For businessesSearchWrite a reviewCategoriesAbout
简体中文English
Restaurants & Bars

Goldbelly

200 reviews

1.5200 reviews
Write a review

About Goldbelly

Data updated
Website
www.goldbelly.com
Category
Restaurants & Bars
Location
United States · New York
Status
Unclaimed
Last 12 months
127 reviews
Replies to negative
87% (151/173)
Do you own Goldbelly? Claim this profile for free and start replying to reviews.

Is Goldbelly legit?

Goldbelly (www.goldbelly.com) has a 1.5 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 200 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Restaurants & Bars and its reputation is poor. 79% of reviews are 1 star, a relatively high share; The business has replied to 87% of negative reviews; 127 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-11.

What people say

D
David Pursley美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-06-09 ·

Customer service non existent

Ordered a cake for my father for his birthday. I purchased using Apple Pay and it automatically linked the delivery to an old address without asking me manually for the delivery address. I immediately reached out to customer service to change the address but it was after hours and nobody was available. Called the next day and was told there was nothing they could do. They offered to credit 50 percent back to my account for my next order. There won’t be a next order. I just sent a 150 dollar cake to someone who lives at my old address. They admitted that the Apple Pay issue was something they were aware of and trying to fix. Essentially, if anything goes wrong with your order, they will do nothing to address it other than offer you a discount on your next bad order. Buyer beware.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-06-11

Hi David, Thanks for your review. We're so sorry that this was not an ideal experience, and it's something we never want our customers to have. While we can appreciate that this was a gift, we can only deliver with the information that we receive at checkout, and we're not always able to make last-minute changes. Like any other company, we have to take steps to get to a resolution for you. We also have policies we have to adhere to to protect our shops. It’s a little different working with food, as it can’t be returned or exchanged like many other things in the e-commerce world. We thank you for allowing us to make this right with you directly, with a resolution that was deemed fair. Take care, and stay safe.

M
Mr Grabbag美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2025-12-08 ·

First I have to say

First I have to say, I never ordered from Goldbelly, so my review may be seen as worthless to some. This is my issue. I am a big fan of deep dish pizza. This goes back to my UC days in the 80’s. Fast forward to now, where Goldbelly mentions Chicago Deep Dish pizza. There web site had nothing close. They actually have frozen pizza that I can get at Walmart listed as “Authentic Chicago Deep Dish Pizza”. And at 4 Times the Walmart price!

Reply from Goldbelly2026-06-11

Hi there, we're so sorry to hear that you didn't enjoy the pizza that you ordered. We want to ensure that all of our customers love the food that they receive, and would never knowingly send a customer anything less than the best we can find. Nonetheless, we understand that it is disappointing to not enjoy your order as much as you anticipated, and for this we do apologize. We strive to keep shipping rates as low as possible. Most of the costs goes directly to UPS and FedEx, along with packaging to ensure your items arrive cold and fresh. We’re passionate about food and love helping you explore new flavors. We hope to serve you some delicious treats again soon!

R
Ryk美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-06-04 ·

Deceptive marketing…Free Shipping is Almost Never

The product page prominently markets “Free Shipping” and doesn’t clearly say “only certain dates” until you’re in the delivery calendar and see a fee, that’s close to a “bait and switch”! Nor do they show a clear order summary—including shipping, fees, and tax—before asking for card details.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-06-11

Hi Ryk, Thanks for reaching out! While we wish we could ship everything for free, shipping costs can vary depending on the shop, item type, and delivery location. Likewise, we recommend customers use the APP or Google Chrome to have full view of the information on the site, including all of the pricing at checkout. To identify products that offer free shipping you can use the “free shipping” filter or look for the blue “free shipping” flag in the bottom right of the product pictures. Keep in mind, some shops require shipping fees or upgrades based on their fulfillment schedules and the delivery address entered at checkout. Likewise, orders shipping to Hawaii, Alaska, or Canada will always include a shipping fee. We hope this helps you find your next favorite treat!

