MedicareSupplement.com (medicaresupplement.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 100 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Money & Insurance and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 95% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
I talked to David Volkert and he was very knowledgeable and very helpful to me in choosing my plan He was very professional at the same time caring and patient Thank you David for your help This is 1st time I am using Mutual of Omaha and I feel good about choosing the company
Sherri L MacK was a tremendous help last December when my husband and I were looking at insurance companies for our Medicare Plan F. I was very confused and was having a hard time. Sherri explained to us that Plan F coverage does not change when we change insurance companies. She spent hours with me on the phone helping us find different insurance companies. If we had not changed companies my husband and I would both be paying over $500 a month in premiums. Now my insurance premium is $277.88 and my husband’s is now $391.12. That is a tremendous savings of over $300 a month, over $3600 for the year!
David Moberly was a great help in setting up a Blue Cross Supplement for my disabled daughter Gail. Gail lives in a facility for Special Needs people and her medical insurance has always been handled by them. I recently came to my attention that she has been covered by Medicare and MediCal. I don't want the MediCal coverage for her and worked to cancel it as soon as I realized the Facility had automatically been using it for her for years. David was a great help in getting coverage for Gail and explained much that was confusing for me. I thank him again for his help in getting the best Blue Cross supplement for her. Betty LeFevre (Gail's mother)
Robert Taylor of TZ Insurance was very helpful, patent and engaging while he helped me with a quote for a Medicare supplement policy which I purchased. Robert took the time to professionally and clearly explain how Medicare works and listens to my questions. I would recommend Robert to anyone looking for Medicare policy advice.
David Moberley at TZ Insurance Solutions was efficient, thorough, and friendly while helping me select a supplemental plan. I got very lucky considering I didn't have one yet and the open enrollment just started. It was much cheaper than I thought it would be.
My representative Robert T, went one step beyond to explain how Medicare and supplement policies work. If you have the time to listen and have the patience to listen to his expertise, you will be knowledgeable to decide which plan works best for you. He gave great advice even if change in the future and your policy doesn't work for you you can change it. Aflac also offers vision,dental and hearing at additional costs, but great if I choose it in the future. He was nice enough to give me a discount as well. I valued that he was very courteous and kind. Thank you Robert. Diane B
I was looking for supplemental insurance and how lucky I was to receive a call from David Moberley, representative of Omaha IC. From the start till the finish line David impressed me with his knowledge of all kind of products. He helped me to find the best plan for me. Thank you David for your sophisticated work! Your kindness is a big plus for Seniors like me. The speed you work, reminds me at my 40-s. I will definitely recommend your services to anyone who needs Medicare supplement insurance! So grateful for people like you! Warm Regards!
David was verey helpful and very patient
Leah was exceptional with conversation on topics and easy to talk to and super friendly!!
Robert was extremely thorough throughout the process and worked hard to secure a lower rate, which significantly reduced my monthly payment. I really appreciated his attention to detail and dedication to getting me the best possible outcome.
I just enrolled with Mutual of Omaha and added Dental and Vision. David Volkert was amazing explained everything and emailed me all the information as well. Very helpful and informative.
My husband used to handle this stuff before he passed but now I have to do it and to say I was lost is an understatement. A friend of mine recommended I call "her insurance guy", Mr. Chris Butcher, for help and advice. She had nothing but good things to say about him. I am very glad I did. Not only did was he patient and understnading, he made it all very easy for ME to understand. I feel that I now have a Much better handle on things and he made it so easy. Insurance is a thing that comes up a lot as we get older and now I can be the one to say that I have "an insurance guy".
Sherri was very pleasant. she explained my N plan, dental and eye. she was thorough and answered all questions i could think of asking. Glad to have her on my team.
I inquired about possibly changing my Medicare Supplement due to constantly increasing costs. I spoke with Demi Leonard, and she was great! She reviewed costs of plans in my area, as well as other areas, as I have looked into possibly moving. She was very helpful and very understanding and professional! I highly recommend trustpilot.com and Demi Leonard! She will give you all the information you need to make a proper decision.
Robert Taylor was an amazing agent. He was very professional and knowledgeable. Thanks Robert for assisting me through the Medicare process.
Robert Taylor of TZ Insurance is very helpful in helping me to select the best policy I need for my Medicare. Robert takes the time to professionally and clearly explain how Medicare works and listens to my concerns. I would recommend Robert to anyone looking for Medicare policy advice.
Ms. Leah was very friendly and clear to understand policy option. I will give her a star 10 if I could!! Thank you Ms. Leah.
Your agent Sherri Mack set me up with a policy almost 2 years ago. We did it over the phone and I was extremely nervous about it because I could not navigate medicare. It was to confusing for me. I have realized over the past year that she took very good care of me and I am so relieved and thankful for her time and help. She's a gem!! She helped me again today and I was happy she was still there.
Ms Britt was very professional and very informative. I appreciate how she explained everything. She was excellent!!!
Stacy McIntosh was a charming and professionally efficient representative. She was very patient with my mom, Nicole Karsenty Ligeti, who joined the Mutual of Omaha, Plan N, with Medicare. Stacy spoke more slowly with her questions for my mom to understand the information. Stacy was a delight to help us deal with a stressful Medicare decision that has many options to understand.
100 reviews matching