they would have had to eat the return shipping costs. By canceling within 30 minutes, I saved them the time, the shipping supplies, the insurance liability, and the hassle. Their response was to short my refund. If you are dropping serious money on key issues or premium slabs, take your business to a professional dealer who behaves like an adult. Between retaliatory bans for condition returns and stealing money via cancellation 'fees,' MyComicShop is a pitiful operation. I highly recommend avoiding this storefront entirely And wow, I thought I was the only one I had didn’t realize that this guy’s ratings were so low that says a lot
One of the best ways to order my books online. Fair shipping, good prices.
I paid for a comic and received a damaged item with scratches, marks, and defects. That alone is bad enough. Instead of making it right, they blocked me and basically made it clear they do not want to deal with customers who push back when they receive damaged merchandise. That is not good customer service. That is not accountability. If you sell collectibles, condition matters. When the item arrives messed up, the buyer should not be treated like the problem for disputing it. My experience was terrible, and I would not trust this company again. And the cleanest way to say the chargeback point is this: A return is sending the item back through the seller or platform. A chargeback is disputing the payment through your card issuer when the seller/platform does not properly resolve the issue. So no, “item arrived damaged and I disputed it” is not automatically wrong. The safer wording for your review is to focus on this: the item arrived damaged, the issue was not resolved to your satisfaction, and they blocked you afterward.
This is my honest review for MyComicShop as a 1st time seller. I chose to sell on consignment with them because they allow comics to be sold that Ebay will not (adult related) Since it is my 1st submission with them I only sent 5 books to test how the process will go. MyComicShop confirmed receipt on Nov 12. They have noted on site that the process can take up to 15 days to grade, scan and file submissions before they will be available for sale. I knew this before I sent the books and was cool with it as I wanted to have them in the Dec 15th auction. (that should give me a 30+ day cushion before the auction to allow processing my books) I waited 20 days and they were still not ready but I searched for my books on their site and noticed that they had been scanned and graded. What exactly does "filing" mean anyways and should it take longer than a day to file 5 books? No problem, I'll give them another week. Well the Dec 15th auction is now passed and I missed it and my books are still being "filed" and not ready to sell after 30+ days. Yes, I have inquired with the response being the generic excuse of holiday delays and short staff. So what exactly is "filing" and why does it take so long? My books have been graded and scanned for awhile now. I was told a 15 day process once you received my books and that is what I expected and clearly that has not been held up on your end. And the "holiday short staff" excuse does not sit well with a company that claims to be "professional". Professional companies usually hire more help for the holidays am I right?
Hi, thank you for leaving your feedback. I'm sorry that we didn't have your books processed as quickly as you needed. You are correct that our website language was not accurate for your books. We looked into it, and the main reason these took longer than usual is that some of the books you submitted were variants (Kickstarter editions, etc) that we did not already have set up in our catalog. Processing items that aren't already set up in our catalog takes us more time than comics that we already have fully set up. We apologize for the delay you experienced, and we've updated our website language to more accurately reflect what processing time to expect. Our website now states: "Most consignments will be processed within about 15 days from the date that your comics arrive at our office, although any issues that were not already listed in our database will require additional setup time and may take closer to 30 days. We don't guarantee a specific completion date, so if tight deadlines are a concern, please ship as early as possible, and get in touch with us to discuss what you need." Thanks for bringing this to our attention and apologies again for the slower turnaround than you were led to believe.
Always good product but very poor customer service. I have spent thousands over the years and they could not split up an order onto different cards of over 50+ books. They wanted to cancel and make me do it again which would add to shipping. That's just poor service. I will no longer order from them and they lost a customer they had for years.
I've order from MyComicshop about 10+ times. Each time the orders have been shipped within 24 hours. I do find that they under grade. I purchased a Strange Adventures 1. They had it rated as a 4.0. Sent it to CGC and got a 5.5. I find to be safe they seem to grade books 1.0 or .5 lower than what the books are. They are my number one place for Silver and Gold books
Shockingly bad. Use PayPal and they take your money but no order made and blame PayPal for their crap website. You have been warned. Do not buy here
Might be a fake labubu but I already spend my $59….mistakes were made and thx for successfully scamming I think if you did shame on you Bubu Gift 😡 Sorry in advance if your labubus are real🙏🏽
Hi, this review seems to be regarding some other business. We don't know what labubus are or what "bubu gift" means. We sell comic books, magazines, and books.
