Sportsmemorabilia (www.sportsmemorabilia.com) has a 4.2 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 101 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Sports and its reputation is good. 79% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 19% are 1 star; The business has not yet replied to negative reviews; 6 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-11.
Absolutely worthless. They authenticate a card that has no signature. Doncic card had damage. Peeling back bottom and several dot indentations. $28.99 for a card that’s only worth $2. Spent $100 on 3 cards that are only worth max of $6. Real Scam.
Ordered Signed NFL jersey 02/08/2026. Stated ships in 3 to 5 days. Checked my order through their phone system yesterday bc their online status progress still said processing, and as they were closed, identified the cell i was calling from said my order will ship 2026/6/23. I pressed 1 to repeat. 2026/6/23. Five and a half months to ship!!!! This is NOT happening. Extremely deceptive. Not recommended. They should be investigated.
Got handed down a Framed Derrick Rose autographed photo which was specially framed and certified by Sports memorabilia. Over the years the frame got damaged. I reached out to them to see if I could get it reframed. I was even willing to ship it myself and pay whatever the cost would be. They refused to help me saying that since it was purchased before 2011 and because I didn’t have the original order number I was S.O.L. Terrible experience and service. They should back their products!
Ordered a helmet case on 11-29 with an estimated delivery of 12-15. Order status was still pending after the 15th, called in. Received new shipping date of Jan 9. Called back on Jan 21. Was told would receive an email within 48 hrs with an update. Next day received email telling me my cancelation request is being processed. Called back in. Order was being canceled because item was out of stock. Funny thing is their website says in stock, ships within 5 days. Was told website would update soon but it has said in stock since I originally bought it.
I ordered 2 signed photos from this site came in pristine condition and as described and came with coa
Purchased a coin from this company was selling on Amazon. Was described to be XF / VF condition. Upon receiving the coin discovered it was at best Good condition. From what I'm reading I am not the only customer to be scammed by this so called store! BEWARE! SCAMMERS
I purchased a Derek Jeter signed 8x10 from this company back on February 9, 2016. I just found out today the autograph is actually forged. Fake!!! I wouldn’t feel comfortable purchasing from Sportsmemorabilia.com in the future. SM holo#T247989 even shows in their database. After the latest Mister Mancave scandal, everyone should seek second opinions for items in their collection, ‘authenticated’ or not. There is a ton of counterfeit items out there…
Horrible Operations From This Company Ordered something for Father's Day and was supposed to be here in time for Father's Day. Not only did it not come in time, but it was pushed back to October!! 6 Months Later.... Even better - they gave me no notification of this and it doesn't even update on their site. Horrible operations
I ordered an autographed plaque for my brother's birthday and I paid an extra $25 for Rush delivery which stated that it would be here by my brother's birthday. It did not show up for my brother's birthday and when I contacted sportsmemorabilia.com they stated that it would take an additional 10 days. When I asked why I paid the extra $25 for rushford delivery if it's going to take more than 10 days. They had no answer and wouldn't even refund the additional $25. Clearly this company is run terribly and they do not do good business. Do not order from them. They are completely unprofessional. I will go anywhere but them going forward. Terrible business and I will also be reporting them to the better Business bureau.
About six weeks ago, my wife bought a costly gift for me from their store, hoping it would arrive in time for Christmas. Now, on Christmas Eve, we still haven't received it. After reaching out to them, she learned that the item was never actually in stock. Over the last month, she had made numerous calls and was repeatedly told that it would arrive on schedule. This news has left her feeling heartbroken. It's hard to fathom a company that could be more indifferent and unreliable, especially in a field where trust is crucial.
I am very disappointed. Order got delayed w/out any notification and ruined Christmas for my daughter. I ordered something for my daughter for Christmas on 12/9 and when I placed the order they said it would ship by 12/12 and I would receive it by 12/17. I received an email saying it shipped and all was fine (with no tracking number, which was another mistake on their end) and when I looked into it on 12/19 and called them, I found out it wasn't going to arrive until after christmas. Their customer service offered me no kind of resolution at all. I asked if I could order something else and have it expedited, could they call UPS and get this expedited. They simply said I had to call UPS. And of course UPS has no desire to help me since this was not their mistake to begin with. its too late to order from somewhere else and now I can't get the only thing my daughter asked for christmas. So disappointed. will never shop here again.
Pure bait and switch! Item ordered was not the same as item shipped. Customer service very difficult to contact via phone (45+ minutes in queue). Order was not cancelled despite request to do so. No return/refund policy for item was not disclosed during online ordering process.
Pricing for this site is horrible. Changes all the time and when they run a sale, they jack up the prices to make it seem like you’re getting a deal. Dealing with them on eBay is just as bad as they also raise the price and then offer you a sale. Very deceptive.
I ordered a jersey with them and they “voided” my order first with out contacting me before doing so and when I contacted them about it they said it was to prevent fraud and the money will be back in my account in 1-5 buisness days it’s been over a week and I still have yet to see the money back and keep getting sent in circles. I had to contact my bank for them todo a fraud investigation for an order that was almost 1k.
Heartbroken. Thousands were spent on a signed ball that has almost no signature. Have been calling for years but customer service has never helped.
I ordered an item. They shipped three. I spoke to them both by phone and email and left them know I only wanted the one item. That the other two were still in the package and I would return to them. They strung me on for a couple of weeks then told me that wouldn’t do a return. I wouldn’t recommend this company to anyone
Cristin was instrumental in locating my package and getting it shipped. She rocks!
I have purchased before from Sportsmemorabilia and never had any issues. This is my first experience with an issue and Cristin was great! She resolved it quickly and responded quickly! Thanks Cristin.
Cristin provided me with excellent customer service! I will continue shopping at SportsMemorabilia.com!
Sheilah provided excellent customer service and was a pleasure to talk with.
101 reviews matching