Postfly (postflybox.com) has a 4.1 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 103 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Hobbies & Crafts and its reputation is good. 76% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 19% are 1 star; The business has replied to 23% of negative reviews; 4 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-10.
I purchased a one time 4 month gift subscription. There was no indication that it renewed and yet it did. Postfly sent me to my account to the - non-existent - Manage Subscriptions button which per their communication was consistent with a non-renewing subscription. And yet..... the charges and boxes continue to come despite weeks of email communication. DO NOT USE POSTFLY.
Poor customer service response. Monthly fly box subscriptions delayed or have not arrived. Very small amount of actual useful products in very small package. I would definitely not recommend this company.
I purchased a fly tying kit for my husband for Christmas. My knowledge base is very minimal. I bought the wrong kit ( salt water instead of the trout kit.) Fred from Post Fly was amazing. Got back to me quickly, sent me the trout kit, and let us keep the salt water kit. ( I had opened it all up to look at it). This was completely my error, but the customer service was top notch and better than anything I have ever experienced. The kit’s were fantastic, and my husband has been impressed with the quality . Highly highly recommend getting all of your Fly Fishing needs from Post Fly. I know we will!
Avoid this company. I ordered their Fishmas Calendar and never received it. They don't respond to emails and the phone number on their site leads to nowhere.
Ordered as a gift. Paid and received nothing. Crooks. No answer on email or phone.
i like the products and the monthly surprise fly tying kit. that said their customer service is beyond terrible. they have no interest in providing customer service. it is all email or chat but you can actually never get anyone on chat. a recent order had hooks with beads that slipped off the hook. i reached out several ways and noone has responded. you cannot talk to a live person so i am forced to wait. they do not seem to care.
Ordered a six month gift subscription for my son and they only sent four. No response from their customer service and I can’t file a credit card dispute because the charge was made in December.
My son loved his advent calendar with flies. He is hard to buy for, so it was a great hit! Thank you👍
I placed an order of 2 items, I only received 1. I contacted Postfly and they reshipped. That shipment was sent to the wrong state. I contacted them again. I received an apology and they resent the item, BUT also included SEVERAL (free to me) items for their error!
Subscription boxes come with useless stuff. Not worth the money
Jack was super helpful in making sure I received my order.
Super kind and extremely helpful. Responded super fast and helped me out in a big way!!! Much appreciated
Jack at Postfly has always been clutch. I’ve orderded quite a few products from Postfly and the customer service is always top notch.
Jack went out of his way to correct my mistake. Top notch customer service.
Always responds within the day packages are never damaged highly recommend postfly for any fly fisherman
Jack made my experience great. They send you Quality items at a great price. I will definitely use them in the future
This company is great. Excellent products and world class customer service
Postfly has amazing customer service!!! Very fast to respond and quick to remedy any issues. Top notch customer experience!!!
Personal service! A human (Jack) reached out and handled my issue quickly and was very kind in doing so. They've made a fan out of me.
103 reviews matching