For businessesSearchWrite a reviewCategoriesAbout
简体中文English
Shopping & Fashion

Superjeweler

104 reviews

3.9104 reviews
Write a review

About Superjeweler

Data updated
Website
superjeweler.com
Category
Shopping & Fashion
Location
United States · New York
Status
Unclaimed
Last 12 months
60 reviews
Replies to negative
38% (10/26)
Do you own Superjeweler? Claim this profile for free and start replying to reviews.

Is Superjeweler legit?

Superjeweler (superjeweler.com) has a 3.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 104 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is mixed. 20% of reviews are 1 star, a relatively high share; The business has replied to 38% of negative reviews; 60 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-11.

What people say

N
Nancy Guckin · 1 review · Experienced 2026-03-19 ·

Certificate of quality

I thought it would come with a certificate of quality. In general, I am pleased with this purchase.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-05-01

Hi Nancy, we'll have the appraisal care sent right out to you! Sorry about this

P
Pamela Rodgers · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-03-09 ·

Delivered on time

Delivered on time, great quality in the jewelry.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-05-05

Thanks for the great review, Pamela!!!

P
Patricia Trujillo · 6 reviews · Experienced 2026-03-09 ·

I received my necklace and ring it was…

I received my necklace and ring it was supposed to be 2day delivered but it was 4 day. But they are both beautiful I love them the ring was a little different than in the picture but it's ok. Thank you

Reply from Superjeweler2026-05-05

So sorry about the small delay Patricia, but everyone here at SuperJeweler.com hopes you are loving your necklace and ring!

M
Ms. Dee · 11 reviews · Experienced 2026-03-05 ·

Super happy

I am super happy with my purchases with Super Jeweler. I shop here often and love their big selection. Great and easy to order! Love Super Jeweler!!

Reply from Superjeweler2026-05-05

We are super-happy with you too!

M
Martin Watson · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-03-08 ·

My wife loves them

My wife loves them. And the light in the box adds class! When does it go out?

Reply from Superjeweler2026-05-05

Martin, we love the light up box too! I'm so glad you noticed! All the best and please come back to SuperJeweler.com soon!

D
Deborah · 4 reviews · Experienced 2026-02-28 ·

The whole experience from ordering to…

The whole experience from ordering to receiving my ear rings was easy and expedient.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-05-05

Deborah that is so wonderful!!!

N
Nan Cumbie Baker · 1 review · Experienced 2026-02-17 ·

Very easy to order product at a great…

Very easy to order product at a great price!!!

Reply from Superjeweler2026-02-19

Thanks so much for the 5 star review of SuperJeweler.com Nan!

G
Greta Buzzard · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-02-12 ·

I would actually give a 4.9/5

I would actually give a 4.9/5. Ordering was smooth. My item was delivered promptly enough. It arrived in good condition. The item was of the quality described. The only thing that was not accurate was the stone that was pictured was not color correct to the stone I received. The picture showed a deeper hue than it actually was. But, for the cost, it was certainly satisfactory.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-02-19

HI Greta. Thanks for the detailed review. If you would like to trade, please reach out!

B
Bolling McNeill · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-02-08 ·

Superjeweler has always delivered as…

Superjeweler has always delivered as advertised, hence the reason that I am a repeat buyer!

Reply from Superjeweler2026-02-19

You are the best and everyone at SuperJeweler.com is here to serve you always!

P
PG · 1 review · Experienced 2025-12-24 ·

I ordered a time-sensitive item that…

I ordered a time-sensitive item that was advertised with a December 16 ship date and expected delivery by December 24. After the order failed to ship on time, I contacted SuperJeweler multiple times and was repeatedly assured it would still arrive by December 24. However, USPS did not receive the package until December 23, making on-time delivery impossible. I was also told a supervisor would contact USPS to expedite the shipment and follow up in writing, which never happened. I sent follow-up emails requesting clarification and a partial refund or store credit but did not receive a response. The item eventually arrived, but the delivery assurances were inaccurate and the lack of follow-through was disappointing. Buyers relying on guaranteed delivery dates for important occasions should be cautious. After receiving no communication or responses from email and phone calls I asked for a partial refund as they broke the contract of making sure i received the product before Christmas and lied saying the product has been shipped when it wasn’t. After not getting a reply back for partial refund and sending 3 emails I reached out to my credit card company they suggested filing a claim. If needed I have written proof from multiple super jeweler employees saying I will receive shipment before Christmas. There sales manager Jason is useless wouldn’t give me a number to call or when my call was transferred to him he didn’t return a single call and would respond with a email.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-02-20

This buyer seems to be dishonest. They filed a chargeback saying that the item was not received. Here is the tracking link so you can see that they did receive the shipment. https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction?qtc_tLabels1=9200190303007900487644 The honest thing to do would be to return the item for a refund.

I
Ina Johnson · 3 reviews · Experienced 2026-01-24 ·

1/4 Pave Wedding Set in Sterling Silver

I just bought a wedding set that was on sale and I got a really good deal. Then I received the ring really quickly and was very happy when I opened the package. The wedding set is very nice. I really like it and glad I bought it. The set looks amazing. Anyone who buys this set will not be sorry.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-02-19

HI Ina, yes this set is a crazy good deal! SuperJeweler always passes the savings on to you! Come back soon!

