MedicareSupplement.com (medicaresupplement.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 100 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Money & Insurance and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 95% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
Bailey Deazevedo was personal, competent, and knowledgeable. I was somewhat panicked when my health insurance company informed me that my Advantage Plan had been discontinued. Bailey guided me through the process of applying for a Medicare supplemental plan with a steady focus on price, quality, and on what suited my precise needs. I would definitely recommend Bailey to anyone, who wants to feel confident that they have successfully enrolled in the best plan available.
J
Jean S · 3 reviews · Experienced 2025-11-21 ·
★★★★★
Knowledgable/thourough/patient
David Moberley- did an excellent job- explaining and answering my questions patiently. Even discussed dental coverage- which I will compare and consider. Very satisfied with the service.
RobertTaylor was patient & knowledgeable.
After back and forth, I was able to finalize my Medigap supplement.
He was a pleasure to talk to and a real gentleman.
Thank you, Robert,
Cecilia
S
Stuart Wiener · 1 review · Experienced 2025-11-20 ·
★★★★★
Robert was excellent
Robert was excellent. He explained everything clearly and concisely. He was very friendly. He saved me quite a bit of money. And was able to add dental insurance at a very reasonable price
a
anne · 4 reviews · Experienced 2025-11-13 ·
★★★★★
Excellent agent.
Jamie listened with genuine interest to my concerns and needs. She presented multiple options in a professional manner. She was kind and friendly. I feel like I now have an advocate to help with medical insurance. Thank you.
M
M. Seatvet · 2 reviews · Experienced 2025-11-14 ·
★★★★★
Agent assigned to me (because licensed…
Agent assigned to me (because licensed in my state) was very patient in working through problems with my technology. She informed me of my options and quickly completed my application. Always friendly, courteous, and cheerful
M
Mary D Fournier · 1 review · Experienced 2025-11-10 ·
★★★★★
Great Medicare Supplement Agent
I knew exactly what I wanted as my Medicare supplement, just had to call to sign up. Entered my info on Medicare.gov and within a few minutes had an agent from Aflac on the phone. Robert Taylor of TZ Insurance called and I told him what I needed and he was wonderful. Got me signed up at a great premium and was able to give direction and understanding throughout the process. Highly recommend. Signing up for anything over the phone is stressful but he made it a breeze!
L
Larry · 2 reviews · Experienced 2025-11-06 ·
★★★★★
After starting the day in a quagmire
After starting the day in a quagmire of questions surrounding my medicare choices, I picked up the phone, and an extremely knowledgeable Mutual of Omaha agent walked me through everything I needed to know. He made me comfortable with my decisions. Wonderful, professional experience!
I dealt with Jamie Knatz. She was super nice and professional. I called to see if I could get cheaper insurance cause the company that I had raised my price up by $50.00. She was able to help me out a lot and I appreciate her so much for doing that for me.
When i called about my insurance to be taken over because i needed a lower rate but still the best i could get. He slowly went over the different ways i could go to help me. I ended up with a better policy and my rates was still lower. My dental and vision policies also doubled. He was the best agent ever Robert Taylor with TZ Insurance.
N
Nana Dee · 1 review · Experienced 2025-11-04 ·
★★★★★
The agent Laniesha Britt was extremely knowledgeable and professional
The agent Laniesha Britt was extremely professional and knowledgeable about the insurance plans, both dental and medical that she was able to answer any and all my inquiries. She was also extremely pleasant and respectful and patient with me. Being older you notice these things. I would recommend that she be put in charge of training when it comes to handling customers and their needs, because she is definitely a experienced professional and a angel 😊
Robert Taylor was very helpful and patient with helping with explaining coverages. I felt he was open and honest with the information he gave me.
G
George · 3 reviews · Experienced 2025-10-30 ·
★★★★★
Robert was extremely helpful and very…
Robert was extremely helpful and very knowledgeable. He helped us through the entire application process and made sure we were satisfied with the entire process.
M
Mark Butler · 9 reviews · Experienced 2025-10-30 ·
★★★★★
We dealt with Michael Jones
We dealt with Michael Jones. What a great guy, so professional. So helpful, knew everything, and answered all our questions. He got my wife a great policy and Part D. I recommend him and his Company to anyone. Thank you for walking us through the complicated process.
I just talked to Mr. Robert Chatham at Mutual of Omaha to look for dental coverage. This gentleman was professional and kind explaining everything in great detail. I was so surprised at the cost of this coverage and told my husband to contact Mr. Chatham regarding his coverage plus getting this wonderful coverage plus Medicare Supplement.
She was amazing and was in top of the game when dealing with me. I was very apprehensive about some of the questions and she explained them if we went along and we got through it.
Up and down I wasn't the nicest person to deal with but she hung in there and kept her patients and she was just amazing all the way around.
EXCELLENT CLARITY TO COMPLEX MEDICARE COVERAGE!
Today a heavy burden lifted in moving from Medicare advantage plan back to Medicare supplement Plan because our advantage plans will be discontinued. David Volkert walked my wife and me thru this process very politely with care and understanding our situation and medical needs. His explanations were thorough and understood. We are very thankful He completed this process with us and will be available for future needs.
Sherri Mack was very knowledgeable, friendly and patient. I had spoken with other representatives from other companies and they were not as knowledgeable as she was. I was fortunate to have had her to guide me through the process.
B
Bart Tatro · 1 review · Experienced 2025-10-15 ·
★★★★★
Jamie Knatz
Jamie Knatz - extremely knowledgable, great ability to explain nuances of various policies, very friendly to speak with. She is a great representative for the company.
My agent Dave Volkert with Mutual of Omaha couldn’t have been more helpful. He was kind enough to walk me through everything. He answered all my questions and I never felt rushed with him. He’s definitely someone I will call again if I have any questions my medicare. I will also be adding my husband in the next year so Dave Volkert will be my go to agent. Mutual of Omaha is a great company to work with.
