Very great quality and very fast
Very great quality and very fast. Love the communication between the team and I.
About Keyzar Jewelry
Data updated- Website
- www.keyzarjewelry.com
- Category
- Shopping & Fashion
- Location
- United States · New York
- Status
- Unclaimed
- Last 12 months
- 61 reviews
- Replies to negative
- 100% (2/2)
Do you own Keyzar Jewelry? Claim this profile for free and start replying to reviews.
Is Keyzar Jewelry legit?
Keyzar Jewelry (www.keyzarjewelry.com) has a 4.8 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 61 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 95% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
What people say
Great!
Fair price, fast production and shipping! Sizing guide was accurate and the ring was just as we expected and wanted!
Great selection and quality
The ability to find the quality of stone with varied choices. All competitively priced.
As always Keyzar didn’t disappoint
As always Keyzar didn’t disappoint. I ordered my finances engagement ring and of course had to get the matching band for our upcoming wedding. Love this company!
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-08-03
You always come first for us, and making sure everything is a perfect match is what it’s all about! We are so excited to be a part of your love story. Congratulations🥂
Great ring
Item delivered timely and as expected. Beautiful ring at a great price.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-08-03
On time, beautiful, and a great price… the perfect combo! 😜 Truly the things that matter most. Thank you so much for the love! 💗 Team Keyzar💍
So where do I start
So where do I start? This company caught my eye through tireless searching on IG and eventually I think I got an ad. I was looking at their tagged photos found out they were legit & the quality looked good on peoples photos. I ran to the website and I started to look for the style my wife wanted. I scheduled a meeting for the virtual appointment since I am in the south and their room is located in New York. And I was very pleased with Stevens help explain the bowtie effect and what to look for… when I went back on the site to pick my stone I felt like I had the parameters I needed to make a good choice and I did. He helped me with understand where I get the most bang for my budget. And that was great but not the end. After I mentioned that I would doing a destination proposal and needed my ring shipped with the standard time. Not only did they overnight my ring but they did this immediately after I sent the email explaining my situation. 10s for Keyzar and people have already began asking me who I got my ring from. So all my friends will be likely shopping with Keyzar next.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-08-03
Wow, we truly have the best customers! Thank you so much for such a thoughtful review. We always strive to make sure that not only the jewelry is perfect, but the whole experience is just as special. And Steven really is something else, he puts his absolute whole heart into everything he does! Wishing you both a lifetime of happiness💖
amazing service and quality
not knowing anything I was helped through the process and educated along the way without feeling the pressure to upsell. Highly recommended and very good service
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-08-03
Gutsche, We’re so happy to hear this!! It’s so important to us to make the whole experience easy and comfortable for you. Thank you for trusting us and for the wonderful recommendation! ❤️ Team Keyzar
The ring is beautiful
The ring I ordered is beautiful and just know it’ll be to my future wife’s taste, thank you so much.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-28
David, So happy to hear that! We’re so sure she’s going to absolutely love it! 💍💕
Keyzar has the customer service most…
Keyzar has the customer service most companies can only dream of having. They are so quick to respond, kind, courteous, and they go above and beyond for their customers. Living in another state makes you a little nervous to make such a big purchase but they have helped make our engagement experience unforgettable.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-28
Our team really is something special, and we are so excited to be a part of your story. Congratulations on your engagement, Sarah!🌷 Team Keyzar💍
Beautiful ring
Beautiful ring, great price and delivered on time to meet a deadline! Thank you!
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-27
The holy trinity: beauty, price, and timing! 😜 We’re so glad we delivered on all three.!!
Ring looks amazing
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-27
Kim, That is so awesome to hear! Enjoy your new ring! 💍✨
Bowtie in oval diamond that wasn't…
Bowtie in oval diamond that wasn't visible in the pictures of the product. I feel cheated.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-27
Hello David, I am so sorry to hear that the diamond you selected fell short for you upon seeing it in person, and even more so that you feel so poorly regarding our reliability. As you are squarely inside your eligibility period for an exchange of the diamond - or even a return for your purchase as a whole - I feel certain that we can improve upon your experience one way or the other. Please rest assured that your satisfaction is of the utmost importance to us, and you may expect an email directly to you soon in order to discuss more thoroughly your concerns and our options going forward. Looking forward to working together in getting you a ring you are well and truly in love with! Best regards, Emma, Support team manager
RING
The transaction from looking for a ring to designing it and finally to receiving the ring was all very easy comfortable and PERFECT !
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-27
We love being part of the process from start to finish to make sure everything comes out perfect. Thank you so much Jay🌷
The Best
One of the best jewelry stores I have ever worked with. Amazing customer service and beautiful jewelry.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-27
That truly means so much to us! Thank you so much for the kind words and for sharing! 💖
Very happy with the setting only…
Very happy with the setting only purchase, was a fair price and my jeweler commented on the quality of the work multiple times. Ring came out stunning and received it very quickly despite it being custom sized to the stone I had.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-27
Mason, So happy to hear that! We always try our best to make sure everything comes out perfect. Thank you so much for sharing! ✨
Order was smooth and customer service…
Order was smooth and customer service was amazing. They were quick to answer questions and were able to make a last minute customization to the ring without any trouble. I proposed yesterday and my girlfriend…I mean, fiancé…hasn’t stopped smiling about the ring. 10/10 would recommend!
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-16
Mario, We are honestly so happy for you guys! Huge congratulations, and we are just so glad we could play a small part in your love story. Wishing you both the very best! 💖
Customer service was very prompt and…
Customer service was very prompt and helpful with any questions or concerns I had.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-13
Konner, Thank you so much! ✨ We always try to be there for our customers whenever they need us.💗
Excellent customer service team
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-13
We really appreciate it. Our team is truly the best!!!🥰
Loved it so much I ordered from here again
This is my second time ordering from Keyzar. They are simply amazing. I saw a wedding band that I loved but didn't know how it would look with my engagement ring, also from there, so I got connected to someone and they were so helpful! 100% recommended to anyone looking for their forever rings.
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-13
Emily, it’s so exciting for us to feel like we’re a part of your story. Making sure every little detail is perfect and that your rings match beautifully is so important to us! 💖 Keyzar Team💍
Amazing customer service
Amazing customer service, amazing products!!!
Reply from Keyzar Jewelry2026-07-09
Amazing customers like you make it all worth it!!! Thank you so much for the love, it seriously means the world to us! 🤍