Pool Supply Unlimited is an e-commerce company that loves water. We love to pump it, filter it, heat it, chlorinate it, light it up and stare at it while we're barbequing a fat, juicy steak. There are real pool professionals working here. Our guys have...
Is Pool Supply Unlimited legit?
Pool Supply Unlimited (poolsupplyunlimited.com) has a 4.4 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 100 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Construction & Manufacturing and its reputation is good. 85% of reviews are 4 stars or higher and 10% are 1 star; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews; Reviews mostly discuss Product, Price, Quality. Last updated 2026-09-05.
What reviewers say
AI generated
Reviewers had a great experience with this company. Customers frequently mention that products are competitively priced, work wonderfully, and arrive in excellent condition. People also appreciate the fast delivery times, smooth ordering process, and helpful support when choosing the right replacement parts.
Some reviewers were not happy with delivery delays or unexpected extra shipping fees charged after completing their purchases. A few consumers noted occasional shipping complications, such as lost packages or receiving incorrect items instead of what they originally ordered. Shoppers also experienced communication difficulties when trying to resolve these specific order problems or obtain refunds quickly.
Auto-generated from all reviews of this business. For reference only.
Everything was fine.
The unit is different than my last one. The first one had in the front that you could see the water and when it was cloudy or needed cleaning. This one was totally enclosed couldn’t see anything. I like the unit that you could see and he water etc.
The issue is that on the site it showed the board in stock, but after ordered, took many weeks. Ordered on 6/11 and got tracking on 6/30, didn't arrive until 7/9
They arrived faster than they said they would! The site was easy to use! They were in stock and the exact replacement I needed for pentair .
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-09-02
Thank you for the five-star review! We’re glad your Pentair replacement parts arrived ahead of schedule and were exactly what you needed. We appreciate your business!
good description. system processing and shipping. Follow up communication.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-09-02
Thank you for the five-star review! We’re glad you were pleased with the product description, order processing, shipping, and follow-up communication. We appreciate your business!
BUYER BEWARE — Extremely Misleading “Free Shipping”
Very disappointing experience with PoolSupplyUnlimited.com. I placed an order for a pool heater costing over $2,000, which was advertised with FREE SHIPPING. After placing the order, they called me and said they would require an additional $500 just to ship it to my area — in New York!
If you advertise an item with free shipping and allow a customer to complete the purchase at that price, you shouldn’t come back afterward demanding another $500 to actually deliver the product.
This felt like a classic bait-and-switch: advertise an attractive delivered price, get the customer to place the order, and then hit them with a massive additional shipping charge afterward.
A $500 surprise shipping charge on a $2,000+ purchase is absolutely ridiculous. If certain areas are excluded from free shipping, that should be made VERY CLEAR before the customer places the order—not after.
BUYER BEWARE. Verify the actual delivered price with them before ordering, because apparently “FREE SHIPPING” may not actually mean free shipping.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-09-03
We’re sorry for the frustration and understand why an additional charge of this size was upsetting. Although standard freight shipping was included with the heater, deliveries to Staten Island can cost significantly more due to limited carrier access and additional destination fees.
The $500 quoted was not the full shipping cost. We waived the amount normally covered by our free-shipping offer and only requested a portion of the unusually high additional cost charged to deliver to this location. Our shipping policy notes that additional charges may be required for areas where carrier costs exceed standard delivery rates.
We apologize that this possibility was not clearer during checkout. We understand how receiving the notice afterward affected your experience and appreciate the opportunity to explain.
I did pick up my order but it was delayed, ship to the wrong address as well
I did pick up my order but it was delayed by FedEx they give me a really hard time to pick up my order later and deliver it to my house properly and I had to go to the depot and when I went to the depot they were asking me a lot of information about my pickup and they delayed my pickup at one point they told me we didn't received the package then they received the package then they gave it to me but I spent over an hour negotiating with them in order to be able to pick up the item very unacceptable
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-09-01
We’re sorry for the delay and the frustrating experience you had while trying to retrieve your package from FedEx. We understand how unacceptable it was to spend over an hour at the depot providing information and receiving conflicting updates about whether your package had arrived.
Although the difficulties occurred during the carrier’s delivery and pickup process, we regret the inconvenience this caused. We’re glad you ultimately received your order, and we appreciate you bringing this experience to our attention.
THIS COMPANY DOES NOT VALUE IT'S CUSTOMERS OR THEIR TIME. SHOP SOMEWHERE ELSE. YOU"VE BEEN WARNED...
