If you are looking for a custom challenge coin service that creates high quality coins in a short turnaround time, your search ends at Signature Coins. Here, you will get the widest range of challenge coins, challenge coin styles and custom coin designs. Get your free artwork and designs at signaturecoins.com today!
Signature Coins (signaturecoins.com) has a 4.8 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 100 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Hobbies & Crafts and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 95% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 40% of negative reviews; 6 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-31.
Signature coins was so easy to work with. I e-mailed hand drawn sketches for a command coin and they turned it into usable art! They're responsive, quick on artwork edits and providing proofs, and affordable. The quality of the coin is superb. We are constantly getting compliments on the details and craftsmanship of the coin. I've used them twice for coins and intend to continue as a loyal customer throughout my tenure in the Army.
The Police challenge coins that Signature Coins helped me design far exceeded my expectations!!! I was amazed by the intricate details of the finished product. They are flawless. I'm sure our Officers will be thrilled to receive them. I give Signature Coins my highest recommendation for design service and manufacturing of absolutely beautiful, first-class challenge coins and look forward to dealing with them on future projects. Can't thank them enough for the outstanding service, high quality and very reasonable price!!!
I could not have asked for a better company to work through on creating BTRY coins. They had a quick turn around on drawing up the perfect design, easy to communicate with and the quality of the coins are fantastic. Cannot wait to show these off :)
I had fantastic support from the team at Signature Coins from beginning to end. I had a very detailed and unique challenge coin I needed produced in a short time. TJ led his team to work through the proof, applying changes quickly, and responding back to me very efficiently. The job was on a time constraint and TJ went the extra mile to check in on the manufacturing to ensure it remained on time and to a high standard. Highly recommend this company- fantastic service.
Signature Coins did a great job producing a challenge coin for our church. They kept us up to date on the progress and the product was excellent. Highly recommend!
Signature Coins did an excellent job in helping us to design a challenge coin signifying our 25th anniversary. We are a Child Advocacy Center and the coins have been a huge hit with our Multi-Disciplinary Team members! I would highly recommend them for your challenge coin needs!
I appreciated the professional and efficient help getting my project created, quoted, ordered and delivered with great efficiency. Everyone that worked with me was extremely helpful and friendly! Thank you for all your help creating a great product for our team :)
All I’m saying is don’t advertise free shipping international if the free shipping only applies to the United States Their site says free shipping, said nothing about what country. I went through weeks of back and forth with designs then I went to check out and got hit with the $150 shipping fee I called them and they where rude raised their voices and even accnoleged that their site was misleading yet they still wouldn’t honour their advertisement
Thanks for the feedback and for taking my call. I am terribly sorry for the miscommunication during your ordering process. Since we’re a US-based company, we are only able to offer free-shipping within the US. I am sorry that this was not clear. I hope our offer to cover the shipping costs for this order alleviates your frustration. I just sent you the quote. Thank you for taking the time to let us know and make this right for you!
Signature coins was very professional. I was pleased with my coins designs, and how quickly I received them.
John Blackwell was amazing. Helpful from the beginning to the end. Wonderful service!
I contacted Signature Coins after talking to other vendors. I was told by others that my idea's for our center's coin could not be done. When I talked to Signature, they laughed and said, "We got it." They are constructing my coins. John Blackwell was an amazing customer service representative that answered all my questions and i have no questions about my order or what the next steps are. Thank you John. I will not use any other vendor and will spread the word to my other agencies.
Great company to do business with. From concept, to design, to final proofs to shipping it was about 6 weeks, the first couple weeks were design ideas and changes. The staff is wonderful with the design changes and even ideas. Shipping is free folks... cant beat that price!
They do such an amazing job creating the coins exactly like I want them. Thank you for such great customer service!! You al are the best!!!
This is my second order with Signature Coins and I have only good things to say about everything related to our interaction. They are responsive to questions with clear information and suggestions. The preview images are clear and well defined. The finished product is beautiful and delivery is timely. Can't ask for much more.
The team made multiple revisions to make the coin exactly how I wanted them to be. Their customer service is top notch
Jeff was great to work with. Provided proofs and pricing quickly.
Our group is very excited about having a custom coin for our members. Both Jeff and Eli were really helpful and made the process very simple. First time designing a coin, and I was a bit nervous. Great suggestions that improved the design. Looking forward to working with them in the future. UPDATE - I got my tracking number today - coins arrive 4/15 - I just ordered less than 2 weeks ago - 2 sided full color. Can't wait to see them - really awesome service - thanks!
Cheap, easy and fast. 2nd time working with these guys and will be working with them a third time shortly. They make the experience simple, and turn out a great product you wont regret.
They worked very hard to created the perfect challenge coin that we envisioned. They worked very closely with us on edits and were very helpful.
These guys are awesome. They sent a couple of different mock-ups and swiftly took care of some modifications I wanted. Their design team are brilliant and the coins look great. I have contacted them via email and phone without any issues. John was really helpful. I would highly recommend Signature Coins.
100 reviews matching
Personalized Paper Manufacturing Group
Notepads Your Way
Inkgarden
iPromo
USB Memory Direct
BottleYourBrand.com
Industry Rockstar
Card Depot