Sanibel Island Vacations offers over 80 quality condos and houses on Sanibel Island. Our team of Certified Guest Service Professionals are knowledgeable about local regulations for the rental community and very familiar with homes and condominiums on the Island. Our goal is to make every island vacation so incredibly special, it will not be forgotten. With a nearly 100% satisfaction rate, we are dedicated to exceeding expectations and are available to answer questions and guide you to the perfect vacation rental. And, if you can’t find what you’re looking for in our inventory, we will work to find it for you! Island Vacations has extensive local knowledge & relationships with other Sanibel accommodation providers and for no additional fee, our team will work to find your vacation rental. The reservation is made through us so you can rest assured you will receive the quality care and attention we’ve been providing guests with for over 20 years. Contact us and let us do the searching so you can start packing your bags and focus on the important stuff like what flip flops to wear!
Written by the business, not verified by us.
Is Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva legit?
Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva (sanibelislandvacations.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 102 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Travel & Vacation and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 96% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has not yet replied to negative reviews; 1 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-09-03.
The experience with the company was a mixture. The reps were pleasant to speak with but unaware of certain things. Where we stayed at Compass Point #163 had many things that needed repairing. The coffee pot was rusty and took 2 days to get a new one. The ceiling fan on the patio was rusty and sounded like it wanted to come off the ceiling and you had to turn it with something in order to start it as the pull chain is gone. We were also told several times with me calling that we could park ANYWHERE we wanted and come to find out we could not after we were blocked in by an owner of one of the condos. The bed in the master bedroom sank in the middle, the daybed in the extra room was too bouncy and noisy. Closet doors for washing machine and dryer was not a good fit as you had to put your clothes from the wash on top of the dryer and then move the door to put the clothes in the dryer. The tile floors were very slippery and an accident waiting to happen, we slipt so many times, had to put towels down just to make it safer.
Very helpful and Personable staff. Easy to contact staff by phone which I appreciate. Loved the Condo which was well appointed and comfortable. Would love to return to Sanibel again in the near future
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-09-21
And we'd love to have you back for another fabulous stay! Please let us know when you are ready.
Thank you for the seamless pick up and drop off. It was a pleasure going to your site for our vacation needs! We look forward to making future reservations with you all.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-09-21
This is our second time to stay with y’all and as the last time it was absolutely fabulous you make it very easy for your tenants to enjoy their vacation
I’ve had wonderful customer experience booking through Island Vacation Rentals, the staff is always friendly and help in anyway they can. Our rental for the week on Sanibel Island is clean, has a wonderful view, and we are looking forward to a return visit next year. I highly recommend Island Vacation Rentals I’ve never had a a bad experience.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-09-21
We appreciate your feedback Christine. See you next year!
This rental process was so easy. The unit, Compass Pointe #182 could not have been better. We are frequent vacationers on Sanibel, but this was our first time using Island Vacation of Sanibel and staying at Compass Pointe. We will definitely return to both! Thank you!
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-09-21
We strive to make your vacation hassle free so you can experience the serenity that comes with Sanibel. Thank you fo allowing us to show you the best of both worlds!
We definitely recommend Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva. We are a family with three children who stayed at a beautiful rental home. We absolutely enjoyed our summer vacations. The staff were professional and helpful. We are very grateful.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-09-21
We are here to make your Sanibel family vacations all that you desire. You picked the best place to experience summer with children. We're sure their memories will be fond and forever cherished. Please let us know when you're ready to return.
We had a wonderful time this year staying at the house. It was absolutely perfect and beautiful. We didn't need to really by to much stuff, they had everything in the house. All the people who came to maintain the home were very respectful and did a great job.
What a great place to spend a week on the Gulf of Mexico. A view of the water and a short walk to the beach. The place was clean and had many things you wouldn't expect for a rental. Will look forward to returning in the future.
We have almost always used Island Vacations for our many stays on Sanibel throughout the years. I have never had any problems and everyone is kind, courteous, professional and friendly.
The folks at Island Vacations are simply the best! Efficient, responsive and SUPER friendly! We’ve enjoyed 3 stays with the this year, with a 4th scheduled in October. Our July/August trip requires some logistical gymnastics as we have family coming and going at different times. The Island Vacation folks couldn’t have been more accommodating! We’re looking forward to our next visit in October!
This is our second year with Island Vacations and fourth year on Sanibel. They provide exceptional personalized customer service. They are very responsive to your needs while on island. Our house needs some TLC and they were quick to respond to our needs.
Colby & Conrad
Luxury Travel Connection
PawClear
DriftHaus Travel
Marketplace Bookings, INC
CasaVoya
Alstanvygetaways
Tucasa