So I ordered some sealant from this company and they shipped out a pool equipment cap instead. The box that arrived with the pool cap in it (not my sealant) clearly had the details of my purchased sealant on the tag outside. I guess the shipping dept. made a goof. I get it , we all make mistakes and deserve a chance to correct them, but when I notified the company through several emails and 3 phone calls, all I got was a run around that they would fix it in 24-48 hours. All that happened in that time was me and my client getting stalled out.
After the 48 hours was up and I made a few more calls, and they finally sent me a return label to ship back the pool cap lol, but no answer on getting my refund or even better, just sending me the sealant I ordered!?!
Anyway, I reported the fraud to my credit card company since they can afford to spin their wheels with this dog and pony show. What a COMPLETE WASTE OF A WEEK OF MY TIME WITH THIS COMPANY. SHOP ELSEWHERE or chance piss poor customer service if something goes wrong (like they ship you the wrong item lol)
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-09-01
We sincerely apologize for both the shipping error and the time you spent trying to get this resolved. You should have received the sealant you ordered, and once you reported receiving the wrong product, we should have provided a clear and timely resolution. We completely understand your frustration, especially since this delayed both you and your client.
Unfortunately, we cannot locate your order with the limited information provided in this review. Please contact our customer service team at [email protected] with your order number so we can investigate and ensure this is handled correctly.
Product was delivered on time and is working well.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-08-17
Thank you for choosing Pool Supply Unlimited! We’re happy to hear your pump arrived on time and is working well. We appreciate the great review and hope to help with your pool needs again!
Thanks for the delivery. It was a very abused package but was in tact.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-08-17
Thank you for the five star review! We’re sorry to hear the packaging had a rough trip, but we’re very glad the product arrived intact and in good condition. We appreciate your business!
The order was received without any issues. It was delivered within a good time frame. I would recommend purchasing from this business.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-08-17
Thank you for the great review! We’re glad your order arrived without any issues and within a good time frame. We truly appreciate your recommendation and hope to serve you again!
I received the correct pool Aqua sensor timely and it worked perfectly since.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-08-03
Thank you for your 5-star review! We are thrilled to hear you received the correct Aqua Sensor quickly and that it has been working perfectly. We truly appreciate your business and are glad we could help get your pool back up and running. Thank you for choosing Pool Supply Unlimited!
Thank you for your 5-star review! We are so glad to hear your order arrived quickly and that everything was exactly as advertised. We appreciate your support and look forward to serving you again for your future pool and backyard needs. Enjoy!
Delivered in a timely manner. Product has worked well so far. No complaints.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-08-03
Thank you for your 5-star review! We are happy to hear your order was delivered in a timely manner and that the product has been performing well. We truly appreciate your business and are grateful for your support. We look forward to serving you again in the future!
Everything was delivered in a timely manner. All boxes were clearly marked and instructions were easy to follow. The set up was completed by one person in under a week. We love our new pool!
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-08-03
Thanks so much for your wonderful review! We are thrilled to hear everything arrived on time, was clearly labeled, and that the instructions made setup straightforward. It's especially great to know the installation was completed so smoothly and that you're already enjoying your new pool. We truly appreciate your business and hope you make many great memories in your new pool. Thank you for choosing Pool Supply Unlimited!
The device was delivered intact in a reasonable amount of time.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-07-20
Thank you for your review and recommendation! We are glad to hear your order arrived safely and within a reasonable amount of time. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to serving you again in the future.
Well priced and order came within a few days. Able to repair some parts on my dolphin rather than buy a new robot so saved a lot of money. Have purchased here before with good experience.
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-07-20
Thank you for your wonderful review and for being a repeat customer! We are so happy to hear you found our prices competitive and that your order arrived quickly. It is great to know you were able to repair your Dolphin cleaner instead of buying a new one and save money. We truly appreciate your continued trust in Pool Supply Unlimited and look forward to helping you with all your pool needs in the future!
Thank you for your 5 star review! We are so glad to hear your order arrived quickly. We truly appreciate your business and hope to serve you again soon!
They were very responsive with my questions and the product was as described would order again
Reply from Pool Supply Unlimited2026-07-06
Thank you so much for your 5-star review! We're delighted to hear that our team was able to answer your questions and that the product met your expectations. Providing responsive customer service and accurately described products is always our goal. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to serving you again in the future!
Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We are very sorry to hear about your experience. Unfortunately, we were unable to locate any information for your order, and when we reached out for additional details, we did not receive a response.
We would truly like the opportunity to help resolve this for you. Please contact our Customer Service team at [email protected] with your order information, and we'll be happy to investigate what happened and work toward a resolution. We look forward to hearing from you.