Wild Idea Buffalo Co (wildideabuffalo.com) has a 4.8 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 61 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Food, Beverages & Tobacco and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 92% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
What people say
E
ELIZABETH · 6 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Buffalo/Bison is wonderful
Bufffalo/Bison is more tender than beef and provides a wonderful alternative to beef, which is under fire due to deforestation and the making of grasslands for them. Buffalo/Bison just wander and do not overgraze and don't need to be fed. I love everything at this on line store, and very thankful it is delivered to my door. It is funny, but I got onto this also for my kitty who is suffering from IBS and was skin and bones. She can only eat one kind of sensitivity canned cat food, but chows down on this Bison. She is now big and fluffy and very spoiled. It is so great to enjoy something without all the guilt. Thank you very much for this wonderful product. My kitty and I are very thankful. I will order all the time. Those steak strip snacks are a killer!!!!
L
Lewis LaCroix · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Ground Italian sausage
Good,expensive shipping
M
Marilyn Jones · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Wild Idea Buffalo is a Very Good Idea
This product is delivered quickly, safely and solidly frozen, well packaged. Finally, a red meat product that you can trust - the treatment of these animals is essential to the quality of the meat. The recipes available online show how you can integrate buffalo into your old family recipes, with good spicing and marinating suggestions. I bought the January special as a gift for my son and his family. Its a gift of better health.
S
Susan · 4 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Best ever
After reading "Buffalo For the Broken Heart," and learning how the bison are killed (not in a slaughterhouse), decided to try, because that's my main issue with eating meat - the horrible conditions of the slaughterhouses.
Well, yum. The best buffalo I've had (and buffalo is what we eat for red meat). It arrived perfectly frozen; it was tender and juicy and sweet. These were the 5 oz. sirloin tenderloins, and I'll come back for more. The perfect size and the flavor is outstanding. So happy to have discovered Wild Idea.
r
ramesh manglani · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Great food, great company
Ordering is simple, and I believe in the company's vision.
E
Edgar Solis · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Delicious meat, quality customer service.
I placed my first order. Great quality bison meat products. Love the hot dogs, much more flavor that the ones sold at Whole Foods. Quick delivery and great service. Good job with your recipes. I will be trying them starting this week.
I will be placing another order as soon as I am out of bison.
Thank You!
D
Denise Burnside · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Best of the best
In the super early 2000's, while traveling across Wyoming on a motorcycle, I picked up a paperback book at a local hotel. Something I often do when traveling.
The book was "Buffalo for the Broken Heart", by Dan O'Brien. It was a good read and told a good story.
Turns out, the author of this book is the Wild Idea guy and we share similar philosophies on sustainability and other things.
I've been buying meat from Wild Idea ever since.
I pay a little bit more for buffalo than I do for beef.
I pay a little bit more for Wild Idea buffalo than I do for buffalo at the local grocer (when I find it consistently).
But, what I rest assured in, is the philosophy of Wild Idea. And that, to me, is a component of me doing my part as a steward of the Earth.
And Wild Idea buffalo is excellent in flavor, much richer in color than mass produced buffalo.
I'm a repeat customer and intend to remain so - I've got 42 pounds of it in the freezer right now!
d
donald tomer · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
yummy!
A job well done in every aspect.
J
Josh · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Awesome So Far
I have only had time to fix the hot dogs but so far I am very very impressed! Shipping was quick and everything was still frozen when it arrived.
R
Rebecca Hanson · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Just great healthy meat
It came shipped with ice. Still completely frozen. Amazing because I was at work all day.
I got ground beef, organ meat, and some type of steak I can't remember. I bought this because I took a blood Serotype test and my type handles bison better than beef.
I don't even miss the beef. I'm really enjoying it. It just feels healthy going down. Enriching. And I feel happy I'm contributing to the highest ethical practices.
F
Freddie · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
satisfied
Spoke with Cori on the phone.She was very helpful in helping answer my questions and getting my order together.Will gladly order from this company again.
J
Jeffrey S Geer · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
will be ordering again
From speed of shipping and the product itself everything is five stars.
K
Kathy Burnside · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Excellent product, excellent service!
Ordered the starter bundle package. Knew from the time that I placed my order when I would receive it via FedX. Arrived as described and completely frozen. Cooking instructions came with the package or there are recipes available on the website. Have only had a chance to try the burgers and they were delicious. Can't wait to try more of the products!
M
Martha King · 3 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Awesome Experience
I ordered a gift online for my friend and then realized that I wanted to amend the gift. I called Wild Idea Buffalo Co. and spoke with a very helpful person, who revised my gift correctly per my wishes. She also amended my credit card appropriately to reflect the correct purchase. I was very impressed that the transaction was handled appropriately and my friend's gift arrived as promised. By the way, my friend loved the gift and I loved the excellent customer service from Wild Idea Buffalo Co. I will definitely be a repeat customer!
J
JOHN · 5 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Happy Bison Customer
My order was handled promptly. Shipping was as promised and the meat arrived still solidly frozen. Yesterday I served 17 of us with the 10 lb. prime rib roast which was done perfectly and with plenty of leftovers. All raved about the meat! I used the suggested rub and roasted on onions and celery as suggested. Results: tender, delicious and beautiful slices. It was a special treat. Thank you for helping to make our Christmas celebration a huge success!
T
Tracy Robson · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
great experience
I was not sure about ordering meat that had a long way to travel. But if I wanted buffalo i had to do just that. The stores around me are limited.
I got steak bundle that had free shipping. And added on some summer sausage and buffalo heart to try. The meat got to me promptly and had been packaged perfectly. All the meat was still frozen.
I couldn't wait to try the summer sausage. The very reason I ordered from this company was because the summer sausages and the like are made without preservatives. I am allergic to them and don't get those treats very often. It was the best I have ever had.
I will order from them again.
J
Jan L Pittman · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Great Company
Prompt, no hassles, delivered on time!
E
Emil Stockton · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
good product, good people
refer to the title
H
HempGrama · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Won't be my last order!!
The only red meat I eat is buffalo. I have to drive an hour to the only store around that sells it. Needless to say, because you deliver, I took the chance on your company. I couldn't be happier!! Not only does the meat taste great, but it arrived on time and packed so perfectly! The size of the "steaks" are a bit small, but that's really a moot point at this time! And yes, I will be purchasing more, including a heart for summer barbecuing!
M
Mike Hancock · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
I had a very good experience.
Easy ordering. I am guessing the product got to the recipient because I have not heard from them. I just wish I had requested the free steak. I would have loved to try it myself…I will be ordering some for myself in the near future.