E
Edward Kim · 11 reviews · Experienced 2026-01-22 ·

SuperJeweler is reliable

SuperJeweler is reliable. I've ordered a lot ot times and always been happy

Reply from Superjeweler2026-02-19

Hi Edward, Thank you — that truly means a lot to us. Reliability is one of the things we care about most at SuperJeweler. From consistent quality and accurate product descriptions to secure checkout and dependable shipping, our goal is to make every jewelry purchase smooth and stress-free. We’re especially grateful for your repeat business. Customers who come back again and again — whether for diamond rings, gold jewelry, anniversary gifts, or everyday pieces — are the foundation of our company. Thank you for your continued trust in SuperJeweler. We look forward to serving you again! — The SuperJeweler Team

P
Pamela Jones · 4 reviews · Experienced 2026-01-20 ·

Excellent prices and beautiful earrings

Reply from Superjeweler2026-01-21

Hi Pamela, Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re thrilled to hear you’re enjoying your beautiful earrings — and that you felt great about the price too. At SuperJeweler, we work hard to offer high-quality diamond and gold jewelry at exceptional value, so it means a lot to know that came through in your experience. We hope you enjoy wearing your earrings for years to come, and we look forward to helping you find your next favorite piece! — The SuperJeweler Team

M
Michelle Horton · 1 review · Experienced 2025-09-01 ·

So I had ordered a boho bracelet was…

So I had ordered a boho bracelet was very excited to be getting it.. So.. a couple of days went by and no email confirmation... So I emailed the customer service and the would give me a bullshit run around about how my order was on back order... I asked why didn't I get a text or email that it was on back order.. The bot that I was exchanging message with said that it would be shipped out sept 9, 2025. And we are in January.. So I sent another email saying I just wanted my money back or the item that I ordered.. It plainly told me that all they could do was give me store credit.. I was like cool but wait... I went to use the store credit and it would say wrong could.. So back to customer service.. That bot told me that, that code had expired and gave me another.. but wait I go to use it and bam code dont exist.. And back to emailing customer service.. And the bot on the other end sure didn't have could customer service skills, if you dont like working with the public, why are you working in this field 🤔.. but let me stop with that tangent. So what im getting at is this store is a fraud, should be shut down, and whoever own this company or the web page should be made an example of.. You are offering this items and not delivering... you should be ashamed of what your doing, but you're probably not... They say all thing come to an end... karam always wins..... disappointed and this is nothing but a scam...

Reply from Superjeweler2026-01-21

Oh Gosh this is such a hassle for you. We are really sorry. We have had very difficult times with US Customs due to the Trump Tariffs, which has caused horrible delays. SuperJeweler.com is not a fraud. We have serviced many millions of customers since 2000.

G
Gail · 1 review · Experienced 2026-01-12 ·

Good looking products.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-01-21

Thaks so much!

V
Vishal Trivedi · 4 reviews · Experienced 2025-12-28 ·

DO NOT BUY - LIE, CHEAT, DECEPTIVE PRACTICE

Aww that's cute :) Here's the reply which took a solid 10 days. Reply from Superjeweler 36 minutes ago this is not for a legitimate order. the actual buyer for this order number is Vishal Trivedi. this is just someone trying to hurt our 5 Star Ratings So a little update. I received an email from these thieves on January 12th. (Below) Hi 3044857 - 45.50$ Did you send all the items back to us? Thank You Jehan SuperJeweler.com 62 West 45th Street 2nd Floor New York,NY 10036 (Updated Review) They asked if the items were returned. They were never sent. I replied they were never sent and still have not heard back from them. THIS WAS A LEGITIMATE ORDER. I AM VISHAL TRIVEDI. These crooks think I randomly guessed the correct order number and made a fake review. Really Super Jeweler - do the right thing and refund the rest of my money. I am still owed $41.10. I don't want a coupon to buy other junk from you I want my money! Not trying to hurt your ratings. I want to inform the public of your shady business practices and TO NOT BUY from you. If you were just honest in the first place none of this would have happened. Return my money. (Original Review) Ordered end of July. They keep pushing back the shipping date. End of December pushed to 2026. I was refunded $45.50. They stole from me. The correct refund amount is $86.60. Awful customer service. Deceptive marketing and ordering practices. DO NOT BUY from Super Jewelers. They LIE & they CHEAT. I emailed "Andrew Fox" President on 12/30/2025 and still no response. These were Birthdy gifts for my Wife. Super Jeweler lied and cheated. They failed, so I failed. I trusted them and have paid a price for my trust of this lying, thieving company Super Jewelers. Again, DO NOT BUY from this company. Order #3044857

Reply from Superjeweler2026-01-21

this is not for a legitimate order. the actual buyer for this order number is Vishal Trivedi. this is just someone trying to hurt our 5 Star Ratings Please see that the "customer" tells us that they use a FAKE NAME. Who is the fraudster?

R
Robin Clark · 1 review · Experienced 2026-01-10 ·

I order from this company often

I order from this company often. Always have great quality as well as price.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-01-21

Thanks so much Robin! We are super-thrilled to have you as a superjeweler customer

B
BIPIN RANA · 1 review · Experienced 2026-01-06 ·

Received as per order

Reply from Superjeweler2026-01-07

We love this 5 star review! Thanks so much Bipin!

R
Regina Nadir · 1 review · Experienced 2026-01-02 ·

Experience

It was a seamless experience.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-01-07

Regina thank you so much for your 5 star review of SuperJeweler.com. We can't wait to have you back!

L
Lisa Jordan · 1 review · Experienced 2025-12-26 ·

Beautiful! Its perfect for any occasion.

Fast shipping with tracking and the necklace is gorgeous.

Reply from Superjeweler2026-01-07

This is such a wonderful review Lisa. Everyone at SuperJeweler.com thanks you very much!