Priority Tire LLC (prioritytire.com) has a 4.5 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 101 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Vehicles & Transportation and its reputation is excellent. 88% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 8% are 1 star; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews. Last updated 2026-08-10.
Priority Tire offered a reasonable price for a set of tires I was in need of so I now own a set.
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
We're glad that you gave us a shot and found our offer to be economically shrewd - we're confident you'll find great long-term value in your order, and we do thank you for your kind review!
J
Juan Rosales · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-23 ·
★★★★★
Fast delivery and excellent product.
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
We do think the pricing helps seal the deal as most impressive, too! We're sure you'll find great value in your order!
We're sure your next order will be even better, and that your recommendations will make a lot of people quite happy, too!
H
Henry Jordan · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-16 ·
★★★★★
The online ordering process was very…
The online ordering process was very smooth. The tire price was the lowest I could find. The tires arrived quickly. I ordered them over the weekend and they arrived within 3 business days. They are in great shape and arrived as advertised. Very pleased with my purchase. I have 5 vehicles . When my other vehicles need tires, I'll order from Priority Tire again.5 stars!!!
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
It's awesome to hear that everything went exactly as you hoped for, and we will keep putting in great efforts to ensure that every single order is just as fantastic - your fleet will be well equipped, for sure! Thank you!
D
David Payne · 4 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-08 ·
★★★★★
Great to deal with
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
We do try to keep things simple, smooth and most convenient - we're glad you found it that way!
S
Sal · 6 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-14 ·
★★★★★
fast shipping, good price
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Nice combination for all of our customers, the necessary building blocks for a great experience! Thank you!
B
Bean Office · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-10 ·
★★★★★
Excellence in speedy shipping
Excellence in speedy shipping. I haven’t yet mounted the tires waiting to put our lift on our 1977 Ford F150 4x4. Excited to see the new look.
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
We're glad that you're excited just as we are that our service is excellent - and we're confident your vintage F150 will look all spiffy and exciting, too!
T
TWM · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-20 ·
★★★★★
Smooth transaction for certain
Smooth transaction for certain! Good pricing plus quick shipping via FedEx. I chose home delivery because I used a mobile installation service. Bottom line…Priority Tire is highly recommended.
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
We do offer both shipping to your home as well as any address of your choice, really - but we indeed also offer our affiliated installers, which does include mobile ones that can come to your address! Your recommendation is most appreciated, and we're glad to have earned it! Thank you!
S
Stanley M. · 4 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-08 ·
★★★★★
Great prices
Great prices. Arrived quickly!
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
We endeavor to make sure all orders arrive ASAP via our advanced Free Shipping, and maintain the best possible prices along the way! Thank you for your support!
J
John Halliday · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-02 ·
★★★★★
Great
Great, everything as expected
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Next time we'll make sure to even exceed your expectations!
B
Bazhan Oleh · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-14 ·
★★★★★
225/60R18 Dunlop Grandtrek ST30
Order Number: 000912630Scam! Priority Tire sent me an old, unsafe tire and ignores my messages!I ordered a 225/60r18 Dunlop Grandtrek ST30 tire (Order #000912630), but this company sent me an expired, outdated product. The tire clearly shows the DOT code 0721, which means it was manufactured in early 2021.It is now 2026, making this tire over 5 years old! Rubber degrades over time even when stored in a warehouse, making it a major safety hazard on the road. Selling 5-year-old tires as new is completely unacceptable.To make matters worse, their customer support is completely ignoring my emails and chats. I demand a full refund and a free return shipping label immediately. Do not buy from them!
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Certainly we do apologize for any delayed responses, as our agents are doing all they can amidst a lot of incoming traffic; we've since replied to you multiple times and offered help, including a Free Return, which has resulted in a finalized return and full refund, per your request.
With that said, we do not sell old or unsafe tires, and do not engage in any "scams".
As you know, we do sell tires of variable ages, which is indeed advertised and disclosed all over our website. Although sometimes a specific tire age is listed, most of the time it is physically not possible to guarantee a specific age for a given tire inventory - which is almost never an issue, as we do all we can to ensure that we only ever send out tires in excellent, untouched NEW condition.
Tire ages can vary, but most of our inventory is indeed no more than a year old, although some tires can be older, up to about 3 years of age. To that end we do agree that 5 years is a too much, and can advise that it was not purposely or willingly sent out like that. With that said, we did understand your concern and thusly provided you with a Free Return.
Truthfully, we strongly disagree with the implication that older tires are in any way a hazard, which is at this point a widely disproven implication - that is why we do sometimes sell older tires like this, although exclusively with disclosed ages for transparency.
At any rate, regardless of your opinion on 5-year-old tires, the fact of the matter is that we do not wish to ever send tires of such ages under a general listing, so you're completely correct that it was a mistake on our part - though not intentional in any way, and not hazardous in any way.
We'll endeavor to further improve both our inventory handling and customer service however as we clearly need to avoid issues of this nature, as we do not ever wish to confuse or frustrate our customers.
Thank you for your understanding and we do earnestly apologize for any inconvenience caused.
Sounds like it was great all around, just as it should be - we'll keep it that way!
T
Travis J · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-06 ·
★★★★★
2 day delivery - very kind delivery man
I was not home for the delivery as I was at work. Only my mom and my aunt was in my house when it happened the delivery driver saw my older family members and offered to bring it inside the house and climbing steel footsteps. I want to thank the delivery driver and the company for being so kind. It took two days from the order date for a full set of tires. Will order again
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Ultimately individual deliveries are entirely up to the individual delivery crews, but we do all we can on our end to foster productive and healthy relationships with our carriers - we're glad that you felt that here, and we likewise thank the delivery person for their efforts as we do you for your kind words!