G
Grace美国 · 2 reviews · Experienced 2026-06-01 ·

“Joe’s Pick” Junior’s Cheesecake & Little Pie Company

I ordered both a cheesecake from Junior’s Cheesecakes and pot pies from Little Pie Company through Goldbelly. Although the orders shipped separately, both arrived at room temperature with no dry ice or cold packs included, making me question whether the food was even safe to eat. The cheesecake was a soggy, mushy mess, and the pot pies were tiny—about the size of a $3 pot pie from the grocery store freezer section. Considering the premium prices, the quality and value were extremely disappointing. I do not recommend Goldbelly. The overall experience reflected poor quality control and very poor value for the money.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-06-04

We're sorry to hear that you were disappointed in your order. We always recommend checking all of the details for products under "More Details" on the product page so you know what to expect! If you're unsure of something, you can always reach out to our team at [email protected]. Likewise, if the order arrived with any damage or delays, please let us know at [email protected], and we are happy to assist with this. We hope you can find something to enjoy with us in the future.

J
James Cataldi美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-06-02 ·

Did not do what they said they would do.

Bought the baby back ribs. The very first line in the description says "shipped in dry ice." The box came, left on my porch, I reached down to pick it up and almost threw my back out. The ribs were NOT shipped in dry ice; they were shipped with four heavy gel packs. When you pay ultra-premium prices you expect, at least, premium customer service. Not with Goldbelly. Oh, and I followed the directions to a tee and the ribs were exceedingly mediocre. Good sauce, though. Save your money.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-06-11

Hi James, Thank you for your review! We always strive to make each and every experience with our food explorers top-notch. We’re happy your order got delivered to you to enjoy. We’re happy to sort out any additional issues you may have if you need. If so, you can reach out to us at [email protected].

D
Delaney Palmer美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-05-29 ·

Arrived damaged but was informed it was “final sale”

The food itself was decent, but part of the order arrived damaged due to poor packaging, not the shipping carrier. Customer service’s response was essentially that because some of the individual cakes were still fine, it was not really a refund issue. My concerns felt dismissed, and for the price plus shipping costs, the resolution offered was disappointing.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-06-04

Hi Delaney, Thanks so much for your feedback. We're sorry you feel that we missed the mark here. We're so glad to be able to send this amazing treat all the way from Los Angeles to you. We wish we could hand-deliver them to you so that they would arrive just as perfect as if you were to walk out of the shop in person. That said, we apologize that there was an issue with the presentation of the order upon receiving it. Like any other company, we have to take steps to get to a resolution for you. We also have policies we have to adhere to protect our shops. It’s a little different working with food, as it can’t be returned or exchanged like many other things in the e-commerce world. We thank you for allowing us to make this right with you directly with a resolution that was deemed fair. Take care, and stay safe.

J
J. Kohl美国 · 4 reviews · Experienced 2025-12-11 ·

NO DELIVERY SERVICE:

NO DELIVERY SERVICE: I ordered a birthday cake for my significant other on 12-11-2025. It never arrived. I spent until 01-03-2026 trying to resolve the issue with GoldBelly and UPS. By January 2026 I did receive compensation for this missed delivery but that wasn't the end of it. I then sent the full amount of the cakes cost to my s/o as a GoldBelly gift card. I whole-heartedly wanted to believe it was an isolated event. That giftcard was then used to purchase an anniversary gift on 05-03-2026. We never received that GoldBelly purchase either. GoldBelly has LITERALLY never delivered anything we've ever ordered from them to this date. I would not only NOT recommend GoldBelly to other customers. I would very strongly encourage them to RUN AWAY from GoldBelly as fast as they can.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-05-28

Thank you for your feedback. We’d be happy to assist you with this. We were able to locate your order, and a team member will be in contact with you shortly via [email protected]

Z
Zhenhua美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-05-08 ·

Look at my boy's birthday cake

Look at my boy's birthday cake and tell me if he is going to love it How to attach a photo of the smashed cake?

