At Modern Gents Trading Co., we offer affordable wedding and engagement rings for men and women. Shop a great selection of wedding and engagement rings today!
Written by the business, not verified by us.
Is Modern Gents Trading Co. legit?
Modern Gents Trading Co. (modgents.com) has a 4.8 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 101 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 93% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 83% of negative reviews; Reviews mostly discuss Product, Quality, Price. Last updated 2026-08-30.
What reviewers say
AI generated
Reviewers overwhelmingly had a great experience with this company. Customers frequently praise the stunning appearance, affordable pricing, and overall exceptional quality of the rings, noting that they look completely real and hold up remarkably well over extended periods of everyday wear. People also appreciate the exceptionally fast shipping times and the consistently helpful customer support team when needing assistance with size exchanges or browsing available options.
Some reviewers were not happy with unexpected durability issues, specifically mentioning that items tarnished quickly, changed color, or showed major signs of wear after minimal use. A few people also experienced frustrating challenges regarding return processing errors, system issues, and out-of-pocket shipping fees for warranty repairs.
Auto-generated from all reviews of this business. For reference only.
I never got the ring (or romantic proposal or happily ever after) so I bought the Heather ring as a birthday gift to myself. It’s stunning & looks like it cost thousands. It’s beautiful, solid & it’s truly my favorite piece of jewelry. Ladies, just get your fiancé to buy this for you & save your money for your future. Stop pressuring men to buy $$$ stuff you don’t need. One of my friends loved my ring & placed an order to replace both her engagement ring & wedding band & she too is very happy.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-07-12
You go, girl! 🎂💖 Self love is the best love, and the Heather ring sounds like it fits the bill perfectly. Here’s to happy birthdays, beautiful bling, and friends who follow your lead!
The customer service did an amazing job helping with a promo code I received. They instantly helped me out without no hesitation like most companies! I will be being more from them! Highly recommend this company! Thank you guys so much again!
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-07-07
We're so glad to hear that you had a positive experience with our customer service! It's our goal to help our customers as quickly and efficiently as possible. Thank you for recommending us, and we can't wait to help you with your future orders!
I ordered two eternity bands from ModernGents to replace my original (real diamond) eternity wedding bands from 42 years ago. These bands are absolutely stunning! The clarity and vibrancy is amazing. They are solid bands and complement my diamond engagement ring so beautifully. Excellent customer service too. Shipped quickly and constant communication during the entire process!
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-07-06
We're overjoyed that you're satisfied with the clarity and vibrancy of your new eternity bands. Your kind words about our customer service mean the world to us. Enjoy wearing your beautiful rings!
my now husband got my engagement ring on modern gents, which i love and i got his wedding band from them as well.
the rings are beautiful, the fit is perfect and i will always recommend them if anyone is looking for a ring.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-07-06
Thank you for the glowing recommendation! We’re ecstatic that you found your perfect rings with us. Here’s to forever sparkle and love!
I ordered a ring and wasn’t positive on size and I was wrong. I exchanged ring after using the ring sizer that came with the ring. Now I have the correct size ring and absolutely love it!! The ring sparkles and you can’t tell it’s not real.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-07-06
Happy to hear that you’re now rocking the perfect size! Nothing beats that bling that makes you feel fabulous! Cheers to more sparkly rings! 🌟
This company is quality! The rings I got are beautiful. I feel so pretty and feminine wearing them. They are clearly good, sturdy quality. I actually ordered the wrong size at first. No issues at all returning the wrong-sized rings for the proper-sized rings. The return process was super simple and so fast. Seriously, Modern Gents is an awesome company!
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-06-15
We couldn't be happier to hear how much you love your rings! It’s awesome that you found the return process a breeze. Just another reason to rock those beautiful pieces with confidence!
High quality products and top notch customer service. We purchased 2 separate pieces and made our own set; The bliss engagement ring and the Alia band. This combo has been a head turner for over a year! We would purchase these again and again! The sparkle hasn’t dimmed and this girl is one happy camper. The lifetime warranty is just a bonus to this already phenomenal experience. Modern Gents is the way to go to shine bright like a diamond!!
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-06-15
Your happiness is the ultimate compliment! We’re over the moon that you’re enjoying your Bliss and Alia pairing. Here’s to many more years of sparkle and joy!
The rings and earrings have made a huge hit on my social life...lol. Everyone wants to know what jeweler store did I purchase them from and did we win the lottery!
The shine, the gems, the overall quality of my jewelry is what they notice when they see it.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-06-15
We’re so glad to hear our jewelry is the talk of the town! Who needs a lottery win when you can shine like a diamond? ✨
Absolutely Stunning Ring – Exceeded My Expectations
I couldn’t be happier with my purchase of The Claire ring. I was searching for something simple yet elegant, and this ring exceeded every expectation. Even after only a few days of wearing it, I’ve received countless compliments.