M
Michael Humes · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-06 ·
★★★★★
Priority has been a valuable resource…
Priority has been a valuable resource for our company. Quality products at awesome prices
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
We're glad to support both the Average Joe and small businesses alike with our tires and service, and more than appreciate your support!
L
Lorenzo Peterson · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-16 ·
★★★★★
The service was great
The service was great! The price was great, and delivery was fast. I ordered 2 Atlas Force UHP 225/40R19 93Y XL tires for my 2025 Bmw M340i x drive. The items were delivered in 3 days.
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Those are subtly some solid tires, suitable for even a nice BMW - we're sure they'll exceed expectations, and we'll get you your order in 2 days next time!
R
Rohan · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-07 ·
★★★★★
Price and speed of delivery
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Don't forget the tire quality, too! We're sure it will all be splendid!
Company is absolutely TRASH. They send damaged, years old, wrong size and then expect you to pay the cost to return them (minimum 150-200 for a set of 4). They use an outsourced overseas third party for customer service. You will not get them on the phone unless waiting hours. Don't fall for the "press 1 and we'll call you back when it's your turn" because that call will never come. It's because the cheapest bidder call center doesn't have the technology to do it. You reach out via email and its 2-3 days in between responses, they claim they "are experiencing high volume currently" WELL I GUESS SO WITH ALL THE PROBLEMS!!! They will respond that you are the problem or blame the delivery company, not accepting fault. They are just a dropshipper off outdated, canceled, and knockoff tires. Read the reviews and complaints about people receiving 3-5 year old DOT number tires. People don't know to check this number on your tires as it will tell you when they were actually manufactured. So your "NEW" tires aren't really new. Rubber compunds break down even when sitting in a warehouse, especially with climate changes and being stacked under weight of others. If you find a great price, orcwhat you believe is a deal, just print it off, take it to Discount Tires or Tire Discounters and they will match the price, plus you'll get a lifetime warranty and free repairs for flats should you need it, plus rotation and balance. Save yourself the headache of dealing with this sorry company who pays third world employees $4/hr wages to run their "customer service", has a 2.0 employee rating for their warehouse jobs where tires are shipped from here in the US per Indeed/Glassdoor. The only people benefiting is this ownership group who couldn't give a D@MN about customers or employees.
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Slander and libel should at least have some effort put in to be a bit believable, we think.
We do not sell or send out damaged, incorrect or otherwise inappropriate tires - on purpose, that is. No retailer or manufacturer is perfect, or ever will be, but we strive to absolutely minimize the amount of mistakes by constantly improving our operational methodology and quality assurance.
We don't "expect" customers to pay for a return - if we make a mistake, we provide a free return; if we do not, free returns are not possible, all of which is advertised. So, it is up to the customers to send the tires back however they want to - we offer to sell prepaid labels at our business rate, which can be as low as $10 for a single tire, and about $50 for a set of 4. Feel free to research standard tire shipping costs and then get back to us as to how useful or fair our offers are.
Our phone line features both a queue system as well as a callback option, which is indeed functional and is not exactly a feat of expensive technology; it is standard fare for any reputable company, so naturally we incorporate it and optimize it for the best possible efficiency. Our US-based customer service does its best to utilize this to its most.
We do have a high volume of calls, because we have a high volume of business - we sell 5000+ orders per day, moving tens of thousands of tires. That's not an excuse for any phone or email delay, but it is an explanation - and we're working hard to improve both capacity and methodology to drastically reduce any and all wait times.
We do not "blame" customers for anything, outside of extreme exceptions and cases where customers clearly do something they shouldn't yet attempt to blame us for it; we likewise don't "blame" our shipping partners, but we do point out when there's an unlucky and unforeseen issue with the shipping, which one would expect a modern customer would understand, especially as we always try to make things right.
We do sell both budget-friendly and premium tires of all kinds and categories, and this is proven by a cursory glance at our website; the notion that we only sell old and/or faulty tires is preposterous. Some tires can be older, as we do stock older tires, but obviously our vast 20+ years of experience with literal millions of orders is proof enough that your supposed understanding of tires, compounds and aging is decidedly outdated and inappropriate.
It's not impossible for an individual mistake of some kind to happen as noted above, but a couple of reviews about old tires (sent out by accident) are drowned out in the sea of positive experiences and innumerable returning customers.
Needless to say, we do all we can to treat all of our customers and employees with dignity and respect - and we're always learning and improving, year-in, year-out, which is exactly why we keep getting higher and higher ratings alongside increasing sales.
All in all, this reply is just for the sake of posterity, as it's abundantly clear to any neutral observer that this review is absurdly inappropriate, inauthentic and inapplicable - kernels of real criticism notwithstanding, which we do always acknowledge.
M
Mike · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-15 ·
★★★★★
Good selection and prices!
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Our tire selection is something we strive to keep rich and varied, and we're most glad that you found something right for you!
T
Travis · 1 review · Experienced 2026-07-03 ·
★★★★★
Easy ordering
Easy ordering, fast delivery, and complete satisfaction!!!
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
Complete satisfaction is definitely a goal we always strive for, and it's awesome to hear that we achieved that for you!
C
Christina Hunter · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-07-07 ·
★★★★★
Fast and reliable and pricing was…
Fast and reliable and pricing was amazing. Will be ordering the remaining 3 tires I need
Reply from Priority Tire LLC2026-07-31
We're glad to have made a good first impression and will happily do even better on the next go, in fact! Thank you!