IL MAKIAGE New York (ilmakiage.com) has a 4.5 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 202 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Beauty & Well-being and its reputation is excellent. 86% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 5% are 1 star; The business has replied to 80% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
I was perfectly skeptical! Now, I am a changed woman. I had never used a brush to apply my foundation OR used a Primer. I love the quality of the products and how helpful the website was when it came to which products and what shade/colors to go with! Very happy with everything!
I'm satisfied with the professionalism of the company on their customer service! Thank you!
A
Anna · 2 reviews · Verified · Experienced 2026-08-05 ·
★★★★★
I don't like the huge pop ups that keep…
I don't like the huge pop ups that keep asking for a regular subscription to the products. It's hard to figure out how to order what I want due to these distracting pop ups.
Reply from IL MAKIAGE New York2026-08-06
Hi there, thank you for your feedback! We're always trying to outdo ourselves and appreciate you sharing your experience with us. We will pass this on to our team! 💌
My "Foundation" order arrived within the promised 10 days - so that was fine! However; when the shipment arrived, my foundation bottle was smashed...sooo damaged that the foundation was covering the inside of the cardboard box. I can't use this makeup, for fear of getting glass on my skin.
*More appropriate packaging would be required when shipping glass containers such as this one.
So sorry to have to report this.
I love the Woke Up Like This Liquid makeup. I also love the concealer. I would love to try their powder foundation compact but the compact (from the looks of the picture), compared to price listed, looks like it wouldn't last very long so I use a different brand for my powder foundation.
Good customer service , good products but a little difficult to find the right shade in foundation… 75 it was s little light, this time I ordered shade 100 🤞🏻🙏🏻.
Thank you
Ruth Ahumada
Reply from IL MAKIAGE New York2026-08-06
Thank you so much for your review. We would love to look into this. Please reach out to [email protected] ❤️
C
Cindy · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-08-06 ·
★★★★★
You cannot cancel out of the auto…
You cannot cancel out of the auto replenishment easily. They promised that they would take $9 and then I would pay in full if I was satisfied. They took the whole amount immediately. What a joke.
Reply from IL MAKIAGE New York2026-08-06
Hi Cindy! We're sorry for the confusion and are happy to help clarify! What you’re seeing is a temporary authorization, not a charge. This is a standard process used by banks and companies to confirm your payment method is valid and the funds are available, but rest assured, you won’t be charged unless you decide to keep the Try Before You Buy products after your trial ends. Pre-authorization is disclosed prior to checking out and it is also outlined in our FAQ’s.
Also, our subscription program is not a requirement, it is never preselected for you. We do require you to actively opt in, and then we automatically send you your product(s) based on your selected or default frequency. Feel free to contact our customer service team via email at [email protected] for any further questions or concerns.
Best customer service ever ! I have had a bit of trouble finding the right shade of makeup foundation and with a few questions I answered they are sending me another shade , just that easy ! I will always buy from a company that puts you first ! No hassle at all ! BRAVO!
Thank you so much for your love and support! We're thrilled to hear you’re enjoying all your products from us. We can’t wait to help you discover even more favorites in the future! 🤍
Well you said that we only have to pay a certain amount which was 690 instead you charge my card the full price which says supposedly temporary home but of 80 bucks so I'm not very happy next time you need to put that see that up front
M
M V · 2 reviews · Verified · Experienced 2026-08-06 ·
★★★★★
Excellent and attentive customer…
Excellent and attentive customer service!
Reply from IL MAKIAGE New York2026-08-06
We're delighted to hear this! We truly appreciate your support 🤍
I had an issue and the customer service team worked with me to fix the issue very quickly. I am very happy with my purchases and the customer service was top notch.
Good site to buy from. A bit expensive though; but I come back.
L
Long time user · 1 review · Verified · Experienced 2026-08-06 ·
★★★★★
Annoying Log In
I really hate that I have to log in to the site through my email versus just using a password. I can only access my email through my phone and it makes ordering and shopping a cumbersome experience.