Postfly (postflybox.com) has a 4.1 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 103 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Hobbies & Crafts and its reputation is good. 76% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 19% are 1 star; The business has replied to 23% of negative reviews; 4 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-10.
I have been a customer since 2022 and Postfly has some of the best customer service and send great products every month. I fish for trout in the western mountains and the flys are always great. The best part of the box though is the monthly surprise product that’s always a great addition to you fishing bag. Last month was a nice Yeti cup.
I've purchase from Postfly previously and had a wonderful experience. Today I realized I used the wrong email for my shipping notifications. Once I realized, I sent an email to their support for help. I received an email back from their support within 15 minutes and my problem was fixed. Great products, great service!
Able to replace rod quickly so I can get back to it.
Great service. Very responsive.
This is by far the best experience I have had with online ordering. When I have questions or request a change in any of the ordered materials they respond and do their best to accommodate!
Jack was super helpful in making sure my package had the right address. He even went the extra step to update my address on my account, thanks!
Postfly has been very helpful and is a great company and they have a great team. They also have a great warranty system in case of accidents, I 110% recommended postfly and can’t thank them enough for all they’ve done for me
Always quick to respond to questions and answers.
Great product and responsive support. The flies are high quality and the literature they send along with them is useful. They were also quick to get back to me when I had questions. Definitely recommend
Handled an unfortunate situation well and compensated me according.
Jack was great and took care of all of my issues!
Super helpful, solved my issue instantly!!
Postfly is awesome, very supportive, the fly tying kits are so much fun, I’m learning how to tie flys with the help of professionals!! Very Happy!!
I really enjoy my Post Fly membership it’s like getting a present each month. Great quality an always get more than your money worth.
Jack was super helpful in understanding exactly what I was asking, and knowing what options were available to me.
A fun monthly box to get your blood pumping for the next fly fishing trip! It’s like Christmas every month and all beneficial for your fly fishing adventures!
Postfly gave me my first set of flies to fish with starting out. Now I look forward to monthly tying kits that have taken my tying skills up a notch! Prompt (almost immediate) service from their team!
Great product. Guys really know their stuff
Quick response and amazing customer service
103 reviews matching