Glad to support a local company
They had what we were looking for and delivered in a timely manner. I'd definitely purchase from them again.
Thank you for the support, Leah!
Paradise Tackle Co • Mahi Maniacs (paradisetackle.com) has a 4.7 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 61 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Hobbies & Crafts and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 91% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 75% of negative reviews; 27 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-10.
They had what we were looking for and delivered in a timely manner. I'd definitely purchase from them again.
Thank you for the support, Leah!
Had excellent experience with these guys. Ordered a few lures and I had them sent them to the wrong address on accident. As soon as I placed the order I realized the error, I sent an email immediately to make them aware. By the time they responded back to me they had already shipped my package and couldn't change the shipping address. So instead what they did was sent me my same order to the correct address and took my word for it that I'd return the other shipment when I returned home. Class act. Would 100% recommend. Plus the lures are top tier
Great prices, fast shipping!
Thank you!
Great experience. Product arrived just as described and was shipped quickly and without any issues. Very happy and will definitely order again from them! And got a bonus sticker from them as well.
We are very thankful for your 5 star review! We are glad you are happy with the products and services! We hope to see you around again soon! Enjoy the sticker! Tight lines, Zac
Easy to navigate, great selection, great products, prompt delivery
Thank you very much for your kind review! We appreciate your business and hope to see you again soon! Tight Lines, Zac
Quick and prompt service. Only draw back was the cost of each lure.
Hello, Thank you for your feedback. We understand that price is an important factor when making a purchase. The product you purchased was an Islamorada Flyer, which is a premium lure manufactured by another company. Our price for the rigged version is actually lower than the manufacturer's direct retail price. While we strive to keep our prices as competitive as possible, we do not control the pricing of products produced by other manufacturers. We also offer a variety of more budget-friendly lure options on our website to accommodate different budgets. We appreciate your business and hope you'll give us another opportunity to serve you in the future. Best regards, Paradise Tackle Co.
Purchase was straight forward but really like the Mylar insert , they were fantastic on Marlin , sailfish ,and wahoo ,(with horse ballyhoo ) down in Cabo this spring .
Thanks for the great review! We cannot wait to see what you catch with the lures! Tight lines, Paradise Tackle Co
I ordered this sweatshirt for a Christmas gift on 12/15/25. I never heard a word from the company and assumed they had for some reason canceled my order. The sweatshirt was delivered the end of May 2026. A little bit late for a Christmas gift. Jennifer Martin
Hello Jennifer, We sincerely apologize for the lengthy delay in shipping your order. We experienced an unexpected health issue that temporarily impacted our printing operations. While we worked through the situation as, we recognize that our communication during that time fell short, and for that we apologize as well. We value your business and want to ensure you are completely satisfied with your purchase. If you have any concerns about the item or the experience, please don't hesitate to reach out. We are committed to making things right and will do our best to resolve any issues promptly. Thank you for your patience and understanding.
He didn’t have the equipment I wanted, but he made good. I’m providing replacement.
We apologize that the manufacturer discontinued the original item. To make things right, we offered you the choice of a full refund or replacement reels. You chose the replacement option, and we provided two reels with a combined retail value of approximately $180 in exchange for a reel that you originally purchased for $89. In addition, both replacement reels were thoroughly cleaned and serviced prior to shipment at no additional cost. Our goal was to provide a solution that exceeded the value of the original purchase and demonstrated our commitment to customer service. While we understand that not every situation ends perfectly, we are disappointed that our efforts resulted in a 3-star review, especially after providing options and absorbing over a $50 loss on the transaction to ensure you received more value than your original purchase to make up for it. In addition, a previous 1-star review. Regardless, we appreciate your business and hope you enjoy the free reel.
You sent your product on time and it looks great ! Thanks
I ordered a reel and after one weeK I called and sent emails to the company did not respond.
good looking lures , fast shipping, will do business again.
You sell a very good product that produces results. I will use your products a lot.
Thank you for your generous review! We are glad you like our products! We hope to see you around again soon! Tight lines! -Zac
Ease of purchase online, wide variety, and super rapid delivery!!!
Thank you for your excellent review! We greatly appreciate your kind words! Hope to see you again soon! Tight lines, Zac
Products seem well made. Shipping was super fast. Nice variety of colors. Will be ordering more from them soon!
Thank you for the kind review, Timothy! I am glad you like our quality and service! Tight lines, Zac
Great, quick service.
Thank you for your excellent review! Tight lines! -Zac
Quick efficient. Good guys
Thank you!
I had an excellent experience with Paradise Tackle Co.. From start to finish, everything about this company reflects quality and professionalism. I had the opportunity to speak with Zack, and he was incredibly helpful. He took the time to understand exactly what I was looking for and guided me toward the right purchase without any pressure. His knowledge and willingness to help made the entire process smooth and enjoyable. Paradise Tackle Co. offers an impressive selection of fishing lures, with options that clearly cater to both experienced anglers and those just getting started. You can tell they stand behind their products and truly care about their customers. If you’re looking for reliable gear and top-tier customer service, I would highly recommend Paradise Tackle Co. I’ll definitely be coming back for future purchases.
Thank you for the excellent review Tim. I really appreciate the time you spent writing the review. It was a pleasure speaking with you earlier, I enjoyed it as much as you did. I am looking forward to meeting you when you're down! Tight lines! -Zac
Fair price, packaged well.
Thank you for the 5-star review! Glad you are happy with our pricing and packing. Hope to see you again soon! Tight lines, Zac
Outstanding Customer Service. Quick Turning an order request. Appreciate the Support!
Thank you for the kind review, Ronald. It's an honor having you trust us for your tackle needs and a pleasure getting your order out the door! We hope to see you around again soon! Tight lines, Zac
61 reviews matching