Smiths Surplus and Supply (smithssurplusandsupply.com) has a 4.7 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 62 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Sports and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 91% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews; 56 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-10.
What people say
M
M · 1 review · Verified · Experienced 2026-07-30 ·
★★★★★
Item as described
Quick and easy purchase. Item was as described. The item shipped quickly from seller. My only hiccup was while tracking the package it arrived at my local UPS location and sat for 3 days to be transferred to USPS for final delivery on the 4th day after arriving locally. Like anything I order online waiting is tough.
I did not expect a “used” pouch that cost five bucks to show up looking brand new, but this one did! Unbelievable value, quick shipping, great communication.
I ordered the 2 quart canteen cover x2, but they did not come with the carry straps.
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-07-23
Hi,
Thanks for your feedback. We’re sorry this wasn’t what you expected.
The 2 Quart Insulated Canteen Covers you ordered are listed in Good condition, and the product description notes that the carry strap is missing on these covers. We try to call that out clearly so customers know exactly what they’re purchasing before ordering.
If there’s anything else about your order that wasn’t as described, please reach out to us directly at [email protected]. We’re always happy to help and want to make sure you receive exactly what you expected.
Thank you for your review! We’re glad you found our website easy to navigate and that your order arrived just as expected. Whether you’re shopping for military surplus or looking for a trusted online Army Navy Store, we work hard to make the experience simple from browsing to checkout. Thanks again for your support—we look forward to serving you again soon.
L
Larry · 17 reviews · Verified · Experienced 2026-07-15 ·
★★★★★
Awesome experience
Awesome experience. I found Smith's site online last year, logged on and put some great looking US Mil items into my cart around thanksgiving, just could not spare the extra to complete the purchase then. Glad I remembered them and went back online to add to my cart and complete the order. Very pleased with the items, their costs, the quality, and will definitely order from Smiths in future. I have shared their site with several friends too
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-07-24
Thank you so much for your support and for coming back to us! It means a lot that you remembered Smith’s Surplus after all that time. We’re glad to hear you were happy with the value, quality, and condition of your gear—that’s exactly what our inspection and grading process is meant to deliver. We also really appreciate you recommending us to your friends. Word of mouth is one of the biggest compliments a small business can receive. We look forward to getting you outfitted again on your next mission!
Thank you for your review, Brian! We’re glad to hear you had a great all-around experience with Smith’s Surplus. We work hard to provide quality military surplus, accurate condition grading, and fast shipping, so it’s great to know we delivered. We appreciate your support and hope to serve you again soon.
L
Larry · 17 reviews · Verified · Experienced 2026-07-08 ·
★★★★★
Very Pleased. Great experience with my first of…
Great experience with my first of several orders for your product you offer. Especially for more of the US Military surplus items I just received from Smiths. I actually had placed many items in my online cart back in November and December last year but just did not complete the order then. Glad 8 months later, I was able to add more items and quantities, and complete that big "wishlist." Many of the items just received appear new, UN-issued condition, and any that been issued, only had soldiers' names or initials written in marker on them adding uniqueness and more authenticity to them.
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-07-15
Thank you for the great review and for coming back to complete that eight-month wishlist! We’re glad you were pleased with the condition of the gear and found several items that appeared unissued.
Names and initials are part of the history and authenticity of genuine military surplus, but if you ever decide you’d rather remove them, 90% rubbing alcohol followed by Amodex can often remove permanent marker or at least make it much less visible. We have more cleaning and care tips in our guide here:
https://smithssurplusandsupply.com/gear-survival-pro-tips-for-cleaning-military-surplus-gear/
We truly appreciate your first order and look forward to helping with the next one!
My hydration pouch came with a bunch of idk what inside of it. How can I send you a picture
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-07-15
Hi Isaiah,
We’re sorry to hear there was something inside the hydration pouch. Please email photos along with your order number to [email protected] so we can inspect the issue and help resolve it.
Trustpilot is a review platform rather than a customer service channel, so we’re unable to receive photos or properly investigate an order here. We always encourage customers to contact us directly before leaving a review so we have an opportunity to address any concerns.
Once we receive your email, we’ll be happy to take a closer look.
