Worthy empowers people to turn life transitions into opportunities by providing a smart and safe way to sell their jewelry. Worthy is an online marketplace for sellers looking to sell their pre-owned diamond, diamond jewelry, luxury watches, estate and heirloom jewelry. Sell Your Jewelry Explore Jewelry Value Worthy is centered around the goal to help people maximize the value of their jewelry when they are ready to sell. Common items for sale include engagement rings, diamond necklaces, diamond tennis bracelets and other statement jewelry pieces. Worthy provides services that help people sell their jewelry. Worthy works with partners such as Lloyd’s of London for insurance coverage, GIA for diamond grading reports, FedEx for shipping, to name a few of our business partners. Worthy is providing a new way to auction important jewelry.
Written by the business, not verified by us.
Is Worthy legit?
Worthy (worthy.com) has a 4.5 out of 5 rating on OK.one, based on 168 user reviews collected here. It is listed under Home & Garden and its reputation is excellent. Praise is nearly unanimous, with 91% rating it 4 stars or higher; The business has replied to 100% of negative reviews; Reviews mostly discuss Customer service, Product, User experience. Last updated 2026-09-03.
What reviewers say
AI generated
Reviewers overwhelmingly had a great experience with this company. Customers frequently praise the supportive and helpful customer service team throughout the entire process, noting that communication is consistently prompt and reassuring from start to finish. People also mention that the online auction method is secure, highly straightforward, and makes selling valuable jewelry through the mail remarkably easy.
Though some customers noted concerns regarding lower than expected final offers and limited communication after their items were successfully sold. Some reviewers occasionally experienced frustrating delays or perceived the valuation process as somewhat misleading due to substantial platform fees and disappointing initial bids.
Auto-generated from all reviews of this business. For reference only.
First I checked the website to be legitament. It was, so i contacted them. The process was easy. My item sold and recieved a very fair price. Payment was sent within a week or so to me directly.
I highly recommend.
Reply from Worthy2026-09-02
Dear Emmy,
We are so glad to hear that you found our process easy. It's wonderful to know that you received a fair price for your item and that payment was sent promptly. We truly appreciate your high recommendation!
Best Regards,
The Worthy Team
Had a local jeweler give me a price and I thought Worthy was a good way to get more . The appraisal was 8300 and I set it at $8500 which my local jeweler was $8000 . Best bid was $7350 and 14 business days later still no deposit. Whole process took over a month.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-31
Dear Doug,
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We understand how important it is to receive both a strong sale result and timely payment.
Worthy's auction process is designed to be risk-free for sellers. You have the ability to set your own reserve price, and if that reserve is not met, you can choose to have your item returned if you are not satisfied with the highest bid received.
In reviewing your account, we can confirm that your reserve price was not met. However, the highest bid was subsequently accepted on your behalf, allowing the sale to move forward.
We can also confirm that today is the 14th business day since the sale was finalized, and our team is actively working to complete your payment as quickly as possible. One of our senior representatives has already reached out to you directly to provide assistance and updates regarding your transaction.
We appreciate your patience throughout this process and thank you for choosing Worthy.
Best regards,
The Worthy Team
Only thing I would say is show the actual price that you will get minus the fees. The way it’s laid out is a little misleading - it doesn’t say MINUS 18% it just says 18%
So it could be perceived that you’re getting that money in the 18% was already taken out.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-31
Dear Debra,
Thank you for your 5-star review and for sharing this valuable feedback.
We're glad to hear that your overall experience was a positive one.
Your feedback has been shared with our team as we continually look for ways to improve the seller experience.
Thank you again for choosing Worthy and for taking the time to provide thoughtful feedback
Best regards,
The Worthy Team
Excellent customer service and a good step by step process that helped me with any issues of trust.Also, good reviews by other customers that I found online.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-24
Dear Laneri,
We are so pleased to hear that our customer service and step-by-step process helped build your trust. It's wonderful to know that other customer reviews also contributed to your positive experience.
Warm wishes,
The Worthy Team
Everyone on staff that assisted me with the sale of my watch made the transaction from mail in procedure to sale extremely professional.The only thing I would suggest if payment is delayed past 14 days notify the seller.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-24
Dear Ed,
We're so glad to hear our team provided a professional experience with your watch sale. We appreciate your valuable suggestion regarding payment notifications, and we will certainly consider it as we continuously improve our processes. Thank you for your positive feedback!
