Mysterious Shop (mysterious.americanmcgee.com) has a 4.7 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 67 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 92% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 40% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
I've spent over 6k in the past year, the company is wonderful however, the company they use for delivery is absolutely horrible. I've emailed about them a few times and the issues I've had and they don't care. I have a delivery box to deliver in with multiple clear as day signs and half the time they don't do shat is asked which out my dog into a seizure
I ordered the autism bunny plush and it came home safe and intact. The quality is good, but they are hand-sown, and the inner ear pieces did get sown on upside down (another one I ordered from the same model did have the fabric the right way around), making me rather not pet those. The magnet on the face is placed more on the cheek than the mouth, so the arm isn't covering the mouth like in the pictures. But the rest was all as expected and I'm happy with the purchase of a new plush bunny friend
Both my friend and I LOVED our Plushie - Fibromyalgia for her, hEDS for me. It feels wonderful to see our conditions represented, something that I have always felt doesn't often happen. The plushies are excellently made and were definitely worth the cost - especially as they came with brilliant tote bags, too.
I love the Mysterious Shop and buy from it all of the time (mostly for my girlfriend—she has an unholy amount of plushies by now). It's wonderful to see even more niche illnesses represented and the quality is great. Plus, I really love American McGee's Alice. Overall, I'd definitely recommend those plushies if you have the money to spare.
I know without a doubt that every time I purchase from Plushie Dreadful it will be a great experience & I've never been disappointed. They make their items with so much care & quality materials. Each item feels like it was made just for me! I highly recommend shopping with them to everyone & believe with all my heart that everyone needs at least one of these plushies in their life!
I enjoy purchasing items from your site! Items are well made and arrive in a timely manner. The Victorian McGee's Mock Turtle is a birthday gift for my daughter, Liz, she collects all things "Alice in Wonderland ", she will absolutely love this! Plushie Dreadfuls is a sweet site! Kudos for addressing mental illness with some of your products, you don't know what a true blessing it is!
Amazing quality, and surprisingly fast international shipping. I started with just one, now I have 10 for myself, and 3 that I have gotten as gifts. Bringing it back to the speedy shipping. My last order was meant for a few friends birthdays that lined up together. Had to hide them for almost a month until I could gift them, and I created new fans with them. Plus every order has had small extras even during promotional events, which happen often.
67 reviews matching