Smiths Surplus Customer Service
The quality of the ATAPs was amazing and got to me quick
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-07-24
Thank you, Sebas! We’re glad to hear your ATAP arrived quickly and exceeded your expectations. We work hard to inspect and grade every Tactical Assault Panel before it ships, so it’s great to know the quality stood out. We appreciate your support and hope your new ATAP serves you well for many years. Thanks again for choosing Smith’s Surplus!
Been looking for this chest rig. Easy to purchase, still waiting for delivery but confident they will deliver on time.
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-07-15
Thank you for your order! We shipped your Airborne TAP Rig the same day it was placed, and tracking now shows it has been delivered. We hope it was exactly what you were looking for and appreciate you choosing Smiths Surplus.
I ordered two new army duffel bags. One of them is new and in good condition, the second is used and falling apart.
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-06-25
Steven,
We’re sorry to hear you were disappointed with your order.
We do want to clarify one important point: these duffle bags were not listed or sold as new. They are listed as previously issued military surplus in good condition. The product description notes that they may show signs of use, including permanent marker, scuffs, stains, tape residue, repairs, and even painted markings.
After receiving your email, we responded the same day and asked for photos of the duffle bag you described as “falling apart” so we could review the issue and determine the appropriate resolution. When we did not hear back, we followed up again a few days later, but unfortunately never received a response.
While cosmetic wear is expected with previously issued military surplus, every bag we ship should still be functional and serviceable. If that was not the case here, we wanted the opportunity to review it and make it right.
Our offer still stands. Please send us a few photos of the bag, and we’ll gladly review the issue.
— Smiths Surplus Customer Service
C
CHRIS JOHNSON · 1 review · Verified · Experienced 2026-06-13 ·
★★★★★
Order wrnt out quickly and item was as…
Order wrnt out quickly and item was as advertised.
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-06-25
Thank you for your review!
We’re glad your order arrived quickly and was exactly as advertised. Accurate descriptions and fast, reliable shipping are priorities for us, so it’s great to hear we delivered on both.
S
Sandra Kate · 1 review · Experienced 2026-04-27 ·
★★★★★
Great company
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-07-24
Thank you, Sandra! We really appreciate your kind words. Our goal is to be a trusted source for genuine U.S. military surplus and provide the kind of service you’d expect from a great Army Navy Store. Thanks for your support—we look forward to serving you again!
H
HENRY H SCHMEDES · 4 reviews · Verified · Experienced 2026-03-07 ·
★★★★★
Item looks unused
Item looks unused. Very nice!
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-07-24
Thank you, Henry! We’re glad to hear your item exceeded your expectations. Finding military surplus in outstanding condition is always rewarding, and our inspection and grading process is designed to identify gear that looks as close to unissued as possible. We appreciate your support and hope to see you back at Smith’s Surplus soon!
Product was exactly as described, with a very quick turnaround. The cargo capacity was more than I expected. It will be great for backcountry fishing excursions! Thank you, Smith's
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-03-13
Thanks for the great review! We’re glad the USGI MOLLE II Waist Pack worked out for you—and that’s a fantastic use for it. A lot of folks don’t realize how useful military surplus gear can be for backcountry fishing and outdoor adventures.
If you ever want to expand your setup, you might also like the MOLLE II Fighting Load Carrier (FLC) Vest:
https://smithssurplusandsupply.com/product/molle-ii-fighting-load-carrier-vest-flc-acu/
It’s a fully modular platform, so you can mount pouches exactly where you want them. You could even clip your waist pack directly onto the FLC to create a completely customizable fishing vest with more capacity and better weight distribution.
Thanks again for supporting Smiths Surplus—we appreciate it, and tight lines on those backcountry trips! 🎣
M
Matt L · 2 reviews · Verified · Experienced 2026-02-03 ·
★★★★★
Great company
Great company. Everything was as described and arrived quickly. Definitely recommend.
Reply from Smiths Surplus and Supply2026-03-13
Thanks for the kind words—we really appreciate it! Glad everything arrived quickly and exactly as described. That’s always our goal at Smiths Surplus: honest descriptions, fast turnaround, and solid military surplus gear you can rely on.
Thanks again for the recommendation and for supporting Smiths Surplus!