Very quick responses and payment
Very quick responses and payment. Great customer service.. I had a good past experience (years ago) so when I was in the market again, I used them, again. Happy to recommend!
Get cash for all your unwanted and unused gold jewelry today with safe FedEx insured shipping. See why we have a reputation for honesty in the cash for gold industry!
GoldFellow (goldfellow.com) has a 5.0 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 101 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Money & Insurance and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 100% rating it 4 stars or higher; 50 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-09-05.
Very quick responses and payment. Great customer service.. I had a good past experience (years ago) so when I was in the market again, I used them, again. Happy to recommend!
The process was easy and very quick. I also talked with Mary and she was so friendly and helpful.
Goldfellow made it so easy to sale my gold too. I really liked how they broke down the settlement for me. I would definitely recommend them to anyone.
Very Professional. Very very. They handled everything so easily too. Lightning fast service. I highly recommend as I was recommended by a friend as well. I will also be recommending Goldfellow & will do more business with them myself. Zero complaints at all. A++ Company
Very fast and easy to do!
I could not believe how fast everything happened. I randomly googled where to sell gold and shipped it out based on the reviews. Next thing you know it arrives from California to Florida getting paid the same day. The whole experience was great and I was paid fairly for what I presented. Thank you gold fellows
The whole transaction was completed within a week, including receiving the check in the mail for the items I submitted.
Great communication with employees, I had a question and was shocked that an actual person answered the line (that spoke clearly) and got my questions answered quick. Their turnaround time is great. Fantastic experience, 10/10
I sent the gold and 2 days later received an offer. I guess I requested a check as payment? Anyway I still don't have my money. I received a call and my money was transferred to my account immediately. Estimate was fair. Service very good.
The shipping process was simple and paid for by the company. The response was fast, and the offer was fair. Very happy with my experience.
Very prompt service, good and fair offer
I feel the transaction was easy and fair and was quite enjoyable!!!!
They sent me a prepaid FedEx envelope to send my class ring to them. They evaluated it promptly and provided a rapid offer to me which seemed reasonable. They sent me a check promptly. I cannot think of any negative aspects of this transaction and I am quite pleased with it. Thank you for a smooth, painless transaction and perhaps we can do business again in the future. - Chris
Mary was great to deal with. Kept me informed of the process. Would recommend to anyone looking to sell jewelry
Fast, friendly and honest
It was quick and easy and all went great!
Great deal! Will return
Very customer friendly and easy process. No out of pocket cost for customers.
The folks at Goldfellow are ethical and do everything they say they will do. If you send jewelry to them, they will promptly evaluate it and make an offer. If you agree to their offer, you will likely get paid the same day. Mary and Michael are a pleasure to do business with and you will definitely feel good about your experience. It’s obvious they have developed a culture that prioritizes treating clients honestly and respectfully. These are traits not often found in this day and age.
Thank you Robert for your kind words. It was a pleasure assisting you! Hope to speak to you again. Please let your friends know about your experience! Best regards, GoldFellow
101 reviews matching