Island Watch (longislandwatch.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 104 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 97% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has not yet replied to negative reviews; Reviews mostly discuss Product, Quality, Price. Last updated 2026-08-12.
Reviewers overwhelmingly had a great experience with this company. Customers frequently share that their purchases arrive remarkably fast, often beating the expected delivery schedule while remaining securely packaged. Buyers deeply appreciate the smooth purchasing journey and find that the extensive catalog offers competitive prices for exceptionally well crafted merchandise. People consistently highlight the outstanding build quality and superb overall value provided by these timepieces and accessories. Some reviewers were not happy with certain minor aspects, specifically noting that the watch hands feature disappointing lume or lack sufficient brightness in dark conditions. Others also pointed out minor product quirks, such as bezel tension or component details that could be refined.
Auto-generated from all reviews of this business. For reference only.I got a great deal on a Damasko model I've been after for years. More importantly, customer service at LIW is always top notch. I've had two experiences with special shipping requests - first, when I needed something quickly due to upcoming travel; second, when I needed shipping delayed a few days while away from home. Marc and Co. made sure my needs were met both times. I have the utmost confidence dealing with this business.
Good quality. Perfectly fit with my watch. Quick delivery. Love it! Thanks.
Received 1 day earlier than projected by LIW and the watch itself is exactly as described by the website. Really a nice watch that I find the watch face extremely useful for my needs.
Shipping was 4 days faster than originally quoted. Watch is amazing!! Customer service and quality of the product has exceeded my expectations!
Exactly what I needed to fix my watch. Shipping was fast as well! Thank you!!
Fast service. A+++
Great watch. Excellent service.
I received the BRAC-71 steel bracelet I ordered from Long Island Watch after 1.5 weeks in Germany, and I am very impressed with the quality and value for money of this fantastic steel bracelet. I would definitely order again!
Repeat customer. Great deals fast shipping. Will buy from again.
The watch I received looks fantastic and came at a very good price.
Having delt with the company in the past they continue to deliver excellent service for a incredible price
I want to say I have purchased two watches in the last couple weeks from Long Island. I wanna say that their communication is fantastic. Shipping was fantastic. Watches came as advertised. No issues really impressed with the communication and the fact that they shipped my stuff so quick. I sent an email asking when it would ship in before you knew it two days later I had it in my hand really appreciate the effort thank you so much. Look forward to doing business again.
Fast Delivery. Beautiful watch>
Prompt shipping. Love the watch
The front-facing marketing from Long Island Watch Company isn't impersonal or generic, which a lot of businesses on the same scale tend to provide. Marc is a great mascot for his own business, and produces fantastic video and other marketing material. The selection of product is also able to satisfy a wide audience, which is legitimately difficult for something with as many options as the watch realm. The in-house designs are unique enough to be their own ideas, rather than a re-hash on another design, or just a basic homage.
beautiful bracelet, shipping was reasonable, fits watch perfectly
Great looking watch! Super pleased… Great communication, wonderful quality and fast shipping.
Amazing service. Watch is a great deal and super quality collaboration from Islander x Phoibos
Amazing watches. Great prices. Fast shipping. What more can you ask for
104 reviews matching
Jomashop
Mint & Lily
Pagani Design Official Store®
myGemma
MYKA
The Art Of Jewels
Factory Direct Jewelry
Wolf & Badger