Best regards,
The Worthy Team
Worthy couldn't have made me have a better experience! Professional, knowledgeable and kept me up to date every step of the way. My peice sold for more than I thought it would and my payment went smoothly. I highly recommend Worthy
Reply from Worthy2026-08-17
Dear Karen,
We are so delighted to hear that your experience with us was excellent! It's wonderful to know that our team's professionalism and knowledge, along with our consistent updates, contributed to a smooth process and a great sale price. Thank you for your high recommendation!
Warm wishes,
The Worthy Team
Great communication, always on top to respond to my emails, I was out of the country they communicate with me. They’ve been just great.
I highly recommend any time.
1 item I did not want to sell, was mail back, which Insurance couldn’t ask for anything more.thank you so much .
Reply from Worthy2026-08-18
Dear Anna,
We are so happy to hear about your positive experience with our communication and service, especially while you were abroad. We truly appreciate your kind words and recommendation. We are glad we could assist with the item you wished to keep.
Best wishes,
The Worthy Team
Great experience, they ship out a prepaid insured shipping label, you send your item, it goes to auction for a week, 9-14 business days you get paid. Simple, reliable, easy, and honest.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-14
Dear Yameen,
We are so glad to hear that you found our process simple, reliable, easy, and honest! Providing a straightforward and trustworthy experience is always our goal. Thank you for sharing your positive feedback.
Warm regards,
The Worthy Team
I was a little scare at first, but worthy kept an open communication with me and explain the process step baby step. I'm very happy with the experience and how they help me sell my ring.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-10
Dear Kathia,
We're so glad to hear that our clear communication helped you feel comfortable throughout the process. We appreciate your kind words about our team assisting you with selling your ring. Thank you for sharing your positive experience!
Warm regards,
The Worthy Team
Process is very transparent and communication is very good throughout. I think getting paid could be a bit quicker since it’s PayPal based.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-07
Dear Jan,
We're glad to hear our communication and transparency were helpful! We appreciate your feedback regarding payment speed and are always looking for ways to improve our processes.
Warm regards,
The Worthy Team
The communication from your associates was awesome! They helped me through the process and continued communication when my items sold and payment was on the way.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-06
Dear Martha,
We are so happy to hear that our team provided you with excellent communication throughout the entire process. Keeping you informed every step of the way is very important to us. Thank you for sharing your positive experience!
Best wishes,
The Worthy Team
Very easy process from shipping to auction to payment. Thought our ring was with a little more but I guess supply and demand rules
Reply from Worthy2026-08-06
Dear Geoffrey,
We're glad to hear the process was easy for you. We understand your thoughts on the ring's value and appreciate your understanding of market dynamics.
Best regards,
The Worthy Team
After receiving my jewelry, it was prepared & posted quickly. We were pleased with the final bid. Communication via email was responded to in a timely manner.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-06
Dear Carol,
We are so pleased to hear that you had such a positive experience with us, from the quick preparation and posting of your jewelry to our timely communication. We truly appreciate your kind words.
Warm wishes,
The Worthy Team
I appreciated that the person I had the initial Q&A with was the same person I committed with until the auction started. He explained the process well, answered all my questions, and was respectful. The shipping process was quite easy for both the (graded) loose stone and ring, the latter of which ended up getting sent back. I was happy with the price we ended up getting in the auction. The only thing that would’ve made the process better would’ve been the time to receive the payment after it sold — it was within the window they said (7-10 business days), it just would’ve been better if the wait was shorter.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-04
Dear David,
We are so pleased to hear about your positive experience with our team, especially regarding the consistent support you received from the initial Q&A through to the auction. It's wonderful to know that our colleague explained the process thoroughly and respectfully. We are also glad that the shipping for both your loose stone and ring was easy and that you were happy with the final auction price. We appreciate your feedback regarding the payment processing time. We understand that a shorter wait would have been more convenient, and we are always looking for ways to improve our services within the stated windows. Thank you for sharing your valuable insights.
