Island Watch (longislandwatch.com) has a 4.9 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 104 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Shopping & Fashion and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 97% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has not yet replied to negative reviews; Reviews mostly discuss Product, Quality, Price. Last updated 2026-08-12.
What reviewers say
AI generated
Reviewers overwhelmingly had a great experience with this company. Customers frequently share that their purchases arrive remarkably fast, often beating the expected delivery schedule while remaining securely packaged. Buyers deeply appreciate the smooth purchasing journey and find that the extensive catalog offers competitive prices for exceptionally well crafted merchandise. People consistently highlight the outstanding build quality and superb overall value provided by these timepieces and accessories.
Some reviewers were not happy with certain minor aspects, specifically noting that the watch hands feature disappointing lume or lack sufficient brightness in dark conditions. Others also pointed out minor product quirks, such as bezel tension or component details that could be refined.
Auto-generated from all reviews of this business. For reference only.
Here's something you could post that reflects your experience:
I don't normally write reviews, but this watch earned one.
I purchased the Islander JFK GMT, and it has completely changed my perspective on what an affordable watch can be.
The finishing is excellent, the cloud dial is beautiful without being flashy, and the GMT functionality is incredibly intuitive. The bidirectional 24-hour bezel makes tracking multiple time zones effortless, and everything operates with a level of thoughtfulness that makes the watch a joy to use.
What surprised me most is how it wears. It has a reassuring weight when you first put it on, but after a few minutes it completely disappears on the wrist. It's one of the most comfortable watches I've owned.
This watch has made me question the assumption that you need to spend thousands of dollars to experience exceptional design and craftsmanship. It's clear that a lot of care went into every detail.
On top of that, the buying experience from Island Watch was outstanding. Fast shipping, great communication, and it's obvious the company is run by people who genuinely love watches.
Highly recommended.
Ordered a black leather strap for my watch. The company sent a blue one. The told me they don’t carry a blue one, even though that’s what they sent me. I told them they may want to check their supplier as I found the suppliers blue one online, which is identical to the one they sent me. Now, they would like me to pay to ship it back to them for a return. This is almost laughable how bad this is. I would expect this from temu or something, but not a company like this. Truly disappointing.
Bracelet for my SRPL15 fits amazing and is really nice. Like really really nice. Like I can't emphasize enough, the quality of this bracelet is top tier. I am quite happy, and will be back for other purchases.
Amazing bracelet! Nice and easy to install on my Casio MDV-107. Feels really high quality and looks great. It also only took 10 days to arrive despite me being in the UK.
It appears that I was shipped a previously used watch - or unboxed at the minimum. The protective plastic on new Seiko watches was removed then kinda stuck back in the box haphazardly. I don't know if the watch was worn and then just put back in the box or what the deal was. Kinda disappointing to pay full price and receive it that way.
Marc and the Long Island Watch Team makes a great aftermarket bracelet. They're professionalism, attention to detail and customer service are GOLD standard. I would highly recommend Marc and the LIW team to family and friends. Thank you!
USPS Ground Advantage is getting crappy for some reason. Finally got watch after 2 weeks. Not Islander's fault.
Got this IW-343 on sale for kind of a beater. Might be a little too nice for that.
This is a great replacement bracelet for my Orient. It fits nice and tight between the lugs and it really comfortable thanks to the fully articulating links.
Jomashop
Mint & Lily
Pagani Design Official Store®
myGemma
MYKA
The Art Of Jewels
Factory Direct Jewelry
Wolf & Badger