Teddy Baldassarre (teddybaldassarre.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 102 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 98% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
What people say
S
Scott Blackford · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
Satisfied first time customer
Teddy’s You Tube videos taught me most of what I know about watches. His internet Team have been on the ball and timely with communication before, during, and after the sale. I purchased the S.A.R rescue timer, blue dial on bracelet. I will not hesitate to buy from Teddy again.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-13
Hey Scott,
Thank you for trusting Teddy with your first purchase. It means a lot that the content helped guide your watch journey. We look forward to assisting you again in the future!
T
Tim · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
This is now my fifth watch purchase…
This is now my fifth watch purchase from TEDDY and as usual it was a great process. The team reached out before shipping and after to make sure everything was going as planned. Will also reached out after delivery to make sure I was enjoying the watch. The Longines Blue HQ is awesome. The dial is really nice and the Longines quality really shines through.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-14
Hey Tim,
Reviews like this mean a lot to the entire team!
Thank you for continuing to choose Teddy, and for highlighting the follow-up from Will and the rest of the team. We hope the Blue HQ continues to impress every time you put it on.
D
Daniel Moon · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-08 ·
★★★★★
A trusted brand that lived up to my…
A trusted brand that lived up to my expectations! Seamless buying and delivery process. Will definitely check them first for my next watch!
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-13
That trust means a lot to us, Daniel.
We’re glad the buying and delivery process lived up to your expectations, and we’ll be happy to help with the next watch when the time comes!
K
KYLE SAVAGE · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-06 ·
★★★★★
A no-brainer
Great price, great selection, great customer service, quick shipping, great experience overall.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-13
Hey Kyle,
We appreciate the kind words! Thanks for supporting and choosing Teddy!
Awesome experience buying an Alpinist. Chat support specialist was helpful, heard out my questions, fast response, quick shipping. Zero complaints.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-14
It is great to know the experience lived up to your expectations, Rusty.
We appreciate you recognizing our chat support team, and we're glad everything from communication to shipping went smoothly. Enjoy your new Alpinist!
J
Joshua Fu · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-09 ·
★★★★★
Easy transaction and super quick…
Easy transaction and super quick delivery! Thank you!
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-14
We appreciate you taking the time to leave a review, Joshua. It's great to hear the process was straightforward and your watch arrived quickly. Enjoy it, and thank you for choosing Teddy!
The shopping on line is easy to move around and find the Watches. Buying was simple and quick. Customer service is Friendly and always egar to help. Finally shipping was quick and timely. Would definitely and have recommended Teddybaldassarre.com to anyone wanting a watch.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Hey Tonya,
We appreciate the recommendation. It means a lot to know the website, customer service and delivery all made the process easy. Thanks for the support!
R
Ryan Johnson · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-06 ·
★★★★★
Excellent service to go with great watches.
The watch I wanted needed some email correspondence and our back and forth getting all the details straight took maybe 15 minutes for 4-5 emails. I paid on Monday and my new watch was on my wrist on Friday. Excellent service from the team and I couldn’t be happier with the new addition to my little collection. Thanks everyone!
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Hey Ryan,
A new piece joining the collection always feels better when the process is that easy. Thank you for choosing Teddy, and we’re glad the team helped make it smooth.
K
Karl · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-09 ·
★★★★★
Where Passion for Horology Meets Exceptional Service
I’ve now purchased five watches from Teddy, and every experience has reinforced why I keep coming back.
Before every purchase, I take the time to speak with the team, and I’m consistently impressed by how knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely passionate they are about horology. They don’t just process an order—they help you make the right decision for your collection.
My latest purchase, the Seiko SRPM19 5 Sports Rowing Blazers x Worn & Wound Vintage Limited Edition (42mm Blue), was a perfect example. I was fortunate enough to secure one, placed my order at 11:00 a.m. on Thursday, and it was on my wrist in New Jersey just 48 hours later. That’s remarkable service for such a sought-after limited edition.
What Teddy has built is truly world-class. His ability to educate, entertain, and inspire watch enthusiasts through his content is unmatched, and his company delivers that same level of excellence through its customer service, shipping, and overall buying experience. It’s rare to find an organization where the founder’s passion is so clearly reflected in every customer interaction.
Thank you to Teddy and the entire team for continuing to raise the bar. I’ll proudly continue supporting the business, growing my collection, and learning from one of the very best voices in modern watchmaking.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-13
Hey Karl,
This is an incredible note to receive for the entire team! Five watches is a level of trust we do not take lightly. We’re grateful that the team’s knowledge has continued to make each experience worth coming back for. Thank you for supporting Teddy.