Best wishes,
The Worthy Team
Smooth transaction. Great communication through the entire process.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-04
Dear Wendy,
Thank you so much for your kind review! We're delighted to hear that you had a smooth experience and felt well-informed throughout the entire process.
Providing clear communication and making the selling experience as seamless as possible are priorities for our team, so it's wonderful to know we met your expectations. We truly appreciate you choosing Worthy and trusting us with your jewelry. Thank you again for your support, and we wish you all the best!
Warm regards,
The Worthy Team
Thought I’d get a little more than I did for my diamonds.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-03
Dear Gerry,
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We understand that selling jewelry with sentimental and financial value can come with high expectations, and we're sorry to hear the final result wasn't what you had hoped for.
As a resale marketplace, auction results are ultimately determined by current market demand and competitive bidding from our network of professional buyers. While we always strive to help our sellers achieve the strongest possible outcome, resale values can differ significantly from original purchase prices or appraised values.
We truly appreciate the opportunity to have assisted you and thank you for trusting Worthy. We wish you all the best.
Best regards,
The Worthy Team
Dear Lori,
Thank you for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that your experience with Worthy went so smoothly.
Our team is committed to making the selling process as easy, secure, and transparent as possible, so it's great to know we delivered that for you. We truly appreciate you choosing Worthy and taking the time to share your experience. Thank you again for your support, and we wish you all the best!
Warm wishes,
The Worthy Team
Very Helpful but didn't get the price I was looking for.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-04
Dear Roma,
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We're glad to hear that you found our team helpful throughout the process.
We understand that it can be disappointing when an offer doesn't meet your expectations. As a resale marketplace, auction results are ultimately determined by current market demand and competitive bidding from our network of professional buyers, which can differ from original purchase prices or appraised values.
We truly appreciate you giving Worthy the opportunity to assist you and hope you'll consider us again in the future. Wishing you all the best, and thank you again for your review!
Best regards,
The Worthy Team
I recently sold my late parents’ jewelry through Worthy, including my mother’s diamond ring and my father’s watch. Because these pieces had tremendous sentimental value, trusting them to a company I’d never worked with was a difficult decision.
I will admit that the waiting period for payment made me nervous. My payment was processed at the very end of the stated 9–14 business day window, and when you’re sending away family heirlooms, those extra days can feel like forever.
That said, Worthy delivered exactly as promised. The auction process was transparent, the communication from the support team was professional and courteous, and the payment arrived safely in my bank account. The prices my items brought exceeded my expectations, and I felt the entire process was handled with integrity.
A special thank you to the customer support team, especially Amber and Christine, who patiently answered my questions and kept me updated throughout the process.
In the end, I would absolutely use Worthy again and would recommend them to anyone looking to sell fine jewelry they no longer wear. Sending away treasured family pieces requires a great deal of trust, and Worthy earned mine.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Reply from Worthy2026-08-03
Dear Dharma,
Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience and for placing your trust in Worthy during such a meaningful and emotional process.
We understand that parting with family heirlooms is never easy, and we truly appreciate your patience throughout the payment process. While your payment was completed within our stated 9–14 business day timeframe, we understand that the wait can feel much longer when cherished pieces with so much sentimental value are involved.
We're delighted to hear that the auction exceeded your expectations and that you found our process transparent and our communication helpful. Your kind words about Amber and Christine mean a great deal, and we will be sure to share your recognition with them.
Thank you again for your recommendation and for allowing us to help your family's treasured pieces find a new home. We wish you all the very best, and if we can ever assist you again in the future, we'll be honored to do so.
Best wishes,
The Worthy Team
I was extremely satisfied with every step of the process. Rachel Kass answered all my questions and the best part is the stone sold for 40% higher than my asking price!
Other companies had offered far less than my asking price.
Reply from Worthy2026-08-03
Hello!
We're so happy to hear about your positive experience with us! It's wonderful that we could exceed your expectations and achieve such a favorable outcome for your stone. We truly appreciate you sharing your feedback.
Warm regards,
The Worthy Team
Worthyalways
myGemma
Sell Your Gold
AuctionNinja
CIRCA
Wolf & Badger
Express Gold Cash
JAXXON