Reply from Goldbelly2026-05-14

Hi Zhenhua, Thanks so much for reaching out to share your feedback with us. We're so sorry for the issues that occurred with your order. We certainly appreciate your patronage and thank you for reaching out to our customer service team. We're so glad we were able to make this issue right with you

J
John Mazur美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-05-09 ·

A 6 year customer who spends thousand

A 6 year customer who spends thousand Per year - they totally failed a very important delivery TWICE for my 83 year old mothers Mother’s Day for hundreds of dollars and their response was “sorry most we can do is give you a $25 gift card”. Done with Gold Belly! Amazing how one experience when your treated this poorly ruins the brand for you - I was such a fan. Now never will I order from them again

Reply from Goldbelly2026-05-14

Hi John, Thanks so much for reaching out to share your feedback with us. We're so sorry for the issues that occurred with your order. It's always our best intention to give the best customer experience possible, and I'm sorry that we missed the mark here. We thank you for your patience, and one of our team members will be following up with you in email shortly.

V
Victoria hochman美国 · 8 reviews · Experienced 2026-04-30 ·

Very expensive but it would have been…

Very expensive but it would have been all good if delivery was made on the date requested. It was a 50th wedding anniversary. There's also artisan ice cream that was ordered in a separate order and that too wasnt delivered as requested. Im done with this company. For these prices I should be getting top tier customer service and that is not what happened with 2 orders this week.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-05-07

Hi Victoria, Thanks so much for reaching out to share your feedback with us. We're so sorry for the issues that occurred with your order. We do say estimated delivery because Goldbelly has no control when unforeseen delays occur. In the case of time-sensitive events and holidays, we do also recommend scheduling an order to arrive 2+ days before you need it, and most items can be stored until you are ready to enjoy! We thank you for your patience, and we're glad one of our agents was able to make this right for you.

D
Deanna Lynne美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-04-24 ·

UPS UNRELIABLE DELIVERY/GOLDBELLY themselves are STELLAR

APRIL 24, 2026 - After 98 orders, I. AM. FRUSTRATED. Everytime you ask me to fill out the survey that says would I recommend Goldbelly to anybody, I always put the lowest score, and the reason is UPS Shipping. This, as my sister waited yesterday (Thursday, April 23) for a baked item that was ordered April 16, shipped Monday, April 20 from Duchess Cookies by UPS, meanwhile SAME EXACT item, shipped Monday delivered Thursday literally two blocks away to my niece. I called before 6pm, and your associate said, no, it should still make it tonight by 10. Really? It looks like UPS has it sitting in Jacksonville. Friday afternoon now and still NADA. 50/50 is NOT good enough. If anyone is thinking of sending Goldbelly as a gift, know that the reliability of the date you have chosen for delivery is not solid if they use UPS. I have used Goldbelly b/c of the AMAZING variety of quality, sometimes unique, shipped foods around the country and including Hawaii. I will not ever dump Goldbelly, b/c they are not the ones choosing UPS, it is the vendors. Vendors: If you use UPS that comes through Florida, count me out. Goldbelly Customer Service: YOU ARE SOLID, and if you ever need a tester for a potential vendor, I am your person.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-30

Hi Deanna, I'm so sorry about the shipping delay with your order. Thank you for sharing some valuable feedback. We do say estimated delivery because once these packages are in the hands of the carrier, Goldbelly has no control when unforeseen transit/weather delays occur. We do recommend that orders for special events or specific holidays be scheduled for delivery 1-3 days before the date the items are needed. We certainly appreciate your patronage and your reaching out to our customer service team. Thanks for your patience with us. We're so glad we were able to make this issue right with you!

K
Kelly Bolinger美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-04-17 ·

I received the wrong order

I received the wrong order, and when I contacted customer service, I was told they could not send the correct item. Instead, they offered a $30 credit—which isn’t very useful given that most items on the site cost significantly more. I’ve had these pizzas in the past (sent as gifts), and they were excellent. Unfortunately, the pizza we received this time was disappointing and not worth the price. Between the incorrect order, lack of resolution, and decline in quality, this was a frustrating experience. I won’t be using the credit or ordering again, and I would not recommend purchasing from this company.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-23

Hi Kelly, Thank you for your review. We’re so sorry for this issue. We see that you’ve also written to our support team, and a team member will be in contact with you shortly. We appreciate your patience.