J
July Sanchez · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-08 ·
★★★★★
Great Experience & Great Price
I’m just getting into watches and I found Teddy Baldassarre on YouTube. His videos were informative and engaging. When it came time to purchase my watch I was excited to learn I could buy directly from his website, which also had the best price! I ended up purchasing two Seiko watches. They arrived super fast and I absolutely adore them.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Hey July,
We're happy to know you've been enjoying the content, and that it has been helpful for your watch buying journey. Thanks for sharing!
C
Chad Nicolardi · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-04 ·
★★★★★
My overall experience was excellent
My overall experience was excellent and I would definitely recommend doing business with this company. I made a mistake when ordering and Andrew bent over backwards to fix my mistake. The customer service is top notch.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Hey Chad,
Andrew will appreciate the recognition here. Thank you for giving us the chance to help fix the order, and we’re glad the experience ended on such a positive note.
B
Brett · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
Top notch
Good price, fast shipping and delivery and everything came as advertised.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Hey Brett,
We're glad to hear that you had a positive experience. Thanks for the support.
I just received my first watch from Teddy Baldassarre and it was a first class experience. I was able to easily place the order online and the access to a substantial amount of Teddy’s YouTube information assured me that my Hamilton was a wise purchase. Also, Andrew Rovinsky, Customer Success Manager, was extremely helpful correcting a shipping mistake that I make when I ordered the watch, one that would have caused substantial delivery delays. I’ve ordered watches from other companies and can say that purchasing from Teddy was indeed the best experience. I love the watch and will definitely purchase more watches from Teddy in the future.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
That is the kind of first experience we hope to deliver, Noel.
Thank you for choosing Teddy for your Hamilton. We’re glad the videos and Andrew’s support helped make the purchase feel easy.
M
MK S · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
Seiko's King Turtle: Trepidatious to Thrilled (Thanks Kara & Teddy)
I purchased Seiko's King Turtle with the olive dial and dark olive rubber strap with some trepidation. Teddy's video review on the newest iteration convinced me I would likely like it. It arrived (3) days after working with Kara, who is always a pleasure to work with), and was shocked at how much more striking it is in person. And, that rubber strap is no slouch. It's more comfortable than any other rubber strap I've worn, and the waves molded into it near the lugs adds to its beauty. I'm thrilled with the piece. I can't recommend Teddy Baldassarre and his staff highly enough. His online store runs like a well-oiled machine and every item I've ordered so far is very well packaged with quality in mind.
Thank you!
Matthew
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Matthew, this is a great note to read. We’re glad Teddy’s review helped you feel confident in the King Turtle and that it made an even stronger impression once it arrived. Kara will appreciate the kind words, and we’re happy the experience continues to feel so consistently positive!
J
James Engel · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-07 ·
★★★★★
I recently made another purchase from…
I recently made another purchase from Teddy Baldassarre, and as usual, it was a great experience. The team helped me choose my watch, and the shipping was very fast. My watch arrived in perfect condition. I highly recommend Teddy Baldassarre for great watches, thanks again
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Hey James,
Thanks for taking the time to share this experience and recommendation. We appreciate the support more than you know!
N
Nick Cassout · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
Easy to be Specific
Having all the watches in one place made it easy to put in filters and find the perfect watch for me. The pics and all the specifications match perfectly.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Hey Nick,
It's great to hear that you found it easy to find the watch you wanted with us. We look forward to helping you again in the future!
L
Luis Fernandez · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
Great watch
Great watch, quick shipping. Will definitely buy again from Teddy.
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-12
Hey Luis,
We're honored to have earned your trust for future purchases. Thanks for choosing Teddy!
V
VICTOR BORME · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-09 ·
★★★★★
Customer Satisfaction is #1
I ordered a watch from teddybaldassarre.com but had to reroute the UPS delivery to a UPS-store for pick up as the delivery date fell on the second day of my 2 week vacation. Unfortunately UPS returned the watch to teddybaldassarre.com after just one week, before I could go and pick up the watch.
I contacted teddybaldassarre.com requesting a refund and offering to pay for the shipment, because the error was my fault. They promptly approved the full refund and declined my offer to pay the shipping, choosing to cover the shipping themselves. This is a great testament to their commitment to customer satisfaction!! They didn't need to do that.
While I didn't decide to keep the watch, I'm certainly sold on placing my next watch purchase with teddybaldassarre.com ... I can feel very comfortable and assured that my shopping experience will be great!
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-10
Hey Victor,
Thank you for giving the team the chance to work through this with you. We’re glad the resolution helped you feel confident in Teddy for a future purchase.
T
Thomas · 9 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-08 ·
★★★★★
speedy delivery to Belgium
speedy delivery to Belgium. Nice Brew watch. Luxury feeling!
Reply from Teddy Baldassarre2026-07-10
Hey Thomas,
We're glad to know the watch arrived quickly! Thanks for the review and the support.
