Unlock a world of fishing experiences with our monthly subscriptions. Mystery Tackle Box offers three tiered plans, suited to anglers at all levels and budgets. We’re your fishing buddy in a box! Our team handpicks the catch of the month, delivered straight to your doorstep with an assortment of hardbaits, soft plastics, jigs, hooks, and other tackle.#HappyDance is our motto at HQ. We put our fans first and strive to deliver a positive customer experience every time. Should you have any issues or concerns, reach out to us and we’ll make it right!
Written by the business, not verified by us.Mystery Tackle Box (mysterytacklebox.com) has a 4.3 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 200 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Hobbies & Crafts and its reputation is good. 82% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 12% are 1 star; The business has replied to 74% of negative reviews; 9 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-25.
Decent baits just not really the quality I would’ve liked especially for a pro box.
Hey Lake, We appreciate you taking the time to share your review! We'd also love to get some more feedback from you about the quality of your box products. Please look out for an email from our team shortly!
Hey Zachary, Thanks for sharing your feedback! We are very sorry to hear about the missing package. We will always ensure that you receive your shipments, and we are happy to make things right. Please be on the lookout for an email from our team so we can fix this issue. We will be in touch soon!
Received this great gift from my pal and I'm loving it. The first box had loads of cool stuff to augment my aging collection of tackle. Can't wait for the next one!
After trying another trial subscription of the $20 economy box on a 3 month plan, after the 1st box it became apparent that a step up was needed. I traded my last 2 remaining boxes for 1 elite box. I was much more happy with results. Once I'm in a position to reactivate my subscription, it will most likely be the pro series or elite. I'm in Eastern North Carolina, our rivers and lakes are full of submerged trees and stumps, trees that fell during hurricanes, losing lures is pretty common here so if getting duplicate lures happens, it's still good, if we lost it meant we were actively fishing it. I got a rodsock(my 1st ever) in my elite box and that will come in handy with all the overhanging trees and bushes especially when bank fishing ponds. To me the best part of the mystery tackle box is not knowing, rather than sight buying from a store, you're more likely to get lures and color combinations you might not otherwise try, just because it's cool looking doesn't mean it's colors are right for where you might fish. If you want to start stacking up a good lure collection, this is a good way to do it.
great products great service, but my tackle box is overflowing
I really loved getting a box every month for 6 months. It was like Christmas every month! I received a great variety of lures and some really cool ones that I would never think to purchase. The quality is also very nice. I would definitely recommend.
Great way to discover new gear for a variety of fishing. Like a little christmas gift every month.
No discount for giving my email. Their website said I would get $10 for sharing my email. I shared it but never received the promised discount code. I had been planning to buy a box before even knowing of the discount, but feeling misled changed my mind and I didn’t purchase anything.
Hey Becca, Thank you for taking the time to leave a review! We are very sorry to hear about the issue with the discount code. We are more than happy to honor the discount for you and make things right. Please send us an email at [email protected]. We look forward to hearing from you!
Fantastic tackle and great value! I subscribed to the ice fishing box for 3 months to fill in some gaps in my tackle box. It would be nice if you could select tackle that works with snap swivels - some of the eyes were a bit to small for the swivels. Overall though, fantastic!
Everything was great. Super gift idea for kids and friends. Easy to sign up, on time delivery, wonderful.
Why are yall taking money out of my account when I canceled my membership MONTHS AGO? Literally last time I bought from yall was from July of 2024. So for it to come out NOW? Is a little weird. I want my money back now & to never buy from yall again.
Hey Rowdy, Thanks for sharing your feedback with us and we are very sorry about the issue. We would be happy to help fix this issue for you and ensure the problem is resolved. Please send us an email at [email protected] and we would be happy to help! We look forward to hearing from you.
Amazing customer service. Fixed my problem right away! Thank you mystery tackle box team for the great service.
Great tackle and good information about the products. Prompt delivery and love the stickers. Just canceled because I have lots of tackle now but will be back sometime.
Products were great Was able to try different things than I would normally use
Gift for my teenage son. He loved the subscription so much he had it for several years. He liked being able to choose boxes. The repeats were things he chose because he liked them. His truck and archery car are covered in the cool stickers that come in the boxes. 😆 Customer service was and to help me resolve an issue when it was time to end the subscription. Would recommend.
The box is Great!! I had the Pro box and switched between a couple of species. A lot of unique lures and some products I didn't even know existed. Will continue the box once I get to try everything I have received over 2024.
I did not sign up for a yearly and they do not have a contact number that works and I want a refund I ordered this for one year for a kids Christmas present not every year. No way to call and cancel misleading company.
Hey Jacob, Thanks for sharing your review with us! We are very sorry to hear about the trouble you are having canceling your subscription. We'd be more than happy to assist and make sure that your subscription is stopped. Please send us an email at [email protected] We look forward to hearing from you!
I signed up for MTB as a gift for my husband for Father’s Day. I signed up for 6 months and then after that was just automatically charged again and again and again. After canceling (or so I thought) because you have to fill out a survey after canceling for it to actually cancel. I do not want to do your survey. Is this how you steal peoples money? Your subscription is too expensive to just keep charging people.
Hi Makayla, My name is Jeremey, and I am with the customer support team here at MTB. Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback with us. We are very sorry to hear about the issues you are having with canceling your subscription. We do see that you have reached out to us to cancel your subscription but we are having trouble locating your order and your account. We will be sending you another email shortly so we can make sure that your subscription is canceled. Thanks and we look forward to hearing from you.
200 reviews matching
Bison Coolers
www.piscifun.com
Grindout
Loaded
Chow420.com
NHS Skate Direct
Number Artist
Gloriousgaming