I thought it would be difficult to stop wearing my original engagement ring, but the moment I opened the box, I fell in love. The craftsmanship, beauty, and overall quality are truly exceptional. I now wear my original engagement ring on a necklace, and The Claire has become my everyday ring.
The attention to detail is incredible, and the ring looks even more beautiful in person than it does online. I’m already searching for the perfect band to pair with it because it deserves an equally beautiful match.
The entire experience was wonderful, and I will definitely be a repeat customer. If you’re considering purchasing The Claire, I highly recommend it. It’s elegant, timeless, and absolutely stunning. Thank you for creating such a beautiful piece of jewelry! ❤️
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-06-07
Thank you for sharing your experience with The Claire ring! We love hearing that it has received so many compliments and has become a favorite in your collection. We're committed to creating pieces that make our customers feel special, and your feedback inspires us to keep doing what we love. We can’t wait to help you find a stunning band to complement your ring!
There website auto correct to a different city then the original address. When I contacted them they said there was nothing they could do. I have called usps trying to find my rings and come to find out the tracking number has been used more than once so my package is just gone. I’m very disappointed in all of this. Also come to find out when looking at more reviews from a different site on modern gents this happens more than you think and also the rings are CZ stones that fall out after a couple months of wear. No where is it advertised that the stones are CZ. This place is selling cheap jewelry for an over price. Will never buy from again.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-06-03
Thank you so much for taking the time to return our call and discuss this further with one of our managers. Your feedback is incredibly valuable to us. We're sorry that the address issue and delivery complications with the post office created a disappointing experience and we are looking into it with USPS to ensure this does not happen in the future. Nonetheless, we appreciate you doing your part to investigate the matter and the efforts made to work with us to find a suitable resolution for the issue. Our team is ready to assist you with a future purchase when the time is right.
I get endless compliments on my ring (The Scarlett), about the shape and size. It is so beautiful, shiny and perfectly fit. My fiancé got his wedding band from here as well and the quality is amazing. I highly recommend these rings!
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-05-27
It sounds like you and your fiancé are shining as brightly as your rings! We love hearing how much joy The Scarlett and the wedding band bring you. Here’s to more compliments headed your way!
My order came within 3-4weeks of ordering and it looked just as pictured and fit to size. My husband loved it! Great price for a great quality ring
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-05-26
It’s great to hear that the ring met your expectations in both quality and fit. We strive to provide excellent jewelry at fantastic prices. Enjoy wearing it!
Stunning Jewelry That begs the Question “How much did you spend on this?”
Oh My Goodness! I purchased a very beautiful band from ModGents.com but wearing it was a bit uncomfortable around the edges so I submitted a return/exchange with ModGents.com. First of all they were very eager to make things right and the return or exchange went very smoothly and without any hassle at all which I appreciate more than I can say.
The ring I wanted to exchange was the Artemis (beautiful baguettes ring!) for the Alia another gorgeous ring with different shaped and position stones. I had been on the fence when initially choosing the band but had gone with the “safe” more traditional look which I loved on my finger but was somewhat uncomfortable. So when i received my exchange the Alia in gold it was breathtaking out of the box and even more so on my hand. I can’t tell you how it sparkles at every opportunity and has so much fire and light emanating off it is truly eye catching! It goes perfectly with the solitaire Elena in gold.
It’s been about a week since I started wearing both rings together and separately and I get constant compliments on it and even get the under the breath “my gxx how much did these cost!” So I can tell you from first hand experience the jewelry is stunning (I have more pieces in my cart now) the fit true to sizing rings, the company is exemplar to deal with honestly I can not say enough great things about ModGents.com! I highly recommend this company they stand behind their policies and are a delight to work with if needed. The jewelry pieces you select will be among your favorites and the nice thing is you won’t be afraid to wear them or feel guilty as I was with mined diamonds.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-05-26
The Alia sounds like it was meant to be on your finger! We're so happy you found the perfect style and that our team could help make it happen. Can't wait to see what else you choose!
I am writing to express my deep disappointment with a ring I purchased, which arrived on March 30th, 2026. Less than two months later, the item has already severely tarnished. The "gold" finish has completely worn off to a matte silver, despite strict adherence to your provided care instructions. While my warranty claim was approved today after I submitted photographic evidence, I was shocked to find that I am being charged a $16 shipping fee to replace a defective item. Forcing customers to pay out-of-pocket to fix a manufacturing defect is unacceptable, especially when the product quality does not match what you advertise. As a result of this experience, I will no longer purchase from Modern Gents, nor will I recommend your brand to others. I request that this shipping fee be waived as a gesture of basic customer service for a faulty product.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-06-16
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re truly sorry to hear that your ring did not hold up as expected, and we understand how disappointing that must be. That said, we understand your concerns and would be happy to review this further with you if needed. One of our managers has tried reaching you by phone but wasn’t able to connect. Please feel free to return our call so we can better assist you.