A
Aim Ganelle美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-04-10 ·

I ORDERED A WEEK BEFORE I NEEDED

I ORDERED A WEEK BEFORE I NEEDED THE CAKE YET THEY HAD NOT SHIPPED IT AT 5 P.M. THE DAY BEFORE THEN WHEN I REACHED SOMEONE SAID BASICALLY OPPS WE WILL UPGRADE YOUR SHIPPING TO OVERNIGHT.. WHAT THE H3LL ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT YOU FAILED BIG TIME NOW THEY ARE SAYING THE CAKE THAT IS SUPPOSED TO BE DELIVERED TODAY WAS HELD UP CAUSE OF WEATHER AND IT WILL BE SPOILED WHEN DELIVERED MONDAY MIND YOU IT IS FRIDAY NOW AND THEY WILL NOT REFUND ME!!!! WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT YOU FAILED TO SHIP IT SO IT WOULD BE HERE ON 9TH OR 10TH A.M. AS ORDERED AND YET YOU WILL NOT REFUND..... THEY SAID NO NOW WE ARE GOING TO BBB

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-16

Hi Aim, I'm so sorry about the shipping delay with your order. Thank you for sharing some valuable feedback. We do say estimated delivery because once these packages are in the hands of the carrier, Goldbelly has no control when unforeseen transit/weather delays occur. Thank you for your patronage and for reaching out to our customer service team. We appreciate your patience with us. We're so glad we were able to make this issue right with you!

E
Estelle Franklin美国 · 5 reviews · Experienced 2026-04-10 ·

Received wrong item. Goldbelly does not respond

My order no. 28308868 was placed on 4/8/2026 and due for delivery today, 4/10/2026. I ordered 2 lbs. of the chocolate Matzo Crack - ready to eat out of the box from The Borscht Belt Delicatessen and paid $64.95. While my order was delivered on time, I received the wrong item. Rather I was sent potato latkes and about 10 jars of unmarked containers filled with liquid and/or powder. No instructions included. The chocolate matzo crack was intended for a party this weekend. I do not cook and threw out what I received. Goldbelly has a useless bot. I did receive a response from "Maureen" and sent her several pictures of what I received. It is apparent I was sent the wrong item. It's not as though my order consisted of 10 items; rather just one item. As someone that has placed multiple orders from Goldbelly over the past three years, the way to make things right is to send me what I ordered overnight at no additional charge. Not surprisingly I have not received a response from "Maureen" despite sending her photos of what I received. Service has taken a deep nosedive. Very disappointed.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-16

Hi Estelle, Thank you for your feedback. We’d be happy to assist you. We were able to locate your order, and a team member has emailed you via [email protected]. We will await your reply. Thanks!

S
Sara S.美国 · 11 reviews · Experienced 2026-04-03 ·

Inedible Food and No Response After Escalation

I’ve used Goldbelly a few times and had good experiences, which is why this was so disappointing. I ordered a cheesesteak kit as a special pre-Easter meal, and the meat quality was unacceptable. It had a strong off/rancid odor while cooking and contained bone and excessive gristle throughout. It was not thin-sliced steak as advertised and was completely inedible. We had to throw it away and order DoorDash to replace dinner that same night. I contacted Goldbelly immediately. They initially offered a $25 credit on a $120 order, which I declined. I was then told my case would be escalated and that I would hear back within 24 hours. That never happened. It has now been 5 days with no response despite multiple follow-ups on my end. At this point, the lack of communication is as concerning as the original issue. This was not a matter of preference, the product was not usable. What’s most disappointing is that once a real issue arose, Goldbelly stopped responding rather than resolving it. Based on this experience, I would be very cautious ordering perishable items through Goldbelly.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-16

Hi Sara, Thank you for your review. We’re so sorry for this issue. We see that you’ve also written to our support team, and a team member has followed up requesting information. We are happy to assist via email support at [email protected].

