Island Watch (longislandwatch.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 104 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 97% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has not yet replied to negative reviews; Reviews mostly discuss Product, Quality, Price. Last updated 2026-08-12.
What reviewers say
AI generated
Reviewers overwhelmingly had a great experience with this company. Customers frequently share that their purchases arrive remarkably fast, often beating the expected delivery schedule while remaining securely packaged. Buyers deeply appreciate the smooth purchasing journey and find that the extensive catalog offers competitive prices for exceptionally well crafted merchandise. People consistently highlight the outstanding build quality and superb overall value provided by these timepieces and accessories.
Some reviewers were not happy with certain minor aspects, specifically noting that the watch hands feature disappointing lume or lack sufficient brightness in dark conditions. Others also pointed out minor product quirks, such as bezel tension or component details that could be refined.
Auto-generated from all reviews of this business. For reference only.
Ordering from Island Watch was a great experience. I received my order earlier than expected, and communication from Island Watch was excellent. I ordered a bracelet for my Marathon TSAR. The bracelet from Marathon is $550 and has a simple fold-over stamped clasp with no OTF adjustment. Island Watch's bracelet for the TSAR/GSAR is really comfortable, matches the watch perfectly, has OTF adjustment, a milled clasp, and only costs $150. I feel like I got a really bracelet and saved a ton of money.
My order for the bracelet for my Bulova Lunar Pilot was processed and shipped promptly. The bracelet arrived in perfect condition. I am very pleased with my transaction.
Great bracelet for my promaster. Saw Mark showing it on his YouTube channel and it did not disappoint. Quick and efficient delivery over the pond to the UK. Many thanks 🙏.
This is the best online watch store. Nice and interesting selection. I've bought many items from Long Island Watch and never had an issue. This is a store you can trust plus their YouTube channel can teach you a lot about watches.
I have done a lot of business with Long Island Watch company over the years and it always a wonderful experience. Their selection of fantastic watches and accessories is marvelous. Very competitive prices and lightning fast shipping. I am a Customer for life !!!
Thank you Marc and your entire staff for doing what you do for the Watch community.
Had a great transaction and experience. I had a minor issue with the purchase. The communication was excellent and they resolved the issue in a timely and more than fair manner. Highly recommend and I will buy from them again.
Long Island Watch has an excellent selection of watches and watch accessories at competitive prices. The replacement bracelet (BRAC-105) for my Lunar Pilot is a game changer. Customer service is top notch. My next watch will be from Long Island Watch!
The service is always great. Thank you!
This Squale 1545 Grey is gorgeous. I know they make a lot of beautifully polished cases but I'm highly biased toward this kind of brushed finish and the execution on this is flawless. Overall I'm very happy with this purchase.
Jomashop
Mint & Lily
Pagani Design Official Store®
myGemma
MYKA
The Art Of Jewels
Factory Direct Jewelry
Wolf & Badger