The comics are in a good shape but the shipping is way too overpriced and it is always delayed for 2-3 days. If you contact the customer service you just get a rude answer back.
I’ve been a customer for quite awhile now and I’ve never had any problems. Prices are (they don’t pull the jacked up price then offer you a discount scam) always fair with plenty of condition options. Grading is always spot on and the packaging is top notch. Love these guys!
They refunded my money stating they didn't have my product that I wanted which online stated in stock. 4 days later they take out double the amount of money and claim its in the post, I never authorised the additional transaction as I have found another vendor for said comic. This business is obviously doing some illegal stuff with unauthorised transactions after cancelling & refunding the original order. Not recommended
Hey man, these guys are good i got comics from the before and they are excellent at what they do. So, don't listen to those 1 star reviews and give these guys a chance.
Very positive experience with this store. I purchased a couple of books from them, and took part in one of their auctions too. Everything went quite smoothly. They also have helpful and accommodating customer support. Definitely recommended.
After reading some of the reviews I was a little sceptical. I ordered a stack of Divine Right comics that I was struggling to get, all the way to NZ. Holy crap each one of them arrived sealed and you can tell they had received TLC. Wait time for the postal was a bit but expected due to my country. Have already ordered the rest + Justice League Infinity comics. Will be making more purchases in the future.
Ok so first of all if everyone will take a look at the people who have left positive reviews you will notice that many have only wrote reviews for mycomicshop and many of them multiple times and they're all about generic experiences lol. So I've just had some comics graded by them and most of those comics were brand new still in the unopened box that they shipped in 30 years ago and just received the most ridiculous counter offer so ill be calling them tomorrow and most likely flying out there to pick them up
They will rip u off big time. Sold them comics that were near mint, read once & been in a back & bag since then. They come back with a good condition, basically if it was just laying around with creases and bends, marks, whatever else they decide to make up. I needed the money & u have to pay for them to ship it back, so it would have cost me money, but they did that for nearly every one. I know condition & they were just lying thier asses off. Doesn't matter if it's in perfect condition they will make $h*t up & say it's in bad shape. Low balling douchebags. Sell anywhere else.
Hi, I requested more information from you through TrustPilot so I could verify you had a transaction with us and review the details, since I'm not able to find any activity under the name listed with your review. I didn't get any response to that so I don't have any info to go on. We are strict graders, and many people selling comics do not grade as strictly as we do. Whatever grade we report to a seller when buying a comic is the same grade we list the comic at when we post it for sale. We buy hundreds of thousands of comics a year, from thousands of different sellers, and have been doing so since 1999 online and another 20+ years as a physical comic book store before that. We would not be as successful as we are if we lied about condition as you described. I'm sorry you weren't happy with the grades we assigned your comics and hope you found a different buyer who was willing to pay more for your comics than we would. You can find more feedback from many comic sellers happy with our service at https://www.mycomicshop.com/feedback
WARNING: I WOULD ADVISE ALL INTERNATIONAL CUSTOMERS NOT TO ORDER FROM MYCOMICSHOP. At the moment, I'm still waiting for the "customer service" person to find out why a shipment has gone missing (no tracking for nearly three weeks). They are trying to blame it on tracking in my country, but...the package went missing in the US. So far, no replacements, no refund...
I absolutely love my comic shop! I order ASM Annual #1 this past Thursday and it was delivered today, Saturday! Packaging was great to! And I think they’re grading is great! If anything, I think they undergrads...mine was listed as 1.0 but I have no doubt in my mind it’s at LEAST a 1.5-1.8...hell possibly even a 2.0! Keep up what you guys are doing! And forget these negative feedbacks! People are to damn sensitive and whiny now a days it’s pretty sad. Thank you guys so much I will definitely be doing business with you again!
200 reviews matching