Sanibel Island Vacations offers over 80 quality condos and houses on Sanibel Island. Our team of Certified Guest Service Professionals are knowledgeable about local regulations for the rental community and very familiar with homes and condominiums on the Island. Our goal is to make every island vacation so incredibly special, it will not be forgotten. With a nearly 100% satisfaction rate, we are dedicated to exceeding expectations and are available to answer questions and guide you to the perfect vacation rental. And, if you can’t find what you’re looking for in our inventory, we will work to find it for you! Island Vacations has extensive local knowledge & relationships with other Sanibel accommodation providers and for no additional fee, our team will work to find your vacation rental. The reservation is made through us so you can rest assured you will receive the quality care and attention we’ve been providing guests with for over 20 years. Contact us and let us do the searching so you can start packing your bags and focus on the important stuff like what flip flops to wear!
Written by the business, not verified by us.
Is Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva legit?
Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva (sanibelislandvacations.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 102 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Travel & Vacation and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 96% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has not yet replied to negative reviews; 1 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-09-03.
Our experience with Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva was A+
Our experience with Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva was excellent. All inquiries were answered promptly after the initial booking. Their communication was very thorough, providing great information about the area, things to do, where to shop for essentials & other, etc. We needed baby items that we didn't want to pack and they provided a rental option through a local vendor. The condo was clean and in good condition, and they left a binder with every type of information that might be needed for the stay. They even called mid-week to "check in" and make sure our stay was what we expected and to see if anything was needed.
Property was exactly what we expected with little amenities like toilet paper, tissues and paper towels that made it easy when you first arrive. Staff was helpful and communications was great. I would definitely book a property through Island Vacations again.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
Compass Point is a wonderful complex and our team of local experts is always happy to accommodate our guests needs! Please let us know when you are ready to return.
Condo was beautiful and well appointed. View from the condo was breathtaking.
Staff very responsive and polite. Would highly recommend.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
5-star reviews reassure us that our efforts are paying off! Thanks so much for the feedback. Our future guests appreciate it as well. We can't wait for your next stay with us!
I’ve been using Island Vacations for several years now and I wouldn’t use anyone else. The staff is always so helpful and nice. They work hard to make your visit wonderful and are always a pleasure to work with - I couldn’t trust my vacation plans with anyone else.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
We love how much you love and trust us Melissa! Please let us know when you're ready to return so we can help you with your next vacation on Sanibel!
The office staff is always pleasant, helpful, and willing to accommodate special requests.
Service repair quickly responded.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
Thank you Roger! We're glad you alerted us of the need for service during your stay so we could address it for you. We appreciate your business and look forward to your next visit!
Staff was very helpful. property well kept. great community
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
We agree Pointe Santo is a wonderful community and are thrilled you were pleased with our staff. We will share your feedback with our housekeeping team and look forward to your return!
The staff of Island Vacations treated us like VIPs before we arrived at our VRBO, when we arrived and then when it was time to check out. They even loaned us a couple of beach towels so we could get in the water before the condo was clean. Thanks for everything!
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
Our staff of Certified Guest Service Professionals is always ready to make your stay comfortable and aims to exceed expectations. We hope that you will consider booking directly next visit so we can save you time and money and deliver the same great experience. Please call us when you are ready to return! (888) 451-7277 or https://www.sanibelislandvacations.com/
The condo was amazing !! All of the girls at island vacations was amazing. Well definitely be back !! The shelling was a plus 🐚☺️
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
Point Santo B33 is a great property and we love that you loved it! We hope that you will think of the wonderful times you had while staying with us when you look at your sanibel souvenirs (seashells) and give us a call when you are ready to return for more!
Check in process was well organized for late arrival. However on the last day in the condo I could not reach anyone in the office for a couple questions I had.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
Thanks for sharing your experience. We did notice that your reservation folio was noted that CenturyLink service was out, Island wide, for 4-5 hours on the Friday before you checked out and as a result, we couldn’t receive calls, make calls, or forward the phones. This is one of the sacrifices that comes along with many perks of vacationing on a barrier island in paradise. We hope you understand and will visit us again in the near future!
Thank you for the excellent service provided by Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva. The rental home was better than expected. We had an issue with the HVAC during our stay which was corrected within three hours of our reporting the issue to the rental agency. We plan to use this service again.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
We can't fix issues we don't know about so we appreciate you informing us of the HVAC concern while you were with us! Our team is always ready to solve any problems that might arise! We will work to find you the perfect spot for your next stay and look forward to hearing from you when you are ready to return!
Island Vacations is amazingly accommodating and Sanibel is always a wonderful week. So its a win win and stress free. Beth, Fran, Paige and the other employees are always friendly and answer any questions we have. Also the check in after hours is so easy. I have used Island Vacations ever since I came to this paradise. Will always use them and definately recommend Island Vacations.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
Thank you for the incredible feedback Cynthia! Your comments are everything we have worked so hard to ensure we deliver over the years and look forward to raising the bar each visit. Let us know when the sunshine and seashells are calling your name so we can help you return!
Amazing vacation experience for our family of 4. Fabulous location and te unit had everything we needed to prep breakfast and lunch. Check in and out were convenient and the management staff was very responsive when we had questions. We would definitely stay here again!!
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
And we hope you will stay with us again Liza! White Sands is just one of many properties our guests can experience and we encourage you to come back for more! The sun, seashells and smiles await your return!
Loved everything !! staff was the best !! you won't go wrong with Island Vacations !!
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
We agree our staff of locals is the very best and appreciate the referral to your friends who have booked with us for a stay! Your kind gesture to leave the next guests your unopened purchases was very kind and much appreciated by all! Cheers from Sanibel!
Island vacation rentals was great. I reserved two condos and had to cancel one of them. I had an issue with the cancellation fee but Fran from Island Vacation Rentals helped me resolve the issue. Would definitely use again.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
Thanks for the time you put in to communicate with us Elizabeth! We're glad we were able to resolve your cancelation fee mix-up and are appreciative of the edit you posted to share your experience with other guests!
The service we received was excellent. Anytime I had questions, they were answered quickly. The condo was perfect. Very nice and the view of the beach was stunning. We've already made arrangements to return next her to the same condo.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
We're so glad you had a wonderful experience and have rolled over for next year! We can't wait to welcome you back to your home away from home in paradise!
We are repeat users of Island Vacations and couldn't be happier. We just returned from another successful trip to Sanibel and, as usual, had a flawless rental. The staff are very friendly and accommodating and always make us feel welcome. My family and I highly recommend them and will continue to use them in the future.
Reply from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva2022-06-23
You're too kind Tom. We love accommodating your family and look forward to your time on Sanibel each year. Thanks so much for the kind words and for taking the time to share them with future guests!
Colby & Conrad
Luxury Travel Connection
PawClear
DriftHaus Travel
Marketplace Bookings, INC
CasaVoya
Alstanvygetaways
Tucasa