Craft Holsters (craftholsters.com) has a 4.5 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 62 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Home & Garden and its reputation is excellent. 87% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 10% are 1 star; The business has replied to 29% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
What people say
B
Bri · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-31 ·
★★★★★
The double magazine pouch is fantastic
The double magazine pouch is fantastic. Fits my 10mm magazines firmly. With the retention adjustment I could adjust how I prefer the tightness of the magazines. Top grade leather and with the optional monogram gives it a great appearance. I have bought several other products from craft holsters including a few holsters. Everything I have purchased has been top quality leather and craftsmanship! I will continue buying products from craft holsters. Highly recommend their products for anyone seriously looking for an all around quality leather product!
S
Steven Nelson · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-29 ·
★★★★★
Great product
Great product. Beautiful leather and well made perfect fit
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-30
Thank you for your kind review. We’re glad to hear you’re happy with the leather quality, craftsmanship, and perfect fit of your holster. We truly appreciate your support.
P
Paul Stockford · 4 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-01 ·
★★★★★
Excellent Craftsmanship
Very well-made products. High-quality material and craftsmanship. Fit my firearm perfectly. Delivered when promised.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-23
Thank you for your wonderful review. We’re glad to hear the holster fit your firearm perfectly and that you were happy with the materials, craftsmanship, and delivery. We truly appreciate your trust in Craft Holsters.
A
Albert K Overbay · 5 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-22 ·
★★★★★
New gun belts and holsters are always…
New gun belts and holsters are always exciting to me especially, since my great grandfather was the First Sheriff of Union County, New Mexico.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-23
Thank you for sharing that with us. That’s a wonderful family connection, and it makes it even more special to hear that new gun belts and holsters still bring that kind of excitement. We truly appreciate you choosing Craft Holsters and hope your new gear serves you well.
W
WILLIAM ECKERT · 4 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
Superb company and products.
Superb company and products.
Tell you to follow instructions so everything stays perfect. Treat setup correct and equipment wont let you down!!!
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-24
Thank you for your review. We’re glad you’re happy with the product and appreciate you pointing out how important it is to follow the instructions for the best long-term performance.
R
Ronald · 7 reviews · Experienced 2026-05-26 ·
★★★★★
I purchased 2 holsters for my revolver…
I purchased 2 holsters for my revolver from Craft holsters. The quality and craftsmanship of these holsters is incredible. I prefer leather instead of kydex holsters. Leather is so much better feeling and comfortable wearing. These holsters are well worth the cost. I would definitely recommend,and, will buy from them again.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-23
Thank you for such a kind review. We’re very glad to hear you’re happy with both revolver holsters and that the leather quality, comfort, and craftsmanship met your expectations. It means a lot that you would recommend us and consider ordering again. We truly appreciate your trust in Craft Holsters.
R
Rick Majeski · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-05-20 ·
★★★★★
One at a Time
That some The products are not massed produced. They are manufactured "one at a time."
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-21
Thank you for noticing that. It really means a lot when customers understand that our holsters are not just pulled from a shelf, but made one at a time for a specific order. That takes a bit more time, but it’s exactly what allows us to focus on the fit, details, and overall quality. We truly appreciate your support.
R
R. John · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-08 ·
★★★★★
We ordered two holsters 1 arrived smashed the other lost in France for 7 days!…
We ordered two holsters this late Spring, early May 2026, we understand that they’re overseas, but they use FedEx for their shipping. Our first holster was delivered pretty much on time, but the box containing the holster was smashed to smithereens and it was just in a bag. Luckily the holster was OK. had a few scratches in the leather! Now our second holster was due to ship to arrive July 7 and every so often I would get an update well for some reason it was shipped on June 30 and for the past six days going on seven days(7/4-7/10). It’s at a facility in France and not moving at all.!!
I finally reached out to them to ask them if they could look into it and all they told me was oh it takes and 8 to 10 days! Yes, I’m aware of that but it’s actually going on 11 days and it’s been at the same facility in France for seven days!! that sure sounds like lost or damaged! I was a shipping manager for many years. I’ve seen FedEx and UPS do this!!
I’ve asked a couple times in replies can you please look into it with no response? (*their response was”it’s only been 10 days”?) 7/10
The holsters are nice the way they get them to us is piss poor and they don’t seem to care about it once they’ve got your money and the product this shipped…oh.. and $21 usd to ship a 5oz. Package.. and takes 8-15 days to get here? They claim 7-10 days ?
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-13
Thank you for your feedback. We’re sorry about the damaged packaging on the first delivery and the delay with your second holster. We understand your frustration, especially when tracking has not moved for several days. Please contact our support team with your order number or reply to your existing ticket so they can check the shipment with the carrier and help resolve this properly. We’re glad you like the holsters themselves, but we’re sorry the delivery experience has not met expectations.
H
Herman Karl · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
Quality products at a fair price.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-13
Thank you for your review. We’re glad you’re happy with the quality and value of our products.
B
Bo Rice · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-08 ·
★★★★★
I received a different holster than…
I received a different holster than what was ordered. Vianey and Fillip both went out of there way to communicate swiftly and as transparent as possible to get me the holster i needed. Their customer service is top notch and the product is well made. Absolutely recommend Craft holsters and their team for any holster needs!