C
Customer Pam美国 · 4 reviews · Experienced 2026-04-03 ·

Defective product and delivery

I received a gift from a friend. It was a cheesecake. When it arrived and we opened it, the cake had melted into a blob. The package itself had had a flimsy plastic bag that we assume once had ice of some kind in it. The delivery had taken 5 days via UPS standard shipping. I let my friend know and she contacted Goldbelly, who told her she would have to buy another if she wanted to but would have to wait 10 days for her refund. Very poor customer service. This is to let people know that Goldbelly will not help you make a situation right if something goes wrong. This stuff is not cheap. TTo hold someone's money for 10 days following a defective delivery is the sign of a bad business.I know Goldbelly has expanded quite a bit, but perhaps people need to know that they just are not what they used to be.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-16

Hi there, Thanks for your review. We're so sorry that this was not an ideal experience, and we appreciate you bringing it to our attention. While we can appreciate this was a gift, we can only deliver with the information that we receive at checkout, and we're not always able to make last-minute changes. It's very important to be sure that when you're placing an order, the shipping address is accurate. Anytime we change an address while it's still in transit will delay the package, which we made clear upon your request. Like any other company, we have to take steps to get to a resolution for you. We also have policies we have to adhere to to protect our shops. It’s a little different working with food, as it can’t be returned or exchanged like many other things in the e-commerce world. We thank you for your feedback and we have communicated directly with the purchaser for a resolution that was deemed fair. Take care!

g
google user美国 · 14 reviews · Experienced 2026-04-02 ·

Crumbs Bakeshop Easter Cupcakes Weren't Fresh

I ordered Crumbs Bakeshop Easter Cupcakes they arrived on time. When I started eating these Easter cupcakes some weren't fresh. WORST cupcakes I've had.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-09

Hi there, Thanks so much for your feedback. I'm sorry you did not enjoy your cupcakes! While we wish we could guarantee that every customer loves every item just as much as we do, everyone's palate does vary a little! We hope you can find another great treat with us in the future.

E
Erica Shafer美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-04-01 ·

Update: They Fixed Things, still bad Borscht Belt!

I got the Passover dinner from The Borscht Belt and it was so salty 2/3rds of it was inedible. I spent $150 on it and they offered a 25$ credit to their site. In the past, orders have been fine but now they won’t respond to me even after I offered to send pictures as they request in their website. Ruined Passover dinner for us this year. Edit: We have come to a settlement. The Borscht Belt never replied to either myself or Goldbelly, but Goldbelly made it right with me. I appreciate that and I will work with Goldbelly in the future, but never order from a store with a percentage less than 90%.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-09

Hi Erica, Thanks so much for your feedback. I'm sorry you did not enjoy your Brisket! While we wish we could guarantee that every customer loves every item just as much as we do, everyone's palate does vary a little! Like any other company, we have to take steps to get to a resolution for you. We also have policies we have to adhere to protect our shops. It’s a little different working with food, as it can’t be returned or exchanged like many other things in the e-commerce world. We thank you for allowing us to make this right with you directly with a resolution that was deemed fair. Take care!

S
Susan美国 · 8 reviews · Experienced 2026-03-26 ·

I ordered an expensive strawberry…

I ordered an expensive strawberry several layer cake. It was meh. If I’d been blindfolded, I couldn’t have told u the prevailing flavor other than a taste of butter. I paid $100 for this? Don’t bother. At least it was on time.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-04-02

Hi Susan, Thanks so much for your feedback. I'm sorry you did not enjoy your cake! While we wish we could guarantee that every customer loves every item just as much as we do, everyone's palate does vary a little! We do strive to keep product and shipping costs as low as possible. Most of the costs go directly to UPS and FedEx, along with packaging to ensure your items arrive cold and fresh. We’re passionate about food and love helping you explore new flavors. We hope to serve you some delicious treats again soon!

T
TJ Pederson美国 · 1 review · Experienced 2026-03-19 ·

They are late every single time I…

They are late every single time I order. Always miss the birthday. Every. Single. Time.

Reply from Goldbelly2026-03-20

Hi TJ, I'm so sorry about the shipping delay with your order. Thank you for sharing some valuable feedback. We do say estimated delivery because once these packages are in the hands of the carrier, Goldbelly has no control when unforeseen transit/weather delays occur. For items that experience delay, we always ask if the items are ok when they arrive, even if they are delayed in transit. A lot of products are shelf-stable for up to 7 days. In the case of time-sensitive events and holidays, we do also recommend scheduling an order to arrive 2+ days before you need it, and most items can be stored until you are ready to enjoy! We really do appreciate your feedback and hope that you can try something else with us in the future.