Mysterious Shop (mysterious.americanmcgee.com) has a 4.7 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 67 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 92% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 40% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
I ordered the first time and shipping took about 2 weeks, and when I finally received my American McGee alice rabbit I was just in awe. Besides the cute other item's that come with the order which is just super cute. I really love her, you can feel and see the love and dedication that was put into her and im sure many of their other plushies.
Great shop, great items, helpful when problems arise
I highly recommend this store! The website is trustworthy, the plushies are premium quality and very well made. The support team is fast, friendly, and extremely helpful. Overall, a great shopping experience—I can only recommend them!
I love their plushies. They truly make you feel seen. The quality is great and the delivery is surprisingly quick. They also respond fast if clients have any concerns.
I had some gifts sent through Throne for my birthday and the address was incorrect. They were able to stop one from being mis-delivered, but unfortunately the other was not so lucky. they still sent me a replacement free of charge to make up for it and they were kind and you could tell it was a real person the entire time. Not only are the products high quality, they come with little side things like a pen and custom matching bag that make the purchase feel so worth it.
I have ordered from them many times and the experiences were consistently good. The orders processed fast and packaged well. The plushies are great quality. I really appreciate how responsive and quick they helped resolve a missed free gift in one of my orders. The plushies bring me so much joy and comfort - I love them!
Very happy with my order. Adore my items. Customer support is awesome.
I bought the shy girl goth plush while opening the package it smelled super fishy it was disgusting will not be purchasing again
Absolutely LOVE this company! Always quick to respond to any questions or concerns and their plushies are amazing!! Will definitely be buying more in the future!
The bunnies help me feel seen and heard. And they are just the right size to take to doctor appointments and squeeze when I get stressed or panic. My friend and I always get excited for the little extras, the pen, the patches, whatever. My optometrist adjusted both of one of my bunnies glasses for me. I said, "thank you, it really helps. "
I bought several plushies and mystery bags from them. Everything has been high quality and great, and delivery was pretty quick.
My girlfriend really enjoyed it great attention to detail
The best plushies, bar none! So soft. Great details. Shipping was quick and efficient.
Love, love, love the items we bought! They do take a little while to get here, but definitely worth the wait. The fibromyalgia bunny is my softest stuffed animal, and so full of thoughtful symbolism. Thank you!
The quality of the product, the variety for any and all. There is something for everybody. I have bought a good number for myself and my nieces.
I have looked for crazy looking stuff animals that fit my darker side and they hit the mark. Plus they cover every disease from Chronic pain to ptsd
I've gotten plenty of plushies from them and none have disappointed, each plushy has been made of great materials, with nice details, and are very cuddly. Favorite so far has been the black hole rabbit :> So far I've gotten nine or ten plushies and each have been excellent
I've bought a few things over the years, mainly the mystery bags they started doing and the fact that you get so much stuff for so little is amazing. The quality of everything is top notch and everything is super thoughtful and just really heartwarming.
67 reviews matching