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-09
Thank you for your honest review and recommendation. We’re sorry the wrong holster was received at first, but we’re glad Vianey and Fillip were able to communicate quickly and help get everything resolved. It’s great to hear you’re happy with both the service and the quality of the product.
It can be difficult to find a well-made holster for an HK USP, so I was very pleased to find this option from Craft Holsters. The quality is excellent. The leather is thick and well finished, the stitching is clean and consistent, and the overall construction feels solid and durable. The fit is precise, retention is secure, and the holster holds its shape well. Craft Holsters clearly pays attention to the details, and this feels like a premium product built for long-term use.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-07
Thank you for your detailed review. We’re glad to hear your HK USP holster fits well, offers secure retention, and feels solid and durable. We truly appreciate your trust in Craft Holsters.
S
S.A.M. · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-01 ·
★★★★★
Shopped other holster companies for my…
Shopped other holster companies for my Kimber KS6, nobody offered one. These guys did and I had it in a few weeks. Quality and workmanship is as good as anyone's. Price seemed a few bucks cheaper than similar holsters that I purchased for other hand guns. Quality was as good or better than the other guys.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-07-03
Thank you for your great review. We’re glad we could offer a holster for your Kimber K6s when others couldn’t, and that it arrived within a few weeks. It’s good to hear the quality, workmanship, and value met your expectations. We truly appreciate your trust in Craft Holsters.
F
Farnsworth · 6 reviews · Experienced 2026-06-09 ·
★★★★★
Great well made holsters
Great well made holsters. I purchased two leather ones. Good workmanship. Very short break in period. I recommend.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-06-23
Thank you for your kind review. We’re glad to hear you’re happy with the workmanship and that the break-in period was short. We appreciate your recommendation.
J
JAK · 1 review · Experienced 2026-06-02 ·
★★★★★
I could not return a belt that I did…
I could not return a belt that I did not even use. They will not even exchange for another size.
No exchange no return no change to the order.
Even simple thing as color change costs money.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-06-18
Thank you for your feedback. We’re sorry to hear about your experience. Please contact us at [email protected] with your order number so our team can review the issue and help find a suitable solution.
Recently I received my new holster.
I was very pleased with the fit, quality and craftsmanship.
The Craft Holsters colleagues were prompt, courteous and professional throughout the entire ordering and delivery process.
The teamwork was obvious and their pride in their product and service was impressive.
The holster delivery package was also pleasantly surprising.
The Craft Holsters team was outstanding from start to finish.
Thank you.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-06-18
Thank you for your kind review. We’re pleased to hear that the holster met your expectations in fit, quality, and craftsmanship. We also appreciate your feedback about our team and the ordering and delivery process. Your words mean a lot to everyone involved. Thank you for choosing Craft Holsters.
R
Retgrunt · 1 review · Experienced 2026-05-25 ·
★★★★★
Beautiful made holster fits my Smith & Wesson 610 like a glove
Beautiful made holster fits my Smith & Wesson 610 like a glove would definitely recommend this to my friends
I got it on the date that they promised
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-06-18
Thank you for your review. We’re glad to hear the holster fits your Smith & Wesson 610 well and that you’re pleased with the craftsmanship. We also appreciate your recommendation and are happy the delivery arrived as promised.
J
John · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-05-21 ·
★★★★★
These folks really work with you
These folks really work with you. I like the fact they are hands on. Although they are a distance they make you feel at home with outstanding customer service !
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-06-18
Thank you for your review. We’re glad to hear our team was helpful and that you felt well taken care of throughout the process. We appreciate your kind words about our customer service.
Product quality is above reproach both workmanship and materials. Always arrives in great condition and ALWAYS is a perfect fit but frequently need to follow their break-in procedure to achieve that. ABSOLUTE confidence and satisfaction with the company. I own other custom hol0sters that cost 3-4 times as much and they are no better/worse. Promote and buy with confidence!!
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-06-18
Thank you for your detailed review. We’re glad to hear you’re consistently satisfied with the workmanship, materials, fit, and overall quality of our holsters. We also appreciate you mentioning the break-in process, as it can be an important step in achieving the best possible fit. Thank you for your continued trust in Craft Holsters.
Well made and very handsome product
Good customer service and feedback
All in,a very pleasant experience
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-06-18
Thank you for your review. We’re glad to hear you’re pleased with the product quality, appearance, and customer service. We appreciate your feedback and are happy the overall experience was a pleasant one.
P
Peter · 1 review · Experienced 2026-04-24 ·
★★★★★
The holster met my expectations and…
The holster met my expectations and more. The quality of leather and craftsmanship are the best I've seen. Followed the break-in instructions and my Sig P226 Legion fit like they had the gun in their shop. It really impressed me. I believe this holster could bypassed down through generations if maintained. When I need another holster, I know who I'll go to. Oh, and it's made to order but the wait was not bad.. Quality can't be rushed.
Reply from Craft Holsters2026-06-18
Thank you for your detailed review. We’re glad to hear the holster exceeded your expectations and that you’re pleased with the leather quality, craftsmanship, and fit for your Sig P226 Legion. We also appreciate you mentioning the break-in process and the made-to-order wait. Quality and proper fit take time, and we’re glad the result was worth it.
