The Year Round Source For Home Gardeners! Specializing in unique, heirloom vegetable varieties, as well as Organics, all priced for the home gardener. We also offer flower and herb seeds, tools, supplies, books and crafts. Always non GMO. Pinetree has been family owned and operated for almost 40 years and takes pride in treating our customers like family. We offer quality, value, and variety to all of our customers. Pinetree- let our family feed your family.
Is Pinetree Garden Seeds legit?
Pinetree Garden Seeds (superseeds.com) has a 4.2 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 101 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Home & Garden and its reputation is good. 78% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 11% are 1 star; The business has replied to 38% of negative reviews; 2 of them were added in the last 12 months. Last updated 2026-08-11.
I have to agree that the germination rates are not up to par with these seeds. Typically inconsistent. I have watched the catalog grow and I wonder if the size of the business is now impacting quality. I used to order more from this company but found those issues problematic. I wonder if they are saving seed (for 1-3 yrs.) and selling that in the current year which could account for these issues. Also, they may be sourcing some of their seed from growers who do this and be unaware of it. I really love that one can order raw ingredients for body care and make more healthy products to use. In my mind, that would be a prime reason to order from this company. Might be useful to know how/where they source the seed they sell. Please note that these reviews also mine your data, including email lists and friends. Another problem, in my mind. If this review software or service is offered free to companies, then they are getting your data in return.
Reply from Pinetree Garden Seeds2020-01-13
Hi, Thanks for your feedback! We are so sorry to hear you are not happy with the germination rates you experienced with our seeds. We guarantee germination rates for all seeds so we are happy to replace or refund anything that was not satisfactory! Please let us know by emailing [email protected] or calling (207) 926-3400 and we will do whatever we can to make this right. We do test every single seed every year for germination rates to ensure high quality and success for our valued customers. We look forward to hearing from you!
Placed my first order friday and emailed to check on status and they said it takes 4-5 business days to ship an order? I only ordered a few packs of seeds, that seems like a long time to me to ship.
Reply from Pinetree Garden Seeds2019-04-30
Hi Angela,
Thanks for the feedback. I am sorry you are disappointed by our busy season order fulfillment timeline. I know it is so hard to wait when you are excited to get planting! We do try to let people know, on our website, that typical turnaround time is several days. I apologize that this was not communicated to you. We are working hard to get orders out as quickly as possible!
Great service! My order was in multiple shipments so I did have to e-mail to check on my order and I received prompt and attentive service. All plants healthy and did very well.
Reply from Pinetree Garden Seeds2017-12-19
Hi Kathy - thanks so much for sharing. Glad to hear that you received your whole order safely, and are happy with our Service!!
I have ordered seeds, books and other products from Pinetree Garden Seeds for many years. They have always stood behind their products. I love the seed packet sizes for the home gardener and the price! Their seeds are well suited for NH gardens. Customer service is great when needed. Delivery is prompt and shipping fees are extremely reasonable. I cannot think of one thing I don't like. Try them...they won't disappoint.
Many of the seed didn't germinate. Or they germinated inside, they died when I transplanted them. Only one, a radicchio, grew, but it didn't head.
Your catalogue doesn't give nearly the adequate directions that the Territorial catalogue does. It's hard to know how to grow your seeds.
You told me one of my credit cards didn't pay for my purchase. I used a different card and it worked. There was nothing wrong with the original card.
Great variety of seeds and a nice price point. Sometimes I get a mixture of other seed in vegetable seed packets. Occasionally a packet of seed is too old and does not sprout at all.
Love this place! Great seed quality and in a quantity I can USE! Great prices - and I can get all the "odd" or different varieties I want without having to buy hybrid this or that!
Best seed company for home gardeners that grow in smaller spaces. The smaller amounts of seeds is just right. Have been growing with you for years! Thank you!
I have been buying seeds from Pinetree for a few years now. I have never had a problem. I like how they have experience with the vegetable seeds they sell, & tell about that experience. I really like the affordable prices ! I like the assortment of natural, DIY skincare items they sell. To me, Pinetree feels like a friend.
Park Seed
Interior Define
LuxeDecor
FlooringInc.Com
Handy
Modani Furniture
FactoryPure
Luna Bazaar