In the meantime, we’re glad your warranty claim was approved, and we look forward to fulfilling your request with a brand-new replacement. Thank you again for bringing this to our attention. We look forward to hearing from you.
When I ordered these rings, 1st was the Camille, it's quality looks and feels real, then I wanted to buy the Iris and Zoey as a wedding set. I love my jewelry; I have fooled a many for what they thought was real diamonds and white Gold.
If you want a beautiful set or just a ring, buy here. prices are very reasonable and you get your orders fast...Plus they have a lifetime guarantee.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-05-20
Wow, it sounds like you have a fantastic collection! Adding sparkle is so much fun, and our lifetime warranty allows you to dazzle with confidence! 😄💍
I own about 12 pieces of jewelry from Modern Gents and I could not be happier with my purchases.
I have multiple necklaces, bracelets, and rings I alternate throughout the week. Several of the pieces I've had for two years now and they look just as good as when I first purchased them.
I did have to get my favorite ring set replated recently and it was a super simple process. Mind you, I wear this set daily and I work a lot with my hands and wash my hands constantly so I expected this to happen at some point. This is common even with real gold rings, they need to be replated periodically.
I contacted Modern Gents through their site and submitted two photos of the rings. They approved the request to have them sent back in. I covered the shipping costs and within a week, I got a new set back.
Because of the great warranty and customer service, I decided to order yet another set of rings to my collection!
I would love for them to add more everyday jewelry to their collections, everything is just so beautiful!
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-05-20
It makes us so happy to know that our jewelry has been a part of your daily routine for two years now. We’re thrilled to provide a service that keeps your favorites looking fresh. Your feedback on wanting more everyday jewelry is really helpful. Stay tuned for what’s coming next! Happy wearing!
Beautiful timeless ring and earrings. The absolute perfect upgrade to my ring for Mother's Day without having to break the bank. Everyone has given me so many compliments on it. Ordering was super easy and shipping was very quick.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-05-14
We're so happy you found the perfect Mother's Day gift! 💐 A beautiful upgrade that doesn’t break the bank is the dream! Thank you for sharing your experience!
Was very disappointed. I ordered the Brielle and the Shay. They look like plastice. The Brielle gem looks worse than a CZ, hardly any sparkle or shine. I got the silver version and both pieces, definitely, disappointed in quality and look. When trying to request a return it continued saying my order was not found. I'm waiting to hear from customer service but I don't recommend nor will I purchase anything else.
EDIT- Yes, I was contacted via a phone call from someone at the company. I didnt call back because there is no reason to. I requested a return so there is nothing more that needs to be done. Part of my disappointment IS the fact that I have to go through the process of printing the label, boxing it up again and making it to the post office before 5. I dont have the extra time during those hrs, which is why it hasn't been sent back yet. Doing a return is NOT convenient in any way.
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-05-18
We’re very sorry to hear about your disappointment with the Brielle and Shay pieces and appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback. We understand how frustrating it must have been to receive items that did not meet your expectations, especially after looking forward to your order.
We can confirm that we received your refund request; however, we have not yet received any tracking updates regarding the return shipment of the items. Additionally, a manager has made several attempts to get in touch to offer further assistance and help resolve this for you as quickly as possible.
We truly value your experience and want to ensure it is a positive one. Your feedback is important to us, and we would be happy to provide any additional assistance needed to help make this right.
What attracted me to Modern gents was the Scarlett and then I saw the Giselle as well I debated this for the past few months but I finally got a really good coupon with free shipping so I said why not this would make an excellent birthday present for myself as well as mother's Day present for mom. I received my order pretty quick every piece I got was very beautiful and worth it I'm happy there's a lifetime warranty on each piece and you can wear them everyday regardless of the occasion. I love that they don't charge extra for double digit sizes especially that I went up a half a size bigger than my normal size since I do have arthritis flare ups as well as occasional hand swelling
Reply from Modern Gents Trading Co.2026-05-11
It sounds like you made some beautiful choices with the Scarlett and Giselle, and we love that you're treating yourself and your mom, too. Quick shipping and stunning jewelry are what we strive for, so thank you for mentioning that! We're also proud of our commitment to inclusivity with sizing. Enjoy your beautifully crafted pieces, and here’s to many lovely occasions to wear them!
Louilyjewelry
Jeulia Jewelry
Rare Carat
MollyJewelryUS
Rodiffymoissanite
ReadYourHeart
MSBLUE Jewelry
Maxinejewelry