Wild Idea Buffalo Co (wildideabuffalo.com) has a 4.8 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 61 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Food, Beverages & Tobacco and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 92% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
What people say
D
David Midthun · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
slow shipping
I ordered on the 14th. Was told I need to change address on 17th. So I did come to find out it was sent to the address they said I couldn't use in the first place. It didn't make it in time for Christmas even with a 10 day window.. I order from these guys as a gift. I will now be taking my business elsewhere
Reply from Wild Idea Buffalo Co2015-12-31
Hi David,
Thank you for your recent order. I'm sorry we were unable to get your order shipped to you in a timely manner. We are happy to either give you a refund or reship the package to you. Even though Christmas is a busy time for us and FedEx, we strive for excellent customer service and we would like an opportunity to make it right. We look forward to hearing from you.
All the best in the upcoming New Year!
Wild Idea Buffalo
866-658-6137
D
Dee R. · 4 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Great Selection and Taste
Loved the items I ordered. Tried a variety of buffalo...two types of snack sausages, breakfast sausage, and bacon. So far have tried only one but it was delicious. Packaged very well and the package arrived on time. Very happy overall with the service.
M
Maricela from Texas · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
I am a lifelong customer. Totally awesome.
I can honestly say that my health has improved. My diet is kosher and mostly organic veggies every day. No processed or fried foods. My strength and stamina have increased. I'd like to believe consuming buffalo meat twice a month is healthier because it is so lean and I feel "full" after eating a buffalo meat steak. Besides, it is a designated "clean" food by G d. I'm 60 yrs young, a disabled veteran and highly recommend Wild Idea Buffalo Co. Blessings to all.
p
paula · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Love the meat love the service great gifting
Everything was smooth and easy
R
Roger Wills · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Wildest.
Bison is the best.
C
Cora Miller · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Wild Buffalo & one odd
We are enjoying our buffalo meats and decided to thaw out some for Christmas chili. Getting ready to cook it, one of the packages is a very different color. Instead of the dense dark meat of the buffalo, it is the much lighter red of beef. We eat buffalo exclusively for red meat so we clearly know the difference in color and taste! This is disappointing since we purchased a large quantity at great expense and expected to have only buffalo shipped to us. Other than this, the quality of the buffalo we do have is outstanding!
Wishing you and yours a Merry Christmas.
Cora Miller
618 259-9416
Reply from Wild Idea Buffalo Co2015-12-28
Hello Cora,
Thank you for your support and sustainable great taste! I'm sorry you are disappointed with one package that was recently sent to you. I can assure you that you received 100% buffalo and not beef. We only harvest and process buffalo and welcome you to visit our complete operation of the ranch and plant anytime.
It's hard to say why one package of ground buffalo was not the same dense dark meat you are used to. It could be the package in question came from an animal that is a bit fattier, or the batch didn't get mixed as well prior to being packaged. Nonetheless, I have made note on your account to send a replacement package with your next order.
Cheers to healthy eating in 2016!
Melissa
S
Shari Evans · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Very happy
The service was excellent. Ordering online was easy and the products were shipped quickly and appear as promised. We have not eaten any of it yet but it looks good. Another company I have ordered from sends their meat packed in dry ice. I do not like dealing with that and prefer the ice blocks Wild Idea uses. I'm very satisfied.
A
Alfred Fyock · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Very pleased!!!!!
Shipping was quicker than expected.. Packages where better than stated... I would 100% recomend Wild Idea Buffalo Co to my friends and family. I will be ordering again.
R
Ralph Breaux · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Ecellent
Worth the money,
M
Michelle Cox · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Satisfied
Ordered online as a gift. Process was quick and easy. Delivered on time with no problems.
r
rosemary Willman · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Tenderloin
My preferred source, product always arrives in a timely fashion. Only downside is price point, it is an expensive product.
A
Artie Hardie · 8 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Very nicely done.
Was a great experience.
M
Mark Faughender · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Once you try buffalo meat you will not go back to cattle.
My first order was short ribs and Buffalo patties. My cousin in Sioux Falls, South Dakota introduced me to the short ribs. We had a barbeque, the meat was tender, lean. The meat fell off the ribs. The taste was excellent. I live in California, the package arrived, the meat was still frozen. I will continue to purchase from this company.
S
Shelly · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Buffalo for Christmas
I gave three families (including my own) buffalo for Christmas. Everyone has received their packages but I do not believe anyone has cooked their meat yet. I do know, from personal experience, that the packaging is expertly done. I also know from past experience that the buffalo is the best meat I have ever eaten. Worth every penny.
a
anonymous · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
excellent service and most high quality product!
Absolutely love supporting this company. I know Im providing my family with the most high quality food at a competitive price. Excellent customer service....never ever have had an issue with my shipment or incorrect orders. Highly recommend!!!
C
Cactus Gulch · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Great product - excellent packaging and shipping
We looked a source of responsibly raised buffalo that was processed in a healthy, clean environment.
We were looking for completely grass fed and finished buffalo and even more important processed in a clean environment.
The closest local stores, which are 60-70 miles away, that carry Wild Idea did not have the ground meat, so we ordered direct from the ranch.
The packaging was excellent as the meat was still frozen. I actually snapped a photo of the temperature - well below freezing. The package arrived a day early!
For me, having the meat processed in a clean facility is just as important as the quality of the raising of the buffalo.
Another huge plus is their humane harvesting process.
And, as if all of that were not enough, they are renewing their part of the plains.
Oh, I am vegetarian, but my husband says this is the best buffalo he has had and he's tried several.
Thank you so much for taking the initiative and then making your buffalo products available and at a reasonable price.
B
Barbara Dina · 5 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
So glad to make your acquaintence.
I discovered Wild Idea from reading Dan's two books about the company and how it came to be. I was so inspired! I have been thinking about eliminating meat from my diet, so I decided to give your buffalo a try to see if we would like it. We certainly love the concept. The shipment came as promised, still nicely frozen. However, the package of steak strips was not completely sealed, which made a mess in the fridge. Not to worry! It needed cleaning anyway. Today I made your recipe for Vietnamese Bison Steak Salad. Wow! Wonderful! The meat was tender and the spices worked so well. We can't wait to try the steaks and roasts. Thank you for offering meat "that won't kill us." And thank you for taking care of our prairie.
Jim and Barbara Dina
Dunedin, Florida
R
Rae · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Delicious Quality Meat
You were out of the 10b. boneless prime rib we ordered and Corey was Great and called to see if two five pounders would be alright. Turned out that actually worked out better for us! The Meat was excellent!!! Now you're out of the five pounders! Guess business is Good and I am happy for you.
I feel lucky to be able to have your beautiful product on our table. Thank you
for all your hard work to make a growing company!!! It shows!
K
Katherine Lockridge · 2 reviews · Verified ·
★★★★★
Terrific job!
I ordered buffalo sausage and jerky from Wild Idea Buffalo Co for the first time recently. The box arrived in a timely fashion and it was well packed. So impressive! The meat items were packed in a box lined with foam panels, and inside there were ice packets.
We have not tried all the products yet as they are xmas gifts, but we did try one package of the sausage, and one bag of jerky. Both were delicious! Not too tuff, not too salty, seasoned perfectly.
J
Jefferson Gray · 1 review · Verified ·
★★★★★
Great product, slight shipping issues
I have only had time to try the bison heart and it is very good, the shipment arrived a day later than the company said but was frozen solid, one nordic ice pack leaked after it thawed, aside from that I am quite happy with it and I have recommended this company to several others.
