Really good experience
The pins arrived quickly, were in good condition, and were a very nice quality for the price.
About Pinnyshop
Data updated- Website
- pinnyshop.com
- Category
- Hobbies & Crafts
- Location
- United States · Milton
- Status
- Unclaimed
- Last 12 months
- 38 reviews
Do you own Pinnyshop? Claim this profile for free and start replying to reviews.
Is Pinnyshop legit?
Pinnyshop (pinnyshop.com) has a 5.0 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 61 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Hobbies & Crafts and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 100% rating it 4 stars or higher; 38 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-10.
What people say
Good selection of pins
Good selection of pins. Quick delivery.
Got the pin on time and in good…
Got the pin on time and in good condition.
Got some mystery pins to use for…
Got some mystery pins to use for trading at PAX West! I love buying from Pinny Shop! Fast shipping even to Canada and everything is packed nicely!
Fast shipping and trustworthy
Fast shipping and trustworthy! Pins came exactly as expected
Very good!!!
The pins are amazing quality and worth the price. Postage is delivered within a reasonable time frame with detailed tracking, all the pins are packaged safely and securely ensuring they remain in great quality. 10/10 store and seller recommend highly!!!
Product arrived super fast and as…
Product arrived super fast and as described, great communication before purchase. Excellent Service
Fast shipping and great selection
Great customer service
Ordered pin fodder while at PAX East, expecting to use it for the next convention. I was contacted by a staff member who was at the convention and I was able to recieve my fodder AT the con. Great service, would recommend.
Was easy to order and get the pins.
As always pins are dispatched as soon…
As always pins are dispatched as soon as available, and easy to track. Highly recommend.
Quick fast
Quick fast. Product as expected.
Speedy shipping
Blind Buy Fodder
My order came super fast and all the fodder pins were in excellent condition, perfect for trading at PAX. I would definitely use this option again in the future!
As expected the PinnyShop exceeds…
As expected the PinnyShop exceeds expectations! The quality and selection is unmatched and you know you will get what you bought for a very fair price. They always deliver and will respond to questions and concern quickly and professionally. I have been a customer for about 6 or more years and dont bother looking elsewhere!
Once again Eric is a Rockstar
Once again Eric is a Rockstar. My Pins came quick and exactly what I ordered. Great customer service. Will be buying from again in the future!
Excellent store
This site is always a pleasure to buy from. They have competitive pricing but without the hassle of auctions. They always ship promptly and the pins are well packaged. Thanks!
Quick shipping
Quick shipping, good price on otherwise unobtainable item, great condition and nice packaging
Shipped quickly and responsive to…
Shipped quickly and was responsive to all questions! Fairly priced.
First time purchaser
First time purchaser. I needed some fodder pins for East '26. Everything came well packed and the fodders were a good variety. Will buy again.