About Mystery Tackle Box
Data updated- Website
- mysterytacklebox.com
- Category
- Hobbies & Crafts
- Location
- United States
- Status
- Unclaimed
- Last 12 months
- 9 reviews
- Replies to negative
- 74% (23/31)
Do you own Mystery Tackle Box? Claim this profile for free and start replying to reviews.
About this business
Unlock a world of fishing experiences with our monthly subscriptions. Mystery Tackle Box offers three tiered plans, suited to anglers at all levels and budgets. We’re your fishing buddy in a box! Our team handpicks the catch of the month, delivered straight to your doorstep with an assortment of hardbaits, soft plastics, jigs, hooks, and other tackle.#HappyDance is our motto at HQ. We put our fans first and strive to deliver a positive customer experience every time. Should you have any issues or concerns, reach out to us and we’ll make it right!
Written by the business, not verified by us.Is Mystery Tackle Box legit?
Mystery Tackle Box (mysterytacklebox.com) has a 4.3 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 200 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Hobbies & Crafts and its reputation is good. 82% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 12% are 1 star; The business has replied to 74% of negative reviews; 9 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-25.
What people say
I am so pleased with the customer…
I am so pleased with the customer service, seriously the best in the industry. I signed up for this Karls Mystery Box subscription for my son. He just moved into his first house and I wanted something special to have shipped to him, and have it be the First Package he receives. Well somehow the billing and shipping address ended up being the same. That stressed me out a bit. As soon as I noticed the error, I emailed and shared my disappointment that it's being shipped to the wrong address, and immediately I received an email that they shipped my order to his address and the original order will come to me. Wow that was a lot. But I really appreciate quality agents and the quality service they provide.
i love the brands and specific lures…
i love the brands and specific lures for that time of year. it helps me make sure i’m using the right gear and always using the best gear. i always love the vibrant and funny stickers
Reply from Mystery Tackle Box2024-08-13
Hey Logan! My name is Jeremey with the MTB team. We are very pleased to hear that you are enjoying the products in the box as well as the stickers! Thank you for sharing your feedback about your Mystery Tackle Box; we are happy to have you as a subscriber.
This has exceeded my expectations in…
This has exceeded my expectations in every way
BEST monthly tackle subscription!
I have received a monthly MTB subscription for over 3 years now and I can tell you that it is the BEST way to discover new lures, fish different species and fish with new techniques that you may not think to try!! It has absolutely made me catch more fish, widen my tackle, and expand my knowledge on lures and techniques.
Long time member
I have been a member for a number of years now. I can say that my experience has been great. Customer service is always quick to respond to any inquiry I may have. I have more tackle than I do to have time to fish.
MYB FIR THE WIN!!!
I was a bit apprehensive about getting the subscription as I’ve seen some that are just cheap baits and whatnot. MTB was awesome. I got it for one year and I have filled my tackle box and boat with tons of cool, weird and normal baits. Everything was always good quality and had a lot of big name brand items. I have and will continue to tell friends and family about MTB. 10/10 I highly recommend. I will also be getting more MTB in the future.
Great way to build up supplies for a new fisher!
I purchased the monthly mystery box for my teen son to build up his gear for two years. It arrived every month timely and he absolutely loved opening it each month! He has acquired quite the selection with great results fishing. Customer service is also fantastic!
Was skeptical at first but fell in Love
This is a great product. I got lots of good high end lures. They had a good variety of things to. The website is easy to navigate and change up your box at any point you want. Very much looking forward to getting my next box and I am planning on signing my friends and family up.
Always on-time and great products
Quality lures mostly,best part,most lures are American made, unlike the other boxes
Quality lures mostly,best part most are American made, unlike the other boxes, please feel free to send me free stuff, 😆 support American made products, love my country,would love to see all American made products
Nice to come home to!
I really enjoy getting the boxes on the mail. It's always something different and I look forward to trying what they sent. Always a good deal too! Can't recommended it more!
Experience
Ease of switching as needed to receive products specifically for season or type of fish. Lots of new products that each of my boys enjoyed receiving or learning to use to up their abilities. Customer service was outstanding. I would recommend MTB to any person wishing to get into fishing or add new stuff to their tackle boxes. Sad, that after 5 years, we no longer receive monthly boxes as both boys no longer live at home.
I have a subscription for myself and my…
I have a subscription for myself and my son. My grand children love to watch us open our boxes together. We do this via Facetime and the joy on their faces is worth the price of the subscriptions.
Highly Recommend
It is a Great way to get some variety into tour tacklebox or even just a great way to get Started, quality is Good and you can switch the specialization of each box whenever you like for Added variety.
Overall experience in general very good was very…
Overall experience in general was very good I like their knives I did not like the fact that I received three tactical boxes with the same stuff in it that's okay I still use them I have some spares I gift out the extras
Too many Googan baits
Too many Googan baits, I'd rather get fewer baits of higher quality. If I knew it was a Googan Box, I wouldn't have signed up and paid for an entire year. You will never see a Vision 110 or any other JDM stuff we all use and want. I can get Googan stuff at D's sporting goods,if I wanted them, shelves are full.
Really?!?!?!
My Nephew bought me the Advent Calendar for a Christmas gift. I was excited to open it and see what it contained, box says, over $50 in value. You all must be joking. There isn't $10 worth of tackle in the ENTIRE calendar. I feel disappointed for my Nephew for wasting his money on this. What a scam.
Don't buy it
Don't buy it, had it for almost a year and everything they sent me stinks. Complete waste if your fishing on west coast. Better off shopping in clearance bin I had it for almost year and it's been a waste
Amazing Service
Great quality lures and when I wanted to switch plans their customer service was instantaneous and incredibly helpful and they helped get what I was looking for
Bison Coolers
www.piscifun.com
Grindout
Loaded
Chow420.com
NHS Skate Direct
Number Artist
